Non-Research Determination

REQUEST FOR DETERMINATION OF RESEARCH STATUS
To be completed by the staff member with lead responsibility for the project and approved by branch chief (if applicable) and Division
ADS. A separate PGO funding memo is required if project is research and involves human subjects regardless of the CDC staff role.
Instructions:

(1) Use this form to declare: (a) the research status of any project, (b) role or roles of CDC staff
(2) A short summary should be attached offering specific details about the project and the role of staff.
(3) Be sure to complete all applicable items, obtain appropriate signatures and submit this form for approval.

Tracking Number:

TBD

(Use PGO number if cooperative agreement, grant, etc.)
Date submitted:

03/07/2016

Title of Project:

Assisted Reproductive Technology (ART) Data Collection

Dates for project period:

Dates for funding (if applicable):

Beginning:

10/15/2016

Beginning:

Ending:

12/31/2020

Ending:

Project is (choose one):
NOTE: Revision, as used below, refers to any substantive change made to the project including scope of project, funding restrictions,
personnel, role of CDC staff member, determination of research status, etc.
[X]

New

[]

Revision

[]

Continuation, without revision(s)

[]

Continuation, with revision(s)

Lead staff member:

Contact information:

Name:

Dmitry Kissin

Division:

User ID:

DTK3

Telephone: 770-488-6408

Scientific Ethics number:

1.

Please indicate your role(s) in this project:

2043 Mailstop:

DRH

F74

[X]

Project officer

[]

Technical monitor

[]

Principal
investigator

[]

Investigator

[]

Consultant

[]

Other (please explain)

Are any or all of the activities within this project DESIGNED to contribute to generalizable knowledge (i.e., research)?
[]

[X]

YES

NO

If YES, list those activities which are research:

2.

Is this CDC project research or public health practice (check all that apply)?
[]

3.

Research

[X]

Public health practice

Check one:

Check all that apply:

[]

Human subjects involved

[]

Emergency Response

[X]

Surveillance

[]

Human subjects not involved

[]

Program evaluation

[]

Other (please explain)

If RESEARCH involving human subjects, has the project or research activities been reviewed by the CDC IRB for human
subjects protection?
a. [ ]

NO, New project, not yet reviewed

d. [ ]

b. [ ] NO, Existing project, not ready to submit

YES, Reviewed and approved by CDC
If YES, please list protocol number and

c. [ ] NO, Submitted for approval

expiration date
e. [ ]

NO, RESEARCH, no CDC investigators (CDC IRB not
required)

f. [ ]

N/A (Not Applicable)

If RESEARCH, list any other CDC staff involved in this project, please include the name, role, and scientific ethics number

Form 684R_NR (revised January 2003)
ID:

26004

1

Tracking NO. TBD
Name

Role (project officer, investigator,
consultant, etc.)

Scientific ethics
number Prin

Dmitry Kissin

2043

IF YOU THINK THE RESEARCH PROJECT MIGHT QUALIFY AS EXEMPT RESEARCH (as identified in 45CFR46.101),
PLEASE ANSWER questions 4-6, OTHERWISE SKIP TO question 7.
4.

5.

Does the proposed research involve prisoners?
[ ]

YES

[ ]

NO

If YES, this research cannot be exempted and must be reviewed by an IRB (skip to question 7).

Does the proposed research involve fetuses, pregnant women, or human in vitro fertilization as targets (such that Subpart B
would apply)?
[ ]

YES

[ ]

NO

If YES, this research cannot be exempted and must be reviewed by an IRB (skip to
question 7).

Educational Research
6.1

Is this research conducted in established or commonly accepted educational settings, AND does the research involve
normal educational practices (e.g., research on regular and special education strategies or research on the
effectiveness of, or comparison among instrucational techniques, curricula or classroom management methods)?
[ ]

YES

[ ]

NO

Research Involving Surveys, Interview Procedures (including Focus groups), Observation of Public Behavior, or Educational
Tests
6.2

Will this research use educational tests (cognitive, diagnostic, aptitude, achievement), survey procedures, interview
procedures or observation of public behavior?
[ ]

YES

[ ]

NO

If NO skip 6.3

Will children (<18 years of age) be research subjects?
[ ]

YES

[ ]

NO

6.2.1

Is the information obtained recorded in such a manner that human subjects can be identified directly or
indirectly through identifiers (such as a code) linked to the subjects;
[ ]

6.2.2

YES

[ ]

NO

Will any disclosure of the human subjects' responses outside of the research setting have the potential to
place the subjects at risk of criminal or civil liability, or be damaging to the subjects' financial standing,
employability or reputation? (Examples here may include: the collection of sensitive data regarding the
subjects' (or relatives' or associates') possible substance abuse, sexuality, criminal history or intent, medical
or psychological condition, financial status, or similarly compromising information).
[ ]

6.3

If YES, this research cannot be exempted and must be reviewed by an IRB (skip to item 7)

YES

[ ]

NO

Will this research use educational tests (cognitive, diagnostic, aptitude, achievement), survey procedures, interview
procedures, or observation of public behavior but the research is not exempt under paragraph 6.2 of this section:
[ ]

YES

6.3.1

Will this research involve human subjects that are elected or appointed public officials or candidates for
public office?
[ ]

6.3.2

[ ]

YES

NO

[ ]

If NO skip to 6.4

NO

Does federal statute(s) require(s) without exception that confidentiality of the personally identifiable
information will be maintained throughout the research and thereafter? (Note: CDC can use this exemption
criterion only in the case where a 308(d) Assurance of Confidentiality has been obtained to cover the
research).
[ ]

YES

[ ]

NO

Existing Data Which Is Publicly Available or Unidentifiable
6.4

Does this research involve only the collection or study of existing* data, documents, records, pathological or
diagnostic specimens? (* 'existing' means existing before the study begins)?
[ ]

YES

6.4.1

Is this material or information publicly available?
[ ]

[ ]
YES

Form 684R_NR (revised January 2003)
ID:

26004

NO
[ ]

If NO skip to 7
NO

2

Tracking NO. TBD
6.4.2

Is this material or information recorded in such a manner by the investigator that the subjects cannot be
identified directly or indirectly through identifiers linked to the subjects?
(Note: If a link is created by an investigator even temporarily, for research purposes, this criterion is not met.
If a temporary link is created by clinical staff who already have access to the data, this criterion is met).

