Rationale for Items Added to or Removed From the ExPECTT Youth Follow-up Instrument
Item Number |
Description |
Addition |
Deletion |
Edit |
Rationale |
Prior Approval Given by OMB |
A1 |
Age |
X |
|
|
Added demographic items for the purpose of ascertaining that we have the correct respondent |
Baseline Survey |
A2 |
Gender |
X |
|
|
Added demographic items for the purpose of ascertaining that we have the correct respondent |
Baseline Survey |
A3 |
Ethnicity |
X |
|
|
Added demographic items for the purpose of ascertaining that we have the correct respondent |
Baseline Survey |
A4 |
Race |
X |
|
|
Added demographic items for the purpose of ascertaining that we have the correct respondent |
Baseline Survey |
A7 |
Grade |
X |
|
|
Added demographic items for the purpose of ascertaining that we have the correct respondent |
Baseline Survey |
B6 |
About how many cigarettes have you smoked in your entire life? |
X |
|
|
Need this item to define experimental smoking |
Baseline Survey |
B13 |
Have you ever tried smoking tobacco out of a water pipe (also called “hookah”), even one time? |
|
X |
|
Redundant |
NA |
B14 |
During the past 30 days, on how many days did you smoke tobacco out of a water pipe (also called “hookah”)? |
|
X |
|
Redundant |
Na |
B15 |
These are examples of electronic cigarettes, often called “e-cigarettes”, “e-cigs”, “vapor pens”, or “e-hookahs”. E-cigarettes sometimes look like regular cigarettes, but run on a battery and produce vapor instead of smoke. Have you ever tried electronic cigarettes, such as blu, NJOY, or Mistic, 21st Century Smoke, even one timeor two puffs? |
|
|
X |
Updated item to reflect new understanding of how youth refer to e-cigarettes |
No |
B16 |
During the past 30 days, on how many days did you use electronic cigarettes, e-cigarettes “vapor pens”, or “e-hookahs”? |
|
|
X |
Updated item to reflect new understanding of how youth refer to e-cigarettes |
No |
C1_3 |
Do you think you will be smoking cigarettes every day, one year from now? |
|
X |
|
Analysis indicates that these items do not add anything over and above more established items |
NA |
C1_4 |
Do you think you will be smoking cigarettes, but not every day, one year from now? |
|
X |
|
Analysis indicates that these items do not add anything over and above more established items |
NA |
C1_7 |
Do you think you will use smokeless tobacco at any time in the next year?
|
|
|
X |
Removed product descriptions |
NA |
C1_8 |
If one of your best friends were to offer you smokeless tobacco would you use it? |
|
|
X |
Removed product descriptions |
NA |
C1_10 |
Do you think you will try cigars, cigarillos, or little cigars at any time in the next year? |
|
|
X |
Removed product descriptions |
NA |
C1_12 |
Do you think you will try e-cigarettes, e-cigs, vapor pens, or e-hookahs such as blu, NJOY, Mistic, 21st Century Smoke soon? |
X |
|
|
Added to capture additional data on unintended consequences of the campaign on other tobacco products. |
These are identical to items approved for the baseline survey, with the exception of the product description, which is new to OMB. |
C1_13 |
Do you think you will try e-cigarettes, e-cigs, vapor pens, or e-hookahs such as blu, NJOY, Mistic, 21st Century Smoke at any time in the next year? |
X |
|
|
Added to capture additional data on unintended consequences of the campaign on other tobacco products. |
These are identical to items approved for the baseline survey, with the exception of the product description, which is new to OMB. |
C1_14 |
If one of your best friends were to offer you a e-cigarettes, e-cigs, vapor pens, or e-hookahs such as blu, NJOY, Mistic, 21st Century Smoke would you smoke it? |
X |
|
|
Added to capture additional data on unintended consequences of the campaign on other tobacco products. |
These are identical to items approved for the baseline survey, with the exception of the product description, which is new to OMB. |
D2 |
During the past [FILL DATE SINCE LAST INTERVIEW]3 months, did you stop smoking cigarettes for one day or longer because you were trying to quit smoking cigarettes for good? |
|
|
X |
