Appendix A-2 EVALUATING STUDENT NEED FOR DEVELOPMENTAL OR REMEDIAL CO

National Assessment Governing Board WASHINGTON, D.C. 20002 EVALUATING STUDENT NEED FOR DEVELOPMENTAL OR REMEDIAL COURSES AT POSTSECONDARY EDUCATION INSTITUTIONS

FORM APPROVED O.M.B. No.: EXPIRATION DATE:

Please respond for the institution that matches the IPEDS ID number printed on the label below. If the information for the institution shown is incorrect, please update directly on the label before returning the survey questionnaire.

OMB DRAFT 6-17-10

VERSION FOR FOUR-YEAR INSTITUTIONS

Appendix A-2

LABEL WITH IPEDS ID HERE

This survey can be completed online at www.nagb-survey.org. We encourage you to complete the survey online if possible. You will need the User ID and Password listed on the attached cover letter to log in to the website. Please contact Liam Ristow at [email protected], 1-800-937-8281, Ext. 2456 (toll free) or 240-314-2456 if you do not have your User ID or Password.

If you prefer, you may complete this paper version. If you complete the paper version, please provide the following information, keep a copy of the completed questionnaire for your files, and return the original to Westat at the address shown below. We have enclosed a postage-paid envelope for your convenience. You may also fax a copy of the completed questionnaire to 1-800-254-0984 (Attn: Liam Ristow).

Name:

Title/position:

Telephone number: E-mail:

Indicate the number of minutes it took to complete this questionnaire in the space below. Include time to review instructions, search existing records, and gather the information needed to complete the questionnaire.

Number of minutes: _______________

Thank you. Please keep a copy of the survey for your records.

Please see page 7 for a list of Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs) regarding the purpose of this study.

PLEASE RETURN COMPLETED FORM TO: IF YOU HAVE ANY QUESTIONS OR COMMENTS, CONTACT:

Mail: Liam Ristow (8756.05.03) Liam Ristow at Westat

Westat 1-800-937-8281, Ext. 2456 or 240-314-2456

1600 Research Boulevard E-mail: [email protected]
Rockville, Maryland 20850-3195

Fax: 1-800-254-0984

According to the Paperwork Reduction Act of 1995, no persons are required to respond to a collection of information unless it displays a valid OMB control number. The valid OMB control number for this information collection is xxxx-xxxx. The time required to complete this information collection is estimated to average 45 minutes per response, including the time to review instructions, search existing data resources, gather the data needed, and complete and review the information collection. If you have any comments concerning the accuracy of the time estimate or suggestions for improving this form, OR if you have any comments or concerns regarding the status of your individual submission of this form, please write directly to National Assessment Governing Board, 800 North Capitol Street, NW, Washington, DC 20002.

Survey Overview and Instructions

This survey examines the test scores used by postsecondary institutions to evaluate whether entering students are academically prepared or in need of developmental or remedial courses in mathematics or reading. The goal of the survey is to identify the test scores below which students are deemed in need of developmental or remedial courses (i.e., academically unprepared for entry-level courses). The scores may come from a variety of tests, including:

• Admissions tests such as the ACT or SAT;

• Placement tests such as ACCUPLACER, ASSET, and COMPASS; or

• Institution- or state-developed tests.

Please report based on the tests your institution uses to evaluate entering students who are enrolled in an undergraduate degree program in the liberal arts and sciences.

Answer all relevant sections, even if your institution does not offer developmental or remedial courses or offers only one or two such courses. Use data from your institutional records whenever possible. If exact data are not available, then give your best estimate.

Definitions

Developmental or remedial courses are generally designed to improve the skills of entering students who are not academically prepared for entry-level college courses, as determined by your institution. This survey focuses on developmental or remedial courses that address skills in mathematics and reading. Developmental or remedial writing courses should not be considered unless they have a substantial focus on improving reading skills.

Please note:

• In most cases, developmental or remedial courses are not credit-bearing and they do not count toward general education or degree requirements.

• Your institution may use other names such as “preparatory,” "compensatory," or "basic skills" or some other term to refer to developmental or remedial courses.

Entry-level college courses refer to first-year credit-bearing courses that require college-level mathematics or reading skills, as these skills are defined by your institution. Entry-level college courses typically count toward general education or degree requirements. Please note that a variety of entry-level courses may require college-level mathematics or reading skills, including entry-level humanities, mathematics, and science courses.

Entering students include full-time and part-time students who are new to your institution and are subject to your institution’s policy for determining need for developmental or remedial courses.

Directions: If your institution did not have any entering students in fall 2009 who were enrolled in an undergraduate degree program in the liberal arts and sciences, please check this box , complete the cover page, and return the questionnaire.

