Download:
pdf |
pdfAttachment N.8. Nutrient Analysis Protocols
This information is being collected from State agencies, school food authorities, schools. This is
a revision of a currently approved information collection. The Richard B. Russell National
School Lunch Act (NSLA) 42 U.S.C. § 1758, as amended, authorizes the National School Lunch
Program (NSLP). This information is required to administer and operate this program in
accordance with the NSLA. Under the Privacy Act of 1974, any personally identifying
information obtained will be kept private to the extent of the law. According to the Paperwork
Reduction Act of 1995, an agency may not conduct or sponsor, and a person is not required to
respond to, a collection of information unless it displays a valid OMB control number. The valid
OMB control number for this information collection is 0584-0006. The time required to
complete this information collection is estimated to average 47.5 hours of reporting burden per
response. The burden consists of the time it takes for the State agency to conduct the off-site
portion of the review which includes scheduling of the review and the completion of the Off-site
Assessment, Resource Management Risk Indicator, and Site Selection Tools. Send comments
regarding this burden estimate or any other aspect of this collection of information, including
suggestions for reducing this burden, to: U.S. Department of Agriculture, Food and Nutrition
Services, Office of Policy Support, 3101 Park Center Drive, Room 1014, Alexandria, VA 22302,
ATTN: PRA (0584-0006). Do not return
the completed form to this address.
OMB
#0584-0006
Expiration Date
xx/xx/20xx
Nutrient
Analysis
Protocols:
How to Analyze Menus for
USDA’s School Meals
Programs
Pre-Publication Copy
February 2014
Table of Contents
Chapter
Page
1. Introduction, Purpose of Nutrient Analysis, and Learning
Outcomes………………………………………………………………………………
2
2. The Dietary Specifications……………………………………………………..
6
3. Key Nutrient Analysis Concepts……………………………………………..
9
4. Selecting Software for Nutrient Analysis……………………………….. 13
5. Overview of Conducting a Nutrient Analysis………………………….
16
6. Preparing for a Nutrient Analysis…………………………………………..
22
7. Entering Food Items (Ingredients) into the Local Database…..
27
8. Adding a Recipe to the Local Database………………………………….
30
9. Entering Menu Plans…………………………………………………………….. 49
10. Evaluating and Modifying Menus and Recipes to Meet the
Dietary Specifications…………………………………………………………..
55
Appendices
Appendix A: Meal Pattern for Required Grade Groups: Breakfast and
Lunch…………………………………………………………………………………….
Appendix B: Nutrient Analysis and Validation Checklist……………………………..
Appendix C: Foods of Minimal Nutritional Value (applies through June 30, 2014)……
Appendix D: USDA-Approved Nutrient Analysis Software
Requirements………………………………………………………………………..
Appendix E: Sample Nutrition Facts Label………………………………………………….
Appendix F: Form for Manufacturers to Submit to Have Food Products
Added to CN Database………………………………………………………….
Appendix G: Raw-to-Cooked Conversion Factor for Selected Vegetables…..
Appendix H: Common Moisture and Fat Change Values (%) for Purchased
Prepared Foods that are Fried……………………………………………….
Pre-Publication Copy
60
63
70
73
75
76
79
80
1
Chapter 1:
Introduction, Purpose of Nutrient Analysis, and
Learning Outcomes
CHAPTER OBJECTIVES
After reading this chapter, you will understand how to:
• Relate the USDA school meal patterns to national nutrition standards for healthy children, such as the
Dietary Guidelines for Americans and the Dietary Reference Intakes.
• Select an option for assessing compliance with Dietary Specifications requirements during an
Administrative Review.
Introduction
The Final Rule for USDA’s Nutrition
Standards in the National School Lunch
and School Breakfast Programs,
(published January 26, 2012) intends to
ensure the provision of nutrient-dense
meals (high in nutrients and low in
calories) that meet the health needs of
school children and reflect the most
current dietary science. Under the rule, all
schools must follow a Food-Based Menu
Planning (FBMP) approach for the National
School Lunch Program (NSLP) and for the
School Breakfast Program (SBP) and
produce enough food to offer each child
the quantities specified in the meal
pattern. State agencies (SAs) may be
required to conduct weighted nutrient
analyses of school lunches and breakfasts
for students in grades K through 12 as part
of the Administrative Review (AR).
Although School Food Authorities (SFAs)
are not required to conduct nutrient
analyses, they are expected to follow the
meal pattern in order to meet nutrient
Pre-Publication Copy
Nutrition Goals
Protein, Vitamins & Minerals
•
•
Appropriate for age/grade group
Minimize inadequacy
Calories
•
•
Appropriate for age/grade group
Reduce childhood hunger and prevent childhood obesity
Dietary Guidelines for Americans
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
Eat a variety of foods, especially dark green, red, and orange
vegetables; beans and peas; whole grains; and fat-free or
low-fat milk and milk products
Balance calories and physical activity to manage weight
Consume at least half of all grains as whole grains
Reduce sodium to < 2300 mg per day
Limit saturated fat to < 10% of calories
Keep trans fat consumption as low as possible
Reduce the intake of solid fats and added sugars
Choose foods that provide more potassium, dietary fiber,
calcium, and vitamin D
2
targets. However, SFAs may conduct nutrient analyses of meals to determine if they are in
compliance with the required Dietary Specifications.
Nutrition Standards for Healthy Children
Nutrition Goals
The Nutrition Standards for school meals underscore our national responsibility to provide
healthy school meals that are consistent with the Dietary Reference Intakes (DRIs), energy
requirements for each age/grade group, and the Dietary Guidelines for Americans. The
Standards are a critical component of combating the childhood obesity epidemic, while also
addressing childhood hunger.
Menu Planning and Nutrient Analysis
See Appendix A for meal pattern requirements.
The meal pattern requires specific foods (components) and food quantities based on the
age/grade of students. The State agency will conduct menu reviews, which may include
performing a weighted nutrient analysis of the lunch and breakfast menus offered for each
age/grade group during the review period to determine compliance with the Dietary
Specifications for calories, saturated fat, and sodium. State agencies will target a menu review
site based on the Meal Compliance Risk Assessment Tool and select one of four options to
complete the Dietary Specifications and Nutrient Analysis portion of the AR.
State agencies must select one of the following four options to assess compliance with dietary
specifications:
•
Option 1: Complete the Dietary Specifications Assessment Tool
Complete the Dietary Specifications Assessment Tool (available at:
http://www.fns.usda.gov/school-meals/administrative-reviewmanual) to determine the level of risk for meeting the dietary
specifications based on the assessment of specific food service
practices for lunch and breakfast. This option requires off-site
review procedures prior to the on-site visit including the review of
menu documentation.
•
Option 2: Validate an SFA-Conducted Nutrient Analysis
Validate an existing nutrient analysis that was conducted
by the SFA or a contractor hired by the SFA. A breakfast
and lunch nutrient analysis performed using USDAapproved software must be available specifically for the
Pre-Publication Copy
3
targeted menu review site for the State agency to select
this option. The State agency may accept the nutrient
analysis after validating that the analysis was conducted in
accordance with these Nutrient Analysis Protocols. An
aggregated, district-wide analysis is not acceptable for
validation.