Changed placement within survey –ITEM ITSELF HAS NOT CHANGED |
NA |
D5 |
During the past [FILL DATE SINCE LAST INTERVIEW]3 months, did you stop using smokeless tobacco such as chewing tobacco, snuff or dip for one day or longer because you were trying to quit using smokeless tobacco for good? |
|
|
X |
Changed placement within survey –ITEM ITSELF HAS NOT CHANGED |
NA |
D6 |
How much do you want to stop using smokeless tobacco ? |
|
|
X |
Removed product descriptions |
NA |
E4_6 |
How much do you agree or disagree with the following statements? If I use smokeless tobacco, snuff or dip, I will… Develop sexual and/or fertility problems |
|
X |
|
|
|
E4_7 |
…lose my taste buds |
|
X |
|
Dropping because smokeless media is not airing at this time |
NA |
E4_14 |
…shorten my life |
|
X |
|
Dropping because smokeless media is not airing at this time |
NA |
E4_15 |
…develop a smokeless tobacco related disease |
|
X |
|
Dropping because smokeless media is not airing at this time |
NA |
E4_16 |
…have bad breath |
|
X |
|
Dropping because smokeless media is not airing at this time |
NA |
E4_17 |
…get sick more often |
|
X |
|
Dropping because smokeless media is not airing at this time |
NA |
E4_21 |
… be a bad influence on others |
|
X |
|
Dropping because smokeless media is not airing at this time |
NA |
E6_7 |
Using smokeless tobacco is a way to show others you’re not afraid to take risks |
|
X |
|
Dropping because smokeless media is not airing at this time |
NA |
E6_8 |
Smokeless tobacco, such as chewing tobacco, snuff, or dip, is safer to use than cigarettes |
|
X |
|
Dropping because smokeless media is not airing at this time |
NA |
E8_1 |
Do you believe smokeless tobacco such as chewing tobacco, snuff, or dip is related to…. …oral cancer |
|
X |
|
Dropping because smokeless media is not airing at this time |
NA |
E8_2 |
…esophageal cancer |
|
X |
|
Dropping because smokeless media is not airing at this time |
NA |
E8_3 |
…pancreatic cancer |
|
X |
|
Dropping because smokeless media is not airing at this time |
NA |
E8_4 |
…gum disease |
|
X |
|
Dropping because smokeless media is not airing at this time |
NA |
E8_5 |
…tooth loss |
|
X |
|
Dropping because smokeless media is not airing at this time |
NA |
E8_6 |
…red or white patches in the mouth (such as leukoplakia)? |
|
X |
|
Dropping because smokeless media is not airing at this time |
NA |
E10_1 |
Does smokeless tobacco such as chewing tobacco, snuff, or dip contain…. …ammonia, a substance found in fertilizer and household cleaners? |
|
X |
|
Dropping because smokeless media is not airing at this time |
NA |
E10_2 |
…arsenic, a substance found in motor oil? |
|
X |
|
Dropping because smokeless media is not airing at this time |
NA |
E10_3 |
…beryllium, a substance used in nuclear weapons and nuclear power reactors? |
|
X |
|
Dropping because smokeless media is not airing at this time |
NA |
E10_4 |
…cadmium, a substance found in batteries? |
|
X |
|
Dropping because smokeless media is not airing at this time |
NA |
E10_5 |
…formaldehyde, a chemical used to preserve dead animals? |
|
X |
|
Dropping because smokeless media is not airing at this time |
NA |
E10_6 |
…lead, a substance found in bullets? |
|
X |
|
Dropping because smokeless media is not airing at this time |
NA |
E10_7 |
…naphthalene, a chemical found in mothballs? |
|
X |
|
Dropping because smokeless media is not airing at this time |
NA |
E10_8 |
…polonium 210, a poison? |
|
X |
|
Dropping because smokeless media is not airing at this time |
NA |
E10_9 |
…uranium, a substance used in nuclear weapons and nuclear power reactors? |
|
X |
|
Dropping because smokeless media is not airing at this time |
NA |
E10_1 through E10_9 |
Nine smokeless items measuring knowledge of ingredients in smokeless tobacco |
|
X |
|
Dropping because smokeless media is not airing at this time |
NA |
E13_1 |
Smoking cigars, cigarillos, or little cigars is… bad-good |
X |
|
|
Added to capture additional data on unintended consequences of the campaign on other tobacco products. |
These are identical to items approved for the baseline survey, with the exception of the product type.