7.

[ ]

YES

(there are no identifying information and no unique identifiers or codes)YES

[ ]

NO

(there are identifiers (including codes))

Please prepare and attach a short summary paragraph (<1 page);
if this is new:
a.

Be sure to include the purpose of the project, specific details about the project and the role of the CDC staff member
(s) in the project. In explaining one's role as a consultant be particularly careful to identify involvement in things
like: study design decisions, oversight of protocol development, participation in review of data collection procedures,
and particpation in data analysis and/or manuscript preparation, as well as whether there will be access to
identifiable or personal data.

b.

Explain your project status selection (research--non-exempt, exempt, no CDC investigator or not involving human
subjects; public health practice). If you selected research not involving human subjects be sure to indicate if the data
includes any personal information (e.g., name, SSN), linkable study identification numbers or codes, or geographical
information.
The purpose of this project is to comply with the Fertility Clinic Success Rate and Certification Act of 1992 (FCSRCA), Section
2(a) of P.L. 102-493(42 U.S.C. 263(a)-1) which mandates that all assisted reproductive technology (ART) clinics in the U.S.
report annual success rate data to the Secretary of Health and Human Services through the CDC in a standardized fashion.
Annual clinic and cycle specific data from all practicing ART clinics in the U.S. will be collected via the National ART
Surveillance System (NASS) and used by CDC to produce annual surveillance reports of pregnancy success rates for the
public, as required in the FCSRCA.
CDC first implemented the FCSRCA in 1997 and has obtained and published data for ART procedures through contracts with
the Society for Assisted Reproductive Technology (SART) and Westat. The current contract with Westat expires on 12/31/17,
with 2016 being the last reporting year covered by an existing contract. In order to ensure a seamless transition of
responsibilities such that NASS is fully functional to receive data on a daily basis, a new contract needs to be in place by
October 15, 2016.
Under the new contract, CDC staff members will be responsible for overseeing clinic tracking, data collection, quality
assurance, and data validation processes for all ART procedures performed in a single calendar year. CDC staff members will
also be responsible for overseeing production of annual surveillance reports using this data.
This project has been categorized as public health practice/surveillance because, as a national surveillance system, the
primary intent of the NASS is to collect information on pregnancy success rates resulting from ART procedures performed in
the U.S. and its territories. The intended benefits of this surveillance system are to provide patients, providers, and policy
makers with standardized information on fertility clinic pregnancy success rates to better inform ART decision-making.

8.

Please list the primary project site and all collaborating site(s).
Explanation of project components:

9.

If project involves research that is funded extramurally, list amount of award that should be restricted pending IRB
approval and describe which project components will be affected, if known:

Approvals (signature and position title)

Date

Linda Hannon-hall - PUBLIC HEALTH
ADVISOR

03/07/2016

Research Determination / Remarks
[X]
[ ]
[ ]
[ ]
[ ]

Public health practice
Research not involving human subjects
Research involving human subjects, no CDC investigators
Research involving human subjects, CDC investigators, exempt
Research involving human subjects, CDC investigators, not exempt

(check if applicable)
[ ]
Local IRB
[ ]
CDC Exemption
[ ]
CDC IRB
staff member completing this form

Form 684R_NR (revised January 2003)
ID:

26004

Comments:
Reviewed and approve

3

Linda Hannon-hall - PUBLIC HEALTH
ADVISOR

03/08/2016

[X]
[ ]
[ ]
[ ]
[ ]

Public health practice
Research not involving human subjects
Research involving human subjects, no CDC investigators
Research involving human subjects, CDC investigators, exempt
Research involving human subjects, CDC investigators, not exempt

(check if applicable)
[ ]
Local IRB
[ ]
CDC Exemption
[ ]
CDC IRB
Team Lead

Comments:
Approved

Karen Pazol - Deputy ADS

03/08/2016

[X]
[ ]
[ ]
[ ]
[ ]

Public health practice
Research not involving human subjects
Research involving human subjects, no CDC investigators
Research involving human subjects, CDC investigators, exempt
Research involving human subjects, CDC investigators, not exempt

(check if applicable)
[ ]
Local IRB
[ ]
CDC Exemption
[ ]
CDC IRB
Division ADS

Comments:

Joan Redmond Leonard - PUBLIC
HEALTH ANALYST

03/11/2016

[X]
[ ]
[ ]
[ ]
[ ]

Public health practice
Research not involving human subjects
Research involving human subjects, no CDC investigators
Research involving human subjects, CDC investigators, exempt
Research involving human subjects, CDC investigators, not exempt

(check if applicable)
[ ]
Local IRB
[ ]
CDC Exemption
[ ]
CDC IRB
CUC ADS, Deputy ADS, or Human
Subjects Contact

Form 684R_NR (revised January 2003)
ID:

26004

Comments:

4