•
Option 3: Conduct a Nutrient Analysis
The State Agency may decline to use the off-site Dietary
Specifications Assessment Tool to determine the level of
risk prior to the on-site visit. The State agency will then
conduct a lunch and breakfast nutrient analysis using
USDA approved software for the site selected for the
targeted menu review.
•
Option 4: Alternate Method Using Menu Planning Tools
Approved for Certification for Six Cents Reimbursement
State agencies may request approval from FNS to use an
alternate methodology to assess compliance with dietary
specifications requirements (see memo SP 46-2013 for
more details).
NOTE: This manual will be used for all options when a nutrient analysis is conducted or
validated to ensure the correct nutrient analysis protocols are followed.
When it is determined nutrient analyses are required, the State agency must refer to and follow
the Nutrient Analysis and Validation Checklist (Appendix B). The checklist provides a series of
questions to ensure specific requirements are met before a nutrient analysis is performed or
validated. The checklist will prompt the State agency to complete the on-site portion of the
Dietary Specifications Assessment Tool as it will provide useful information when conducting or
validating the nutrient analyses.
Purpose of Nutrient Analysis
The purpose of nutrient analysis is to determine compliance with regulatory requirements for
calories, saturated fat, and sodium, and to monitor levels of these dietary components in
school meals.
Performing an accurate nutrient analysis is critical to the evaluation of menus and menu
documentation. This manual is designed to provide the knowledge and skills to perform an
accurate nutrient analysis.
Pre-Publication Copy
4
Learning Outcomes
The information contained in this manual will enable readers to:
1. Explain the purpose of a nutrient analysis and the nutrition goals of the USDA Nutrition
Standards.
2. Select USDA-approved nutrient analysis software which will meet the needs of the State
agency.
3. Describe key nutrient analysis points for schools to consider when selecting food items
and quantities from the Child Nutrition (CN) Database.
4. Assemble materials necessary to conduct or validate a nutrient analysis.
5. Correctly enter data for food items (ingredients), recipes, menus, and school/SFA data
following nutrient analysis protocols for school nutrition programs.
6. Discuss common data entry errors and how to prevent/identify mistakes.
7. Perform nutrient analyses, evaluate data, and revise menus, if needed.
8. Create reports.
Pre-Publication Copy
5
Chapter 2:
The Dietary Specifications
CHAPTER OBJECTIVES
After reading this chapter, you will understand how to:
1.
2.
Discuss Dietary Specifications requirements for school meals.
Explain Dietary Specifications requirements related to USDA-defined age/grade groups.
A dietary specification is the required level of calories, saturated fat, trans fat, or sodium for a
specific age/grade group. The Dietary Specifications were established to serve as a measure of
the nutritional quality of school meals.
Regulations require that breakfast and/or lunch menus offered and averaged over a week meet
the Dietary Specifications for the age/grade group for which they are intended. The Dietary
Specifications for breakfast and lunch must be evaluated separately.
Four Dietary Specifications:
Weekly average requirements:
•
•
•
Calories (range)
Saturated Fat (maximum)
Sodium (maximum)
Daily requirement restriction:
•
Trans Fat (maximum)
HELPFUL TIP
Menu planners should select
nutrient dense foods and
ingredients, and avoid products
that are high in fats, added
sugars, and added sodium.
For total calories, minimums and maximums are
established by age/grade group and must be met on
average over the school week. By keeping calories
within the acceptable ranges, menu planners ensure
adequate, consistent calorie levels to meet children’s
energy and development needs, while also reducing the risk of overconsumption.
Pre-Publication Copy
6
In order to reduce trans fat, sodium, and the percentage of calories from saturated fat, the
Dietary Specifications for these are maximums.
Food products and ingredients used daily must contain zero grams of trans fat per serving
(naturally occurring trans fats are exempt). It is important to note trans fat will not be
evaluated in the nutrient analysis, therefore the State agency must review nutrition labeling or
manufacturer specifications for products or ingredients used to prepare school meals to verify
they contain zero grams (less than 0.5 grams) of trans fat per serving.
Meeting a Child's Overall Nutrient Needs:
USDA recognizes that the Dietary Specifications do not include all the nutrients for which
Dietary Reference Intakes (DRIs) have been established. The required meal pattern
(components and quantities) ensures that children are offered foods that contain certain
amounts vitamins and minerals required for optimal growth and development. Therefore,
following the meal pattern requirements, and monitoring the nutrients for which Dietary
Specifications have been established, should ensure that children’s overall nutrient needs are
met.
Nutrition research indicates that, for optimum health, humans need an array of biologicallyactive compounds that occur in a variety of foods (e.g., fruits, vegetables, whole grains). USDA
is committed to the principle that school meals be comprised of an assortment of foods which
provide naturally occurring nutrients, as recommended in the Dietary Guidelines, rather than
formulated foods which have been artificially fortified.
Nutrition Standards for Meals
The meal patterns are designed to reflect different nutrient and calorie needs of students and
accommodate the grade structure in the majority of schools. USDA has also established
age/grade group-specific Dietary Specifications.
Required Age/Grade Groups for Meal Pattern: Breakfast and Lunch
*
*
*
Grades K-5
Grades 6-8
Grades 9-12
Pre-Publication Copy
7
Single Menu Allowable for Lunch K-8
If a K-8 school is unable to offer different meal patterns for grades K-5 and grades 6-8 students,
the menu planner may offer students in these grades the same quantities of food components
because the lunch meal pattern requirements for the K-5 and 6-8 age/grade groups narrowly
overlap. However, the school district would have to be careful to meet the sodium and calorie
requirements for each age/grade group. For example, if a single menu is offered to grades K-8,
it must comply with the K-5 sodium requirement (also compliant with the grades 6-8
requirement); furthermore, average calories must be in the range where the K-5 and 6-8
requirements overlap (i.e., between 600-650 calories for lunch).
If one menu is served to K-8 students, a single nutrient analysis may be conducted for K-8,
however it may be advantageous to run separate analyses if the nutrient analysis is not meeting
the Dietary Specifications to determine where the menu may need to be adjusted.
Single Menu Allowable for Breakfast K-12
The same concept occurs with breakfast. There is overlap in the Dietary Specifications for all
grade groups for breakfast; therefore it is possible to meet all the Dietary Specifications with
one breakfast menu (K-12). A single weighted analysis may be conducted however the sodium
and calorie requirements for each age/grade group must meet the overlap of all three age
grade groups. For example a K-12 breakfast menu must provide between 450-500 calories and
comply with the K-5 sodium requirements. It may be advantageous to run separate analyses for
each age/grade group if the nutrient analysis is not meeting the Dietary Specifications to
determine where the menu may need to be adjusted.
Pre-Publication Copy
8
Chapter 3:
Key Nutrient Analysis Concepts
CHAPTER OBJECTIVES
After reading this chapter, you will understand how to:
3.
4.