Section A. Evaluating Need for Developmental or Remedial Mathematics Courses

1. In fall 2009, did your institution use ACT, SAT, or placement tests (i.e., ACCUPLACER, ASSET, COMPASS, or other tests developed by your institution or state) to evaluate whether entering students were in need of developmental or remedial mathematics courses (i.e., not academically prepared for entry-level courses that require college mathematics skills)?

• Consider tests used to evaluate entering students who were enrolled in an undergraduate degree program in the liberal arts and sciences.

• Consider any use of ACT, SAT, or placement test scores to determine the need for remediation, even if your institution does not offer developmental or remedial mathematics courses or offers only one or two such courses.

Yes 1 (Continue with question 2.)

No 2 (Skip to question 3.)

2. In Column B, please check the box for each ACT, SAT, or placement test that your institution used in fall 2009 to evaluate whether entering students were in need of developmental or remedial mathematics courses. In Column C, for each test used, write the score below which students were identified as in need of developmental or remedial mathematics courses.

• If different scores were used for either requiring or recommending developmental or remedial mathematics courses, report the highest score used.

• If different scores were used to identify students for different levels of developmental or remedial mathematics courses, report the score used for the highest level of remedial mathematics course.

A. ACT, SAT, or placement test (Score ranges shown in parentheses)	B. Test used to evaluate entering students	C. Score below which developmental or remedial mathematics courses were needed
ACT Subject Tests
a. Mathematics (1-36)		________
b. Science (1-36)		________
c. Composite score (1-36)		________
SAT Reasoning Test
d. Mathematics (200-800)		________
e. SAT total score including Writing (600-2400)		________
f. SAT total score excluding Writing (400-1600)		________
ACCUPLACER
g. Arithmetic (20-120)		________
h. Elementary Algebra (20-120)		________
i. College-Level Mathematics (20-120)		________
ASSET
j. Numerical Skills (23-55)		________
k. Elementary Algebra (23-55)		________
l. Intermediate Algebra (23-55)		________
m. College Algebra (23-55)		________
n. Geometry (23-55)		________
COMPASS
o. Pre-Algebra placement domain (1-99)		________
p. Algebra placement domain (1-99)		________
q. College Algebra placement domain (1-99)		________
r. Geometry placement domain (1-99)		________
s. Trigonometry placement domain (1-99)		________
Other mathematics placement tests
t. Other test 1 (specify):		Not applicable.
u. Other test 2 (specify):
v. Other test 3 (specify):

Please provide any comments about your response to question 2.

3. In fall 2009, did your institution use any criteria other than ACT/SAT tests or placement tests to evaluate whether entering students were in need of developmental or remedial mathematics courses (i.e., not academically prepared for entry-level courses that require college mathematics skills)?

• Consider other criteria such as high school graduation or end-of-course exams, high school records, Advanced Placement (AP) or International Baccalaureate (IB) test scores, or faculty recommendations.

Yes 1 (Continue with question 4.)

No 2 (Skip to question 5.)

4. Please check the box for each criterion that your institution used in fall 2009 to evaluate whether entering students were in need of developmental or remedial mathematics courses (i.e., not academically prepared for entry-level courses that require college mathematics skills).

Criterion	Used to evaluate entering students
a. High school graduation tests or end-of-course tests
b. High school grades (including grade point average)
c. Highest high school mathematics course completed
d. Advanced Placement (AP) or International Baccalaureate (IB) test scores
e. Faculty recommendation
f. Other (specify)

Please provide any comments about your response to question 4.

Section B. Evaluating Need for Developmental or Remedial Reading Courses

Please note: Developmental or remedial writing courses should not be considered reading courses unless they have a substantial focus on improving reading skills.

5. In fall 2009, did your institution use ACT, SAT, or placement tests (i.e., ACCUPLACER, ASSET, COMPASS, or other tests developed by your institution or state) to evaluate whether entering students were in need of developmental or remedial reading courses (i.e., not academically prepared for entry-level courses that require college reading skills)?

• Consider tests used to evaluate entering students who were enrolled in an undergraduate degree program in the liberal arts and sciences.

• Consider any use of ACT, SAT, or placement test scores to determine the need for remediation, even if your institution does not offer developmental or remedial reading courses or offers only one or two such courses.

Yes 1 (Continue with question 6.)

No 2 (Skip to question 7.)

6. In Column B, please check the box for each ACT, SAT, or placement test that your institution used in fall 2009 to evaluate whether entering students were in need of developmental or remedial reading courses. In Column C, for each test used, write the score below which students were identified as in need of developmental or remedial reading courses.

• If different scores were used for either requiring or recommending developmental or remedial reading courses, report the highest score used.

• If different scores were used to identify students for different levels of developmental or remedial reading courses, report the score used for the highest level of remedial reading course.