|
E13_2 |
Smoking cigars, cigarillos, or little cigars is… unenjoyable-enjoyable |
X |
|
|
Added to capture additional data on unintended consequences of the campaign on other tobacco products. |
These are identical to items approved for the baseline survey, with the exception of the product type. |
E14_1 |
Using e-cigarettes, e-cigs, vapor pens, or e-hookahs is… bad-good |
X |
|
|
Added to capture additional data on unintended consequences of the campaign on other tobacco products. |
These are identical to items approved for the baseline survey, with the exception of the product type |
E14_2 |
Using e-cigarettes, e-cigs, vapor pens, or e-hookahs is… unenjoyable-enjoyable |
X |
|
|
Added to capture additional data on unintended consequences of the campaign on other tobacco products. |
These are identical to items approved for the baseline survey, with the exception of the product type. |
E3_13 |
How much do you agree or disagree with the following statements? If I smoke cigarettes I will…Have COPD |
|
|
X |
Changed “trouble breathing” to “COPD” to reflect campaign messaging |
Not previously approved. |
E4_15 |
How much do you agree or disagree with the following statements? If I use smokeless tobacco, snuff or dip, I will…develop a smokeless tobacco-related disease |
|
|
X |
Added the word “smokeless” to clarify that this item does not refer to cigarettes. |
Not previously approved. |
E11_4. |
How many of your four closest friends…Use cigars, cigarillos, or little cigars such as Swisher Sweets, Black & Mild, White Owl, Cheyenne, Dutch Masters, Garcia Y Vega or Middleton’s? |
X |
|
|
Added to capture additional data on unintended consequences of the campaign on other tobacco products. |
These are identical to items approved for the baseline survey, with the exception of the product type. |
E11_5. |
How many of your four closest friends…Use e-cigarettes, e-cigs, vapor pens, or e-hookahs such as blu, NJOY, Mistic, 21st Century Smoke? |
X |
|
|
Added to capture additional data on unintended consequences of the campaign on other tobacco products. |
These are identical to items approved for the baseline survey, with the exception of the product type. |
E12_6 |
E12. How many others your age…use smokeless tobacco but not every day? |
|
|
X |
Removed product descriptions |
NA |
F2_14 |
Thinking about the past [FILL MONTHS], that is since [FILL DATE], how frequently have you watched the following shows? The show Awkward on MTV?
|
X |
|
|
Added in order to develop a measure of individualized potential campaign exposure based on the actual campaign media buy. |
Not previously approved. |
F2_15 |
The show Catfish on MTV? |
X |
|
|
Added in order to develop a measure of individualized potential campaign exposure based on the actual campaign media buy. |
Not previously approved. |
F2_16 |
The show Teen Wolf on MTV? |
X |
|
|
Added in order to develop a measure of individualized potential campaign exposure based on the actual campaign media buy. |
Not previously approved. |
F2_17 |
The show Real World on MTV? |
X |
|
|
Added in order to develop a measure of individualized potential campaign exposure based on the actual campaign media buy. |
Not previously approved. |
F2_18 |
The show Pretty Little Liars on ABC Family? |
X |
|
|
Added in order to develop a measure of individualized potential campaign exposure based on the actual campaign media buy. |
Not previously approved. |
F2_19 |
The show The Fosters on ABC Family? |
X |
|
|
Added in order to develop a measure of individualized potential campaign exposure based on the actual campaign media buy. |
Not previously approved. |
F2_20 |
The show Twisted on ABC Family? |
X |
|
|
Added in order to develop a measure of individualized potential campaign exposure based on the actual campaign media buy. |
Not previously approved. |
F2_21 |
The show Chasing Life on ABC Family? |
X |
|
|
Added in order to develop a measure of individualized potential campaign exposure based on the actual campaign media buy. |
Not previously approved. |
F2_22 |
The show Family Guy on Adult Swim? |
X |
|
|
Added in order to develop a measure of individualized potential campaign exposure based on the actual campaign media buy. |
Not previously approved. |
F2_23 |