5.
6.
7.
Define the Child Nutrition (CN) Database.
Explain what constitutes a school week for a nutrient analysis.
Discuss weighted averages.
Summarize the Yield Factor Method used for recipe analysis.
Explain the difference between whole foods and fortified foods.
Overview of the Software Database
(including the Child Nutrition (CN) Database)
An accurate nutrient analysis is critical in assessing compliance with dietary specifications. In
cooperation with the USDA’s Agricultural Research Service (ARS), FNS developed the CN
Database to provide accurate, reliable, and centralized nutrient data for analysis of school
meals. All USDA-approved software includes the CN Database.
The CN Database contains the nutrient profiles of food items commonly used in SFAs/schools
and contains nutrients that are monitored by the Child Nutrition Program.
The CN Database includes:
•
Selected food items from the USDA Nutrient Database for Standard Reference;
•
USDA foods;
•
Nutrient profiles for USDA Recipes and Recipes for Healthy Kids;
•
Many brand name commercially prepared foods provided by food industry; and
•
Yield information from USDA’s Food Buying Guide for Child Nutrition Programs.
These files are locked, which means the information in these files may be accessed and copied,
but may not be altered by the local user.
Pre-Publication Copy
9
Database requirements for USDA-approved nutrient analysis software programs:
•
Software must contain the most current version of the CN Database.
•
The software may include brand name food items with nutrient data that has been
supplied directly to the software vendors by food industry. The user must be able to
differentiate between food industry items in the CN Database and food industry items
added by the software developers.
•
Foods and recipes added by the software vendor or by the user must have the source
designated as “Local.”
All Foods Are Included in the
Nutrient Analysis
All food or menu items offered in a reimbursable meal, including condiments/accompaniments,
are included in the nutrient analysis and count toward meeting the Dietary Specifications for
the meal.
Schools may offer extra foods (e.g., ice
cream, pudding) that do not credit
toward any food component required in
a reimbursable meal. Extra foods
offered must be included in the nutrient
analysis and count toward the limits on
calories, saturated fat, sodium, and
trans fat.
Are foods served to students with special needs included
in the nutrient analysis?
1.
2.
When food or menu item substitutions are made for
students with special dietary needs, the meals are not
included in the nutrient analysis.
If food or menu items served to students with special
dietary needs are the same menu items served to the
entire age/grade group, only modified for texture, the
food or menu items are included in the nutrient
analysis.
Foods that are considered Foods of
Minimal Nutritional Value (FMNV)
under 7 CFR Parts 210 and 220, Appendices B (i.e., chewing gum, soda water, water ices, and
certain candies) are included in the nutrient analysis calculations only if they are used as a
garnish in a menu item. For example, even though jelly beans are a food of FMNV, a menu
planner would include them in the nutrient analysis if they are used as a cake decoration.
Appendix C provides more information on Foods of Minimal Nutritional Value. [NOTE: When
Standards for All Foods Sold in School are implemented on July 1, 2014, the Foods of Minimal
Nutritional Value category will be eliminated. For additional information, see the Smart Snacks
Interim Final Rule at http://www.gpo.gov/fdsys/pkg/FR-2013-06-28/pdf/2013-15249.pdf.]
Only reimbursable meals are included in nutrient analyses. Therefore, adult meals and a la carte
sales must not be included in nutrient analyses.
Pre-Publication Copy
10
Nutrients Calculated “As Consumed” or
“Edible Form”
YIELD FACTOR METHOD
A nutrient analysis is conducted to calculate the
nutrients in the finished food products as they will be
A method for nutrient analysis of recipes that
consumed by students. It is important to note that
requires that each raw recipe ingredient be
recipes for nutrient analysis, including the ingredients
converted and entered in the recipe database as
ready-to-serve or cooked. If the database does not
used in the recipes, may be very different from the
include raw-to-cooked yield for a specific
standardized recipe that the cook uses in food
ingredient, use the yield data from USDA’s Food
production. This is because many of the ingredients in
Buying Guide for Child Nutrition Programs to
a standardized food production or cook’s recipe may
convert from the raw to the cooked form.
be in the “as purchased” form such as raw ground
beef, raw chopped onions and raw green pepper for a
meatloaf — which will then be prepared or cooked from scratch in the school kitchen(s). The
nutrient content of foods may vary greatly depending on the method of preparation. As foods
cook, they may lose moisture and nutrients. All ingredients in recipes prepared “from scratch”
must be entered into the computer using the Yield Factor Method to account for the changes in
nutrient values due to preparation and cooking.
The Yield Factor Method will be explained in more detail during the discussion of the
procedures for entering recipes in Chapter 8.
Nutrients Averaged over the School Week
State agencies will monitor calories, saturated fat, and sodium in the meals served to students
in grades K -12. Breakfast and lunch menus are analyzed over one school week within the
review period. When evaluating the Dietary Specifications, state agencies may not combine
breakfast and lunch analyses.
Definition of School Week
For the purposes of nutrient analysis, a school week represents a normal school week of five
consecutive days. To accommodate weeks that are either shorter or longer than the five
consecutive days, the analyzed week should contain a minimum of three consecutive days and
a maximum of seven consecutive days. When school lunches are offered less than three times
in a week, combine these menus with either the previous week’s menus or the subsequent
week’s menus.
Pre-Publication Copy
11
For example, during the week of Thanksgiving, an SFA/school serves lunch only two days that
week. Those two days could be combined with either the week before or the week after
Thanksgiving. The same situation might arise around other holiday periods or during the first
and last weeks of school.
By combining a menu week that only has one or two days in it with another week, the school
avoids problems in meeting the Dietary Specifications that can result from analyzing a small
sample of meals.
Weighted Averages
National School Lunch Program (NSLP) and School Breakfast Program (SBP) regulations require
weighted averages for conducting nutrient analyses. A weighted nutrient analysis gives more
weight to nutrients in popular foods that are more frequently selected by students. Weighted
analyses allows for a greater contribution of nutrients to come from menu items that are
selected more often and less nutrient contribution from those menu items selected less often.
More discussion of weighted averages will be provided in Chapter 9.
Whole Foods Versus Fortification
USDA is committed to the fundamental Dietary Guidelines premise that nutrients should come
primarily from foods. Nutrient dense foods contain essential vitamins and minerals that are
often contained in nutrient supplements, and also contain dietary fiber and other biologically
active compounds (e.g., flavenoids, carotenoids, and other phytonutrients) that may have
positive health effects.
Schools offering meals that contain a variety of nutrient dense foods, especially dark green red
and orange vegetables; beans and peas; whole grains; and fat-free or low-fat milk and milk
products, will meet Dietary Guidelines.
School meals also provide an opportunity to teach children about healthful eating. Learning to
make food choices to nourish and optimize health is an important and valuable life skill.
Consequently, it is essential for children to learn about, and recognize, foods and the variety of
nutrients they provide.
Pre-Publication Copy
12
Chapter 4
Selecting Software for Nutrient Analysis
CHAPTER OBJECTIVES
After reading this chapter, you will understand how to:
• Select software for nutrient analysis.