A. ACT, SAT, or placement test (Score ranges shown in parentheses)	B. Test used to evaluate entering students		C. Score below which developmental or remedial reading courses were needed
ACT Subject Tests
a. Reading (1-36)			________
b. English (1-36)			________
c. Writing (1-36)			________
d. Composite score (1-36)			________
SAT Reasoning Test
e. Critical Reading (200-800)			________
f. Writing (200-800)			________
g. SAT total score including Writing (600-2400)			________
h. SAT total score excluding Writing (400-1600)			________
ACCUPLACER
i. Reading Comprehension (20-120)			________
j. Sentence Skills (20-120)			________
k. WritePlacer (1-8)			________
ASSET
l. Reading Skills (23-55)			________
m. Writing Skills (23-55)			________
COMPASS
n. Reading placement domain (1-99)			________
o. Writing Skills placement domain (1-99)			________
p. Writing e-Write placement domain (2-8)			________
q. Writing e-Write placement domain (2-12)			________
Nelson-Denny Reading Test r. Nelson-Denny Reading test (0-172)			________
Other reading placement tests
s. Other test 1 (specify):			Not applicable.
t. Other test 2 (specify):
u. Other test 3 (specify):

Please provide any comments about your response to question 6.

7. In fall 2009, did your institution use any criteria other than ACT/SAT tests or placement tests to evaluate whether entering students were in need of developmental or remedial reading courses (i.e., not academically prepared for entry-level courses that require college reading skills)?

• Consider other criteria such as high school graduation or end-of-course exams, high school records, Advanced Placement (AP) or International Baccalaureate (IB) test scores, or faculty recommendations.

Yes 1 (Continue with question 8.)

No 2 (Stop. Complete cover page and return questionnaire.)

8. Please check the box for each criterion that your institution used in fall 2009 to evaluate whether entering students were in need of developmental or remedial reading courses (i.e., not academically prepared for entry-level courses that require college reading skills).

Criterion	Used to evaluate entering students
a. High school graduation tests or end-of-course tests
b. High school grades (including grade point average)
c. Highest high school English course completed
d. Advanced Placement (AP) or International Baccalaureate (IB) test scores
e. Faculty recommendation
f. Other (specify)

Please provide any comments about your response to question 8.

Thank you for completing the survey. Please remember to fill in the information on the cover page (name, contact information, and time needed to complete the survey) before returning the questionnaire.

FREQUENTLY ASKED QUESTIONS

Why is this survey important?

The academic preparedness of entering students for entry-level courses is a major concern for many higher education institutions. This survey will provide the only source of nationally representative data about the tests and cut-scores used by two-year and four-year institutions to determine student need for remediation in mathematics and reading. Thus, your institution’s participation will help address a knowledge gap on this vital issue.

Why was my institution selected? Do I have to do this?

Your institution was randomly chosen to participate in this study. Your institution’s participation is voluntary, and there is no penalty if you choose not to answer any or all questions in this survey. Your institution’s participation is very important for the success of the study because the answers you provide will be used to represent other institutions similar to yours.

Who is the sponsor of this survey?

The National Assessment Governing Board is the sponsor of this survey. The Governing Board was established by Congress in 1988 to oversee and set policy for the National Assessment of Educational Progress (NAEP), also known as the Nation’s Report Card. NAEP reports regularly to the public on the academic achievement of 4th, 8th and 12th grade students in reading, writing, mathematics, science, and other subjects, such U.S. history, civics, geography, economics, and the arts. For more information about NAEP, go to http://nces.ed.gov/nationsreportcard.

Will responses from my institution be kept confidential?

Data for all participating institutions will be kept confidential. Only aggregate results will be reported; that is, the information provided by your institution will be combined with other participating institutions to produce statistical summaries and reports.

How will the information my institution provides be used?

Your institution’s answers will be used only for statistical purposes and will not be disclosed, or used, in identifiable form for any other purpose. A copy of the results of this study will be sent to all participating institutions.

The National Assessment Governing Board has undertaken a program of research to enable NAEP to report on the academic preparedness of 12th grade students for placement into entry-level credit-bearing college courses. The program of research involves almost 20 studies, of which this survey is one part. The collective results of all of the research studies will be used by the Governing Board to construct and support valid statements about 12th grade academic preparedness in reading and mathematics.

Who is conducting the survey?

Westat is conducting this survey under contract to the National Assessment Governing Board. Westat is a research company located in Rockville, Maryland.

How much time will it take to complete the survey?

The survey is designed to be completed in 45 minutes or less, including the time for reviewing instructions and completing and reviewing the collection of information.

Whom do I contact if I have questions?

For questions about the survey instructions or survey items, please contact Liam Ristow, the Westat survey manager, at 1-800-937-8281, ext. 2456 (toll-free) or 240-314-2456, or by e-mail at [email protected].

For questions about the National Assessment Governing Board and its research program, please contact Ray Fields, Assistant Director for Policy and Research, National Assessment Governing Board, at 202-357-0395, or by e-mail at [email protected].

1