The show Robot Chicken on Adult Swim? |
X |
|
|
Added in order to develop a measure of individualized potential campaign exposure based on the actual campaign media buy. |
Not previously approved. |
F2_24 |
The show American Dad on Adult Swim? |
X |
|
|
Added in order to develop a measure of individualized potential campaign exposure based on the actual campaign media buy. |
Not previously approved. |
F2_25 |
The show The Cleveland Show on Adult Swim? |
X |
|
|
Added in order to develop a measure of individualized potential campaign exposure based on the actual campaign media buy. |
Not previously approved. |
F2_26 |
The show WWE Raw on USA? |
X |
|
|
Added in order to develop a measure of individualized potential campaign exposure based on the actual campaign media buy. |
Not previously approved. |
F2_27 |
The show Tosh.O on Comedy Central? |
X |
|
|
Added in order to develop a measure of individualized potential campaign exposure based on the actual campaign media buy. |
Not previously approved. |
F2_28 |
The show Workaholics on Comedy Central? |
X |
|
|
Added in order to develop a measure of individualized potential campaign exposure based on the actual campaign media buy. |
Not previously approved. |
F2_29 |
The show Kay & Peele on Comedy Central? |
X |
|
|
Added in order to develop a measure of individualized potential campaign exposure based on the actual campaign media buy. |
Not previously approved. |
F2_30 |
The show It’s Always Sunny in Philadelphia on Comedy Central? |
X |
|
|
Added in order to develop a measure of individualized potential campaign exposure based on the actual campaign media buy. |
Not previously approved. |
F2_31 |
In the past [FILL MONTHS], that is since [FILL DATE], how frequently have you been on YouTube or Hulu? |
X |
|
|
Added in order to develop a measure of individualized potential campaign exposure based on the actual campaign media buy. |
Not previously approved. |
F2_32 |
In the past [FILL MONTHS], that is since [FILL DATE], how frequently have you been on Facebook? |
X |
|
|
Added in order to develop a measure of individualized potential campaign exposure based on the actual campaign media buy. |
Not previously approved. |
F2_33 |
In the past [FILL MONTHS], that is since [FILL DATE], how frequently have you been on Twitter? |
X |
|
|
Added in order to develop a measure of individualized potential campaign exposure based on the actual campaign media buy. |
Not previously approved. |
F2_34 |
In the past [FILL MONTHS], that is since [FILL DATE], how frequently have you used Pandora or Spotify? |
X |
|
|
Added in order to develop a measure of individualized potential campaign exposure based on the actual campaign media buy. |
Not previously approved. |
F2_35 |
In the past [FILL MONTHS], that is since [FILL DATE], how frequently have you used PlayStation or Xbox? |
X |
|
|
Added in order to develop a measure of individualized potential campaign exposure based on the actual campaign media buy. |
Not previously approved. |
F3_1 |
In the past [FILL MONTHS],3 months, that is since [FILL DATE], have you seen or heard the following slogan or theme? Healthy Teen |
|
X |
|
This was added as a fake brand but it is a real pregnancy prevention campaign
|
NA |
F3_5 |
In the past [FILL MONTHS],3 months, that is since [FILL DATE], have you seen or heard the following slogan or theme? Drop the Ash |
|
X |
|
This was added as a fake brand but we have two others so are dropping |
NA |
F3_11 |
In the past [FILL MONTHS] months, that is since [FILL DATE], have you seen or heard the following slogan or theme? Tips from Former Smokers (Tips) |
X |
|
|
Would like to ask about awareness of the Tips brand, for comparison |
These are identical to items approved for the baseline survey, with the exception of the campaign name. |
F3_12 |
In the past [FILL MONTHS] months, that is since [FILL DATE], have you seen or heard the following slogan or theme? Truth |
X |
|
|
Would like to ask about awareness of the truth brand, for comparison |
These are identical to items approved for the baseline survey, with the exception of the campaign name. |
F4 |
In the past [FILL MONTHS], that is since [FILL DATE], have you seen or heard of any ads on television or radio with the following themes or slogans? |