• Explain the various functions that USDA-approved software programs allow.
• Choose an approved nutrient analysis program.
USDA-Approved Nutrient Analysis Software Programs
USDA approves software to be used for the Administrative Review to ensure valid and
consistent nutrient data.
•
State agencies must use USDA-approved software when conducting a nutrient analysis.
•
SFAs/schools conducting their own nutrient analysis must use USDA-approved software
if they want the State agency to accept their nutrient analysis for the Administrative
Review.
CN Database in Approved Software
To be eligible for USDA approval, the nutrient
analysis software program must contain the
current CN Database developed specifically for
analysis of school meals. Software manufacturers
are expected to update their software within 90
days of the date a new CN database version is
released.
USDA-approved software programs allow you to:
• Enter the nutrient data of a new food item
from a Nutrition Facts label or from a
manufacturer’s nutrient analysis data
report.
Pre-Publication Copy
Using Software with the Most Current CN
Database
Federal guidelines require USDA-approved
nutrient analysis software developers to update
their customers with the most recent CN
Database release to remain approved for use in
Child Nutrition Programs. State agencies and
SFAs are encouraged to work with their software
vendor to ensure that they are using software
with the most current CN Database version. Each
revision contains updated nutrient data, new
commercially prepared items, and USDA Foods
nutrient information. A list of USDA-approved
software is available on the Healthy Meals
Resource System website:
http://healthymeals.nal.usda.gov/menuplanning/nutrient-analysis-software-approvedusda/nutrient-analysis-software-approved-use.
13
•
Enter, modify and analyze recipes.
•
Plan, copy, or modify menus for a 3- to 7-day school week.
•
Compare nutrient analysis of the weekly breakfast or lunch menu to a specific nutrient
standard and indicate when standards are not being met.
•
Search the database for food items containing specific nutrients in order to modify
menus to meet the nutrient standard.
•
Create reports, such as nutrient composition, menus, and recipe analysis.
A more detailed description of the software program requirements and functions is provided in
Appendix D.
Choosing an Approved Nutrient Analysis Software Program
Differences in Software Programs
While the USDA-approved software programs must include the functions outlined in Appendix
D, there are still many differences between the USDA-approved software programs.
•
Some programs perform only nutrient analysis.
•
Some programs are part of a larger system that include many other school foodservice
software modules, such as Free and Reduced Price modules, Food Production modules,
and Inventory modules.
•
Operating system and hardware requirements vary.
The SFA/school and State agency will need to do some research to find the program that best
meets the needs of your school district/school or State agency. Confer with your computer
personnel to ensure software compatibility with existing hardware.
Questions to Consider When Selecting Software
•
Do you need software that does only nutrient analysis, or do you want related program
applications that perform many functions such as procurement, inventory, enhanced
production records, etc.?
•
Do you want a Windows-based system? A networked system?
Pre-Publication Copy
14
•
What are the hardware requirements? Will current hardware support the software
requirements? Check with your technology support team in the State agency or SFA for
guidance.
•
Are you able to participate in a demonstration of the software program at a conference
or through other means?
•
Can you visit a site that is using the software program in which you are interested?
•
How easy is the program to use for entering data? Consider who will be using the
program and staff computer literacy.
•
How efficient is the overall nutrient analysis process? How well does the “search”
feature help you locate food items (ingredients) and recipes in the database?
•
Are reports easy to understand? Is it easy to interpret the results of the nutrient analysis
and modify the recipes and menus to adjust results?
•
How often is the software updated? Will the updates be provided as part of your initial
cost or be separately priced? What are the update costs?
•
What will the software package initially cost for one school/for the district? Consider
how many copies or licenses for the software will be needed.
•
What support is available? Online, telephone, on site? What does it cost?
NOTE: USDA only reviews and monitors the CN Database and software functions that relate directly to nutrient
analyses and meal pattern contributions. USDA does not review or approve other functions added by software
vendors.
Pre-Publication Copy
15
Chapter 5:
Overview of Conducting a Nutrient Analysis
CHAPTER OBJECTIVES
After reading this chapter, you will understand how to:
• Use the CN Database in conjunction with vendor-added and user-added data.
• List the five steps needed to conduct a nutrient analysis.
The exact steps to conducting a nutrient analysis may vary slightly among software programs,
but there are similar functions. Menu planners and State agency staff must understand and
carefully follow the procedures or protocols for each step to conduct an accurate nutrient
analysis, regardless of the software program.
Detailed descriptions of each step will be provided in the following chapters but initially the
user must understand several principles or concepts prior to conducting a nutrient analysis.
Before beginning the process of entering new food items into the nutrient analysis software
database, the user should understand how the software database has been developed.
Contents of the Nutrient Analysis
Software Database
There are two parts to the software database:
1. Child Nutrition (CN) Database
All USDA-approved nutrient analysis software
programs must contain the most current version of
the CN Database. All files in the CN Database are
locked which means they cannot be modified or
deleted by the user. The CN Database includes:
The USDA-approved nutrient analysis
software contains foods or ingredients in
the CN Database and also allows the user to
add, modify, and delete food or ingredient
items and recipes in the local database.
•
USDA Standard Reference Foods or Ingredients: The CN Database contains foods or
ingredients most commonly used in school meals from the USDA Nutrient Database for
Standard Reference. These foods or ingredients are identified in the software database
under the Source as USDA Nutrient Database.
•
Commercially Prepared Foods: FNS contracts with a private company to manage the CN
Database. Because SFAs/schools use numerous commercially prepared products,
Pre-Publication Copy
16
manufacturers are encouraged to submit nutritional information for their products so
they can be added to the CN Database. This saves data entry time for local school
districts/schools and State agencies and makes nutritional information on those
products available nationwide. A sample of the form to be completed by manufacturers
for submission of data is included in Appendix F. These food products or ingredients are
identified in the software database under the Source as Food Industry.
•
USDA Foods: The CN Database contains the current USDA foods available to school
districts/schools. These food products or ingredients are identified in the software
database under the Source as USDA Foods. The CN Database does not include USDA
Foods that are processed under State processing contracts. For more information about
USDA Foods, see http://www.fns.usda.gov/fdd/foods/healthy/ToolKit.htm.
•
USDA Food Buying Guide Yield Data: The CN Database contains yield data from the
Food Buying Guide as a tool to assist the menu planner in determining raw-to-cooked
yields for recipe analysis. It also provides yield data for many other foods from an as
purchased form (AP) to the edible portion (EP) of the food. This yield data is also useful
for volume/weight conversions from the purchase unit, e.g., can size to cups, cups per
pound, and cans to weight.
•
USDA Recipes and Recipes for Healthy Kids: The CN Database contains all current
USDA-standardized quantity recipes for school foodservice. Only the nutrient
information is included — not the recipe ingredients and directions. If a school uses the
USDA recipe exactly as displayed on the recipe card (first listed ingredient when
alternates are listed and no optional ingredients), the nutrient analysis for the USDA
quantity recipes in the CN Database is the most accurate selection for menu analysis.
