Army Civilian Brand Focus Groups
Discussion Guide – Revision 2
Setup & disclosures
Thank and welcome; moderator introduction
Reading of OMB Control Number, expiration date, and Agency Disclosure Notice
Purpose of group discussion; role of respondents
Observers may be present in viewing room; microphone/audio recording to ensure the discussion fully and accurately captures, all questions asked, any issues noted for future refinements of discussion items.
Assurance of confidentiality; no personal information will be used or shared; respondents are identified with first name only
Ground rules: participate, speak one at a time, no wrong answers
Oral Consent form and Agency Disclosure Notice distribution and consent
Topic I: Introductions & warm-up 5 minutes
Respondent introduction:
Name (first name only)
Principal activity:
Student – full/part time, school attend, major,
Work – full/part time, position held, years in position
Topic II: Mind Map – employment goals/aspirations 10 minutes
Adapted for student vs. professional respondents
Everything that comes to mind about employment goals, expectations, aspirations in terms of tangible and intangible benefits and personal satisfaction/development
Probe any generalizations, organize as needed – tangibles/intangibles
Probe if not mentioned: compensation (pay and benefits), job security, geographic flexibility, possibility & speed of career advancement, opportunities for advancement and personal growth, opportunities for leadership positions, ability/need to travel, exposure to range of exciting challenges, flexibility to change positions/careers, retirement plan
Take hand count or 3 – 4 most important
Topic III: Current occupation & employer 15 minutes
Specifically for professional groups
How got current position; was it position of choice, employer of choice
Degree to which current employer delivers/exceeds on expectations and benefits previously mentioned, focusing on top 3 – 4
Likes and dislikes regarding current employer
Likelihood of staying with current employer; reasons
How would search for another job if was necessary
Probes: networking (where and how), information sources, preparation; importance of specific employer
Topic IV: Awareness & perceptions of different employer types 10 minutes
Discussion of different employer types come to mind: private companies, government agencies, own business.
Expectations of which employer types will deliver best against personal goals. Reasons why.
Which goals and expectations will each deliver best against? Differences across employer types.
Topic V: Exploration of current perceptions of US military/Army as an American Institution 5 minutes
Perceptions of US military and Army in particular; on a personal level, what do these institutions represent
What thoughts come to mind about the US military/Army?
What feelings do these institutions inspire? Probe: admiration, respect, aspiration, gratitude.
Differences between perceptions/thoughts/feelings about US military vs. the Army in particular?
Topic
VI: Awareness & knowledge of civilian employment in
military/Army
20 minutes
Awareness of civilian employment opportunities in the military/Army
Immediate reactions to civilian Army employment
Probe: positive and negative aspects
Perceptions of Army as employer
Knowledge of the types of jobs/occupations available
Knowledge of job commitment requirements as a civilian vs. enlisted officer/active duty service member
Comparison/expectations of Army civilian vs. private jobs/careers across goals/benefits
Probe list generated earlier: compensation (pay and benefits), job security, geographic flexibility, possibility & speed of career advancement, opportunities for advancement and personal growth, opportunities for leadership positions, ability/need to travel, exposure to range of exciting challenges, flexibility to change positions/careers, retirement plan
Most important reasons to seek civilian employment in the Army; which would Army civilian employment deliver better than private employer/other govt. agency
- Probe: compensation (pay and benefits), retirement, ability/need to travel, job security, geographic flexibility, possibility and speed of career
advancement, exposure to range of exciting challenges, flexibility to
change positions/careers
- Probe separately: importance/relevance of sense of purpose, service to
country/community, contributing to national defense
Perceived negative aspects of Civilian Army Employment
- Probe: need to sign contract, duration of contract, nature of employment
contract, geographic transfers against will, transfers to dangerous locations
Topic VII: Reactions to facts about civilian Army employment 10 minutes
Respondents will be presented with a list of facts about Army civilian employment followed by discussion on reactions to these facts.
Probes: compensation relative to private sector, ability to refuse transfers to dangerous locations, exposure to exciting challenges, speed of career advancement
Topic VIII: Army civilian positioning messages & concepts 15 minutes
Expose a few concepts and discuss
What is the main message; what trying to communicate?
Who is this message intended for? Who are they trying to reach? Are they talking to you (relevancy)?
Does this idea succeed in making you more aware of civilian employment with the Army? In what ways; what does it tell you about Army civilian employment? What does it tell you about the benefits of Army civilian employment; does it say enough about this?
What ideas do you connect with most? What ideas/messages are most relevant to your personal situation?
Anything not relevant to you? Something in particular that you don’t like about this concept?
Anything confusing, difficult to understand, or difficult to believe? Why?
Rank order the concepts in terms of their appeal to you
Wrap up
Page
File Type | application/vnd.openxmlformats-officedocument.wordprocessingml.document |
File Title | Financial Aid Exploratory Qualitative Research |
Author | Altagracia Ramos |
File Modified | 0000-00-00 |
File Created | 2021-01-23 |