|
X |
|
We’ve asked the same questions using a different format (F3) |
NA |
F5_3c |
Where have you seen or heard about [INSERT CAMPAIGN NAME]? In magazines |
|
|
X |
In this version we drop the word “newspapers” because no media will run there |
The item was approved in a similar version. |
F5_3e |
Where have you seen or heard about [INSERT CAMPAIGN NAME]? Billboards or other outdoor or mall ads |
|
|
X |
In this version we add the word “mall” because media will run there |
The item was approved in a similar version. |
F5_3f |
Where have you seen or heard about [INSERT CAMPAIGN NAME]? At the movie theatre |
|
|
X |
We are adding an item for “move theatre” because media will run there |
The item was approved in a similar version. |
F6_3 |
The [INSERT CAMPAIGN NAME]Real Cost campaign is online. Have you ever seen [INSERT CAMPAIGN NAME]the Real Cost online? YouTube |
X |
|
|
Adding as planned to capture online exposure where online media will run. |
The item was approved in a similar version. |
F6_4 |
The [INSERT CAMPAIGN NAME]Real Cost campaign is online. Have you ever seen [INSERT CAMPAIGN NAME]the Real Cost online?Hulu |
X |
|
|
Adding as planned to capture online exposure where online media will run. |
The item was approved in a similar version. |
F6_5 |
The [INSERT CAMPAIGN NAME]Real Cost campaign is online. Have you ever seen [INSERT CAMPAIGN NAME]the Real Cost online? Pandora or Spotify |
X |
|
|
Adding as planned to capture online exposure where online media will run. |
The item was approved in a similar version. |
F6_6 |
The [INSERT CAMPAIGN NAME]Real Cost campaign is online. Have you ever seen [INSERT CAMPAIGN NAME]the Real Cost online? In video games |
X |
|
|
Adding as planned to capture online exposure where online media will run. |
The item was approved in a similar version. |
F7_x |
Now we would like to show you some screen shots from a television advertisements… |
|
|
X |
Edits to introductory text |
The item was approved in a similar version. |
F8_x |
Apart from this survey, hHave you seen this ad… |
|
|
X |
Edits to introductory text |
The item was approved in a similar version. |
F9_x |
Have you seen this ad online in the past [FILL MONTHS], months, since [FILL DATE]? |
|
X |
|
We have decided that youth may not be able to discriminate between ads seen on TV and ads seen online so we have asked one question that covers both possibilities. |
NA |
F9a_x. |
In the past [FILL MONTHS], how frequently have you seen this ad online? |
|
X |
|
We have decided that youth may not be able to discriminate between ads seen on TV and ads seen online so we have asked one question that covers both possibilities. |
NA |
F19_x |
What is the main message of this ad? |
X |
|
|
We want to assess whether youth understanding of the ad influenced outcomes |
This has not been approved in a prior instrument. |
F14_x. |
Did you talk to anyone in person or online about this ad? |
|
|
X |
Edit to add the words, “in person or online.” |
This has not been approved in a prior instrument. |
F15_1 |
This ad was good |
|
|
X |
Edit to make singular; we will ask for every ad |
This has not been approved in a prior instrument |
F15_2 |
This ad was not good |
|
|
X |
Edit to make singular; we will ask for every ad |
This has not been approved in a prior instrument |
F16 |
Have you heard of the Website www.therealcost.betobaccofree.hhs.gov? |
X |
|
|
We want to collect data on visits to campaign website |
This item was modified from the Tips campaign instrument. It has not been OMB-approved for use in this instrument. |
F16a |
Have you visited www.therealcost.betobaccofree.hhs.gov in the past [FILL MONTHS] months, since [FILL DATE]? |
X |
|
|
We want to collect data on visits to campaign website |
This item was modified from the Tips campaign instrument. It has not been approved in a prior instrument. |
G1_5 |
electronic cigarettes, e-cigarettes “vapor pens”, or “e-hookahs” such as blu, NJOY, Mistic, 21st Century Smoke |
|
|
X |
Updated item to reflect new understanding of how youth refer to e-cigarettes |
No |
File Type | application/vnd.openxmlformats-officedocument.wordprocessingml.document |
Author | Allen, Jane |
File Modified | 0000-00-00 |
File Created | 2021-01-27 |