Some software companies have entered the USDA standardized quantity recipes into a
separate recipe database, with each ingredient listed, to make it easier for school
districts/schools to modify the recipes. USDA Recipes for Schools are available at:
http://www.fns.usda.gov/tn/Resources/usda_recipes.html. Recipes for Healthy Kids are
available at: http://teamnutrition.usda.gov/Resources/r4hk_schools.html.
Companies that want their products entered into the CN Database should visit the Healthy School Meals Resource System website at:
http://healthymeals.nal.usda.gov/online-web-tool-submitting-nutrient-data-0
2. Local Database
In addition to the CN Database, some
software manufacturers include nutrient data
in their local databases for the following:
•
Review local databases and vendor-added recipes for accuracy
•
Commercially prepared products, and
•
Pre-Publication Copy
USDA does not review local databases for accuracy. State
agencies and SFAs are cautioned that these local
databases may not have the same quality control and/or
monitoring as the CN Database, and may contain errors
and/or missing data.
USDA does not review recipes entered by software
vendors for accuracy and adherence to nutrient analysis
17 agencies are
protocols. School districts/schools and State
cautioned to carefully review vendor-added recipes to
ensure that nutrient analysis protocols are followed, if
these recipes are used for nutrient analyses.
•
Raw-to-cooked yield data for certain products
These vendor-added commercially prepared food products or ingredients are identified in the
software database under the Source as Local.
All USDA-approved software also allows the user to:
•
Enter the nutrient data for new food items, and
•
Enter, modify, and analyze recipes.
These user-added or modified food products and recipes should be identified in the software
database under the Source as Local.
Overview of Steps for Conducting a Nutrient Analysis
STEP 1
Preparing for Nutrient Analysis – Gathering the Materials
This process will be discussed in-depth in Chapter 6. Materials include:
•
Breakfast and lunch menus including menu choices and portion sizes for each age/grade
group and menu type.
•
Standardized recipes, including USDA Recipes and local recipes that will be used in the
menus.
•
Description or specifications for all food products used in the menus.
•
Nutrient information for ingredients used in recipes that are not included in the
software database,
•
Food production records to assist in weighting the more frequently selected items and
document if reimbursable meals were offered to students. If this is an entirely new set
of menus this information may not be available until the menus for an entire menu cycle
have been served.
STEP 2
Entering Food Items (Ingredients) into the Local Database
Pre-Publication Copy
18
This process will be discussed further in Chapter 7 and includes:
•
Reviewing the recipes to be used in the cycle menus (SFA) or the review week’s menus
for the school (State agency) and identifying ingredients missing in the software
database.
•
Entering the missing ingredients, including volume and weight measurements, and
nutrient information.
How Food Manufacturers Provide Nutrient Information
Manufacturers provide nutrient analysis information in one of two ways — as purchased or as
served.
•
As purchased nutrient analysis data represents the nutritional content of a weight
and/or a volume or other measurable amount of the product exactly as it is purchased;
that is, the nutrients contained in a certain amount of an unprepared cornbread mix or
an unbaked prepared whole grain pizza or pre-fried egg roll. Note: “The Nutrition Facts”
labels on products are required to provide “as purchased” data. A sample copy of a
Nutrition Facts Label is included in Appendix E.
•
As served nutrient analysis data provides the nutrient values for a product after it has
been further prepared. For example, cornbread mix will provide as purchased data on
the unprepared mix and may also provide as served data on the mix when prepared
according to package instructions.
Food Products Used “As Purchased”
For ready-to-serve products, i.e., foods that only require
chilling, heating and/or portioning and are used as
purchased, use the nutrient data exactly as provided on
the food product and enter it into the ingredient
database.
HELPFUL TIP
When entering new ingredients,
always indicate whether the
nutrient data is “as purchased”
or “as served,” and indicate the
cooking method.
Food Products Prepared According to Manufacturer’s
“As Served” Nutrient Information
When a manufacturer provides as served nutrient analysis information, specifies the cooking
method, and the school foodservice prepares the food exactly according to directions, use the
nutrient data exactly as provided on the food product and enter it into the ingredient database.
Food Products Requiring Further Preparation
For purchased products that do require further preparation, if the manufacturer has not
provided “as served” nutrient information, or the SFA uses a differing preparation method, the
user must develop a recipe for this prepared ingredient. This will be further described in
Chapter 8.
Pre-Publication Copy
19
STEP 3
Adding Recipes to the Local Database
Select the correct food items from the database for each recipe in the menus. The person who
adds recipes to the software for the nutrient analysis must have knowledge of the foods that
are purchased and how they will be prepared and served in order to select the correct item for
the recipes. The software, including the CN Database, contains multiple entries (and different
nutrient content) of the same food item, based on the varieties, types, and forms of the food
item and different preparation methods.
Recipes are nutritionally analyzed based on the form in which the food is consumed. If quantity
recipes include raw ingredients that will be cooked or further prepared before consuming, they
will need conversion to the edible form of the ingredient. This is referred to as the Yield Factor
Method and will be further discussed in Chapter 8.
Basic Rules for the Yield Factor Method
•
Use the form and portion of the food as offered.
•
Select raw if not heated or cooked.
•
Select cooked (or a cooked preparation method)
if cooked before serving, using the database
food code for the cooked ingredient.
Convert or adjust the amount of the raw ingredient in
the recipe by using a yield factor from the Food Buying
Guide. Some commonly used cooked food products in
schools have a raw-to-cooked conversion factor
included in the software. If this option is available, it will
eliminate the need to convert the raw weight to the
cooked yield.
What is the Yield Factor Method?
Yield Factor Method is a method for
nutrient analysis of recipes that
requires that each raw ingredient be
converted and entered into the
recipe database as ready-to-serve or
cooked.
If the database does not include rawto-cooked yield information for a
specific ingredient, use yield data
from USDA’s Food Buying Guide for
Child Nutrition Programs to convert
from the raw to the cooked form.
STEP 4
Entering Specific Menu Planning Data
The order of this process may differ between software programs, but the data needed to
complete the nutrient analysis is common among programs.
•
Identify menu name(s) or site names and associated age/grade group for each menu
type offered.
Pre-Publication Copy
20
•
Identify menu or meal type, such as breakfast or lunch.
•
Develop individual menus or link to cycle menus.
•
Assign dates to menus and determine a date range for each nutrient analysis, as defined
by the school week.
•
Determine the number of servings of reimbursable meals and the serving sizes of food
or menu items.
•
Create the reports for review.
STEP 5
Evaluating and Modifying Menus and Recipes to Comply with Dietary Specifications
Requirements
•
Review menus for variety.
•
Review the weekly nutrient analyses, noting Dietary Specifications that have not been
met.
•
If necessary, modify the menus to meet the Dietary Specifications.
•
Reanalyze menus when menus/food items change, products change, recipes change, or
when participation or student selections change.
Pre-Publication Copy
21
Chapter 6:
Preparing for a Nutrient Analysis
CHAPTER OBJECTIVES
After reading this chapter, you will understand how to:
• Collect the necessary materials and information for conducting a nutrient analysis.
• Collect nutrient data or information for food items that are not listed in the CN Database.
Information and Materials Needed for Nutrient Analyses
Whether you are an SFA conducting your own analysis, or a State agency conducting analysis
during an Administrative Review, you will need to have the following materials ready and
available to conduct an accurate nutrient analysis.
1. Menus
When the State agency conducts a nutrient analysis as part of an Administrative Review of an
SFA, State staff will choose one week within the review period to evaluate the dietary
specifications for breakfast and lunch at the selected school. The site is selected based on
results from the Meal Compliance Risk Assessment Tool. The State agency will collect the menu
documentation for each USDA established age/grade group and menu types offered at
breakfast and lunch and conduct a weighted nutrient analysis of all menu and food items,
including condiments, offered as part of the reimbursable meal. In other words, a separate
nutrient analysis is required for each age/grade group at the selected review site and if the
review site has different menu offerings for different segments of students in the school,
separate analyses are required for each population segment.
Example:
A school serving 6-12 graders plans two different lunch menus, one menu for 6-8 and another
menu for 9-12. In this case, the school is offering two different lunch menus for different
segments of students in the school. The SA will need to conduct two weighted nutrient
analyses for lunch: one for the 6-8th grade students and one for 9-12th grade students to
ensure each menu type meets the dietary specifications.
If the SFA or school district is conducting its own nutrient analysis of menus — the SFA will need
a complete set of draft or tentative menus prepared for data entry. Written menus should
Pre-Publication Copy
22
include all menu or food choices with portion sizes to be served to each USDA established
grade/age groupings and menu type for breakfast and lunch.
Most SFAs plan centralized cycle menus. School districts that conduct nutrient analyses find that
cycle menus, repeated on a periodic basis, save time and resources. For purposes of the
Administrative Review, nutrient analyses must be for the targeted menu review site only, not a
SFA-wide nutrient analysis.
2. Standardized Recipes
In order to ensure that the nutrient analysis reflects what is offered, all schools must use
standardized recipes. Standardized recipes are those that have been tried and tested and found
to be acceptable to students, have the same ingredients and method of preparation, and
provide a consistent yield.
Standardized recipes should be available for input into the nutrient analysis software or be
available to provide to the State agency during an Administrative Review.
3. Food Product Descriptions or Specifications
The school district should have written food product descriptions or specifications for all foods
used in the schools — not only as a purchasing tool but also for determining which product or
ingredient to select from the software for the analysis.
School districts that use procurement software
can provide food product descriptions for each
food product. This allows the school
district/school menu planner or State agency
staff to select the correct ingredient from the
software database when conducting nutrient
analysis.
Examples of Food Product Descriptions:
•
•
Ground beef, frozen, no more than 20% fat
Milk, unflavored, 1% low-fat
4. Nutrient Data or Information for Food Products Not in the Database
Identify food products not in the CN Database or in your software’s local database.
•
Review menus and the standardized recipes to be used for the preparation of the
menus.
•
Compare to the software to determine if all food items or ingredients are included.
Pre-Publication Copy
23
For single ingredient foods or foods in the USDA Food Buying Guide, the nutrient data for most
products will already be in the CN Database. Examples of single ingredient foods are fruits,
vegetables, and milk.
For food products with more than one ingredient, the food may be in the CN Database or it may
not, depending upon whether the food has a standard of identity or the product manufacturer
has submitted the product information for inclusion in the CN Database. Some software
manufacturers also include a limited number of commercially prepared products in their
ingredient database. These will be labeled as Local.
•
If the product is not in the CN Database or your software’s local database, you will need
to locate the nutrient information for the product.
•
Sources of nutrient data other than CN Database are:
o Nutrition Facts Labels, often found on institutional-sized product packaging, even
though they are not required. A sample Nutrition Facts Label is shown in
Appendix E.
o Nutrient data provided by the manufacturer. A nutrient analysis data form you
can ask the manufacturer to complete is included in Appendix F.
o Nutrient analysis data from another reliable source, such as USDA’s Nutrient
Database for Standard Reference, available at: http://ndb.nal.usda.gov/
5. Food Production Records
All SFAs/schools are required to document the foods served to students as part of a
reimbursable meal. In addition to ensuring that meals served adhere to meal requirements,
production records also provide valuable information for conducting nutrient analyses of foods
offered to children.
Food production records must include:
•
Number of reimbursable meals planned, offered, and actually served;
•
All menu items (or food items) planned, offered, and served for reimbursable meals
including milk type(s) and condiments/accompaniments;
•
Portion or serving sizes for each age/grade group;
•
Recipes used (note if USDA recipe, or local recipe);
•
Brand names, CN label numbers (if desired), and identification numbers of commercially
prepared food products;
Pre-Publication Copy
24
•
Total amounts of foods planned, offered, and actually selected/served;
•
Documentation of a la carte, adult, and/or other non-reimbursable meals, including
number of portions for each of these food items; and
•
Documentation of substitutions and/or leftovers used.
Planned, Offered & Selected/Served: what’s the difference?
Planned: A planned menu is what the menu planner intends to offer to students.
Offered: An offered menu is what is actually prepared and set out on the line(s) for students. Offered menus may
differ from “planned” menus because, for example, a planned food item was not received and the menu planner
had to offer a different food item.
Selected/Served: Selected refers to which food items were actually taken by students.
A Menu Planner for Healthy School Meals (revised edition forthcoming) provides more
information on documenting food production records and provides several sample food
production record forms. Additionally, many State agencies have developed State prototypes or
sample food production records for use by school districts/schools within the State. Several
foodservice software companies—including companies that have approved nutrient analysis
software—have software applications that can be used for creating computerized school-level
food production records.
Pre-Publication Copy
25
Chapter 7:
Entering Food Items (Ingredients) into the Local
Database
CHAPTER OBJECTIVES
After reading this chapter, you will understand how to:
• Enter food items/ingredients into the local database, step-by-step.
• Delete and modify ingredients in the local database.
How to Enter Data for New Food Products or Ingredients
By this time, all of the recipes and food items or ingredients to be used in the nutrient analysis
should have been identified.
Unless the food product description found in the CN Database or local software database
exactly matches the food item your SFA/school is using, you’ll need to create a new entry for
each food item or ingredient using the nutrient data you obtained, and save it in the SFA local
database.
Steps for entering new food items/ingredients into the software
database:
Follow directions provided by your software program to add a food item or ingredient. The
following are general steps to enter a new food item or
ingredient.
STEP 1
Assign each new food product an identification number
Some software applications allow the user to assign an
identification number while others assign identification numbers
automatically. Some software also marks locally entered food
items with a specific code. Enter an identification number for the
new food item/ingredient or use the number assigned by your
software.
Pre-Publication Copy
HELPFUL TIP
Some State agency staff and
SFAs find it helpful to write the
database identification code
number next to each
ingredient on the copied
standardized recipes. This
helps identify ingredients that
are missing in the database
and reduces data entry time.
26
STEP 2
Enter a description of the food item/ingredient
Give the food item/ingredient a basic name and then add a short description that will help you
locate and identify this food item/ingredient in the future (e.g., fully-cooked, frozen, raw).
Some people find it helpful to include the brand name in the description.
STEP 3
Enter a food category for the food item/ingredient
Assigning a food category makes it easier to conduct a search for the food items.
STEP 4
Identify the source of the data as “Local.”
For any food item entered by the local user, the source is always identified as “Local.”
STEP 5
If the product is commercially prepared, enter the name of the manufacturer and/or
brand name.
The brand name of a commercially prepared product can be very important in ensuring that the
correct food item/ingredient is chosen from the database.
STEP 6
Enter the unit(s) of measurement for the food item/ingredient.
Add weight measure(s) for all different sized portions and/or weight/volume measures, if
appropriate. It is important that the user enter correct measurement information from the
label or other document, as all conversions are based on
this entry(s). For items served by volume, a weight/volume
relationship must be established. To perform a nutrient
analysis of a certain volume of fruit and/or vegetable, you
KEY POINT
must enter a volume measure and the weight associated
The software cannot calculate the
with that volume.
Refer to the product information from the Nutrition Facts
Label/manufacturer’s nutrient data information, the Food
Buying Guide and other resources3 that will allow you to
determine the serving size description, in weight, and if
appropriate, corresponding volume.
Pre-Publication Copy
nutrient analysis of a volume measure
unless the weight of a volume
measure (e.g., teaspoon, tablespoon,
cup) is provided by the user.
27
Adding Food Items or Ingredients to Your Database
STEP 7
Enter the nutrient composition information
•
Enter the base weight (the weight of the food
item/ingredient for which the nutrient data has been
provided). The base weight/nutrient content can be
found on the Nutrition Facts Label or the
manufacturer’s nutrient data statement.
Other Helpful Resources:
•
•
•
Bowes and Church, Food Values of
Portions Commonly Used
Molt, Food for Fifty
USDA, Nutrient Database for
Standard Reference, available at:
http://ndb.nal.usda.gov/
•
Enter the serving size description associated with the
base weight (oz, cup, each).
•
Enter the actual values for calories, saturated fat, and sodium for the base weight.
Pre-Publication Copy
28
•
If the Nutrition Facts Label or the manufacturer’s nutrient data statement indicates
there is an insignificant amount of a nutrient, enter zero “O” for the nutrient value.
•
It is not necessary to enter the information for water or ash for nutrient analysis;
however, if the information is available, it provides a more accurate analysis of the
product’s weight.
KEY POINT
If there is no information for a required nutrient, follow the software directions to mark it as missing
nutrient information. Do not enter zero “0” for missing nutrient information because:
1. You will not be able to identify missing data, and
2. The nutrient analysis will be inaccurate.
STEP 8
Review data entry for accuracy and save the data
Before saving the data, review each entry to ensure that the data has been entered correctly.
Follow your software instructions for saving entered data.
STEP 9
Create a report of ingredients and recheck for accuracy
Most of the software programs allow the user to print the food item/ingredient information in
various ways — alphabetically, by local food items/ingredients only, by food items/ingredients
used in recipes only, and by missing nutrient data. This is a good way to check the accuracy of
the data entry and to identify food items/ingredients with missing data.
To modify or delete ingredients, you must be in the modify/edit mode
Only food items entered by the local user in the local database may be modified or deleted.
• To modify an existing ingredient in the local database
o Locate the product in the database, and
o Repeat steps 2 through 7.
•
To delete or deactivate a local food product from the database, follow the software
instructions for deleting food products.
Pre-Publication Copy
29
Chapter 8:
Adding a Recipe to the Local Database
CHAPTER OBJECTIVES
After reading this chapter, you will understand how to:
• Select the correct food items and correct measures of foods for recipes.
• Determine the difference between cook’s recipes and recipes for nutrient analysis.
• Describe the Yield Factor Method using the Food Buying Guide when analyzing a recipe’s nutrient content.
• Adjust moisture and fat loss or gain in selected commercially prepared products.
How the Nutrient Analyses of USDA Recipes Were Calculated
As discussed earlier, for USDA recipes, only the nutrients, not the production recipes, are
included in the CN Database and the approved nutrient analysis software. It is important for the
menu planner to understand the protocols used to analyze these recipes.
•
Based on first ingredient only. When USDA recipes show alternate ingredient choices,
the nutrient analysis is based on the first ingredient listed, not the alternate ingredient.
For example:
Recipe D-13 Beef or Pork Taco
Raw ground beef or raw ground pork is listed as an ingredient. The nutrient analysis in
the CN Database is based on the first ingredient listed, raw ground beef. Therefore, if
the SFA/school uses raw ground pork, or a combination of ground beef and ground
turkey to prepare this recipe, a new recipe must be entered in the software or the
recipe may be copied into a local recipe and edited. It is important that the recipe be
entered as it is prepared so the nutrient analysis is accurate.
•
Optional ingredients are not included. The nutrient analysis in the CN Database
does not include any ingredients listed as optional in the recipe.
For example:
Pre-Publication Copy
30
Recipe D-20 Chili Con Carne with Beans
Cheddar cheese is an optional ingredient in this recipe and was not included in the
nutrient analysis. If cheddar cheese is included as an ingredient in the recipe, the recipe
including cheddar cheese must be entered into the local recipe software database and
the nutrient analysis recalculated. The user may also copy the existing recipe and edit
accordingly to reflect the ingredients actually used.
•
Variations of some, but not all USDA Recipes are included in the CN Database.
For example:
Recipe B-4 Baking Powder Biscuits
Four variations are included:
1. B-4a Baking Powder Biscuit using Master Mix
2. B-4b Cheese Biscuits
3. B-4c Drop Biscuits
4. B-4d Wheat Biscuits
If the school district/school is using a variation of a recipe that is not in the software, a
new recipe with the recipe variation must be entered into the local software database
and the nutrient analysis recalculated.
KEY POINT
Some software companies enter the USDA recipes as production (cook’s) recipes, including ingredients, into the
local database of their approved nutrient analysis software. This data entry may help schools easily modify the
recipe for variations using alternate, optional, or unique ingredients. The user can simply copy and edit the
recipe, instead of entering the entire recipe with the alternate ingredient or variation. State agencies and SFAs
must review these recipes to ensure they have been entered according to nutrient analysis protocols, including
yield factors. Some approved nutrient analysis software programs have functionality that allows the yield factors
to be incorporated into the recipe. The recipes may lead to an inaccurate analysis after it is copied, unless it is
edited by the user. Your software developer can help you follow their instructions for correctly entering recipes
to result in an accurate nutrient analysis.
Pre-Publication Copy
31
Selecting the Correct Food Items/Ingredients for Recipes
To ensure the correct calorie and nutritive value of the recipe, it is important to select the
correct food item/ingredient from the software database. The nutrient content of raw foods is
different from the nutrient content of cooked foods.
Recipes that require cooking are a challenge for nutrient analysis because the recipes contain
raw ingredients, and yet we eat cooked products. Cooking changes the nutrient content, the
moisture content, and, very frequently, the fat content.
Cooks’ or Production Recipes Versus Recipes for
Nutrient Analysis
Important: Recipes for nutrient analysis and cooks’ or
production recipes are usually different.
•
•
•
•
The amount of calories and nutrients in a food will
vary depending on the edible portion of the food
and whether the food is raw or cooked.
The ingredients in your standardized recipes or
cooks’ recipes usually indicate foods in their raw
form, as purchased, including peel, bone, skin, etc.
For nutrient analysis purposes, recipes must
include only the edible portion of a food.
Thus, the ingredient information in recipes must
be adjusted or converted to reflect what is
actually consumed.
KEY POINT
Individuals performing nutrient
analyses must have knowledge of the
foods that are purchased, and how
they will be prepared and offered, to
select the correct database item. The
CN Database contains multiple entries
(and nutrient content profiles) of the
same food item, based on the
varieties, types, and forms of the food
item and different preparation
methods.
Using the Yield Factor Method
After selecting the correct ingredient for the recipe, the SFA/State agency will need to use the
Yield Factor Method to convert the raw, frozen, condensed, or dehydrated food item to the
form the item will be when consumed. There are numerous food items or ingredients that need
to be converted to an edible version such as raw meats, raw and frozen vegetables, and dried
pasta that will be cooked before consumption.
Heat affects the nutrient content of many foods. The nutrient profiles of database foods
described as cooked have been adjusted for the nutrient changes that occur with cooking. For
Pre-Publication Copy
32
example, the nutritive value of frozen green beans cooked with salt will be different from the
nutritive value of canned green beans, which have been heated.
The Database features a list of nutritive values of foods prepared by various cooking methods.
Cooked foods may be listed, for example, as:
• Boiled
• Broiled
• Baked
• Fried
KEY POINT
The Yield Factor Method requires that each raw recipe ingredient be converted and entered in the recipe database as readyto-serve or cooked. If the database does not have the raw-to-cooked yield for a specific ingredient, use yield data from
USDA’s Food Buying Guide to convert from the raw to the cooked form.
Vegetables
Vegetables that are indicated in the recipe in the as raw or frozen form will need to be
converted to the cooked form because of change in nutrient and in the moisture content upon
heating.
Example: Recipe Using Frozen Whole Green Beans
A recipe calls for 10 pounds of frozen whole green beans to be used to make Green Bean
Casserole. To enter the recipe, you would select the cooked green beans (without salt) from the
database. We selected Beans, Green, Whole, Frozen, Boiled, No Salt (CN Database #11061).
Pre-Publication Copy
33
•
To convert the green beans, as purchased, to an edible amount of cooked green beans
for the nutrient analysis, refer to the Food Buying Guide, page 2-8.
NOTE: The yield and nutritive value
differences are small between
“heated” and “unheated” canned
food items, so menu planners may
use the data for “unheated”
canned food items for nutrient
analysis.
•
The Food Buying Guide indicates that each pound of frozen green beans yields 0.88
pounds of cooked, drained green beans.
10 pounds X 0.88 = 8.8 pounds of cooked green beans
Pre-Publication Copy
34
•
The menu planner would select CN database, number 11061, Beans, Green, Whole,
Frozen, Boiled, No Salt and enter a weight of 8.8 pounds of cooked green beans into the
Green Bean Casserole recipe.
Fresh Vegetables in Cooked Recipes
There are several fresh vegetables that are frequently added to school recipes made from
scratch. To expedite the conversion of these vegetables from raw-to-cooked, conversion from
yield data in the Food Buying Guide of 1 pound raw-to-cooked is provided in Appendix G.
Meats
There are a number of factors that must be considered in entering recipes that contain raw
meat for nutrient analysis. Remember, the recipe must be analyzed to reflect the nutrients in
the recipe that the children will actually consume (Yield Factor Method).
When there is “Raw-to-cooked yield” in the database:
Several of the meat items in the software database have a conversion factor built in for raw-tocooked data. For those items, the computer
will calculate the nutritive value of the cooked
yield when the amount of raw meat in the
recipe is entered.
KEY POINT
When raw-to-cooked data is available, a user
would:
1. Select the “cooked” meat item from the
database,
The Yield Factor Method uses cooked ingredients for raw
foods in recipes that are cooked, and adjusting the amount of
ingredient in the recipe by using yield data from the approved
software program, or USDA’s Food Buying Guide. The “cooked
codes” and cooked yields will reflect the losses or gains in
moisture and fat, and the effect of cooking on other nutrients.
2. Select yield after cooking, raw-to-cooked,
raw, raw yields, or other language used by
your software program that indicates you may enter a raw weight,
3. Enter the weight of the raw meat as indicated in the recipe, and
4. The analysis will be calculated by the software using the nutritive values and cooked weight
conversion from raw weight.
When there is no “raw-to-cooked yield” in the database:
What if the software does not indicate that you can enter the raw weight of the meat? In that
case, you must convert the raw weight in the recipe to the cooked or edible weight, using the
Yield Factor Method.
Pre-Publication Copy
35
To convert raw weight to edible or cooked weight, a user would:
1. Select the cooked meat item from the database,
2. Convert the raw weight to the edible or cooked weight by multiplying the raw weight of the
meat called for in the recipe by the percent yield in the Food Buying Guide (Column 6)
3. Enter the cooked weight into the computer
Example of converting raw-to-cooked yield for Beef Stew:
Recipe for Beef Stew
An SFA/school is serving a recipe for beef stew which calls for 21 lbs. of raw stew meat (the
recipe calls for browning the meat and draining the fat) and there is no raw-to-cooked yield for
beef stew in their database. For the nutrient analysis, staff would check the USDA Food Buying
Guide for the cooked yield of stew meat (61 percent), calculate the cooked weight, and enter
that figure along with the cooked item for, stew meat, such as CN Database item would be
#23090, Beef, Chuck for Stew, separable lean and fat. This example is shown below:
To correctly enter this recipe for nutrient analysis, the user would enter the correct
identification code for cooked beef stew meat (23090) or find cooked beef stew meat through
the search feature. Then enter 12.81 pounds.
“As Purchased” vs. “Edible Portion” of Chicken (without bones and or skin)
The nutritive value of a three-ounce portion of cooked chicken with the skin and bones will be
different from the nutritive value of a three-ounce portion of cooked boneless chicken.
Pre-Publication Copy
36
If a recipe calls for 25 lbs of raw chicken thighs to be baked and served with the skin, you must
convert the 25 lbs. of as purchased raw chicken thighs to the equivalent weight of the baked
meat and skin only.
To enter the correct chicken ingredient into the recipe, select CN Database # 5094, Chicken,
Thigh, Roasted, with Skin, and enter: 13 pounds.
The Food Buying Guide also contains as purchased to edible portion yield data for cooked
chicken without skin.
Exception to Use of Yield Factor Method for Some Cooked Meats
There is an exception to the rule of choosing a cooked meat item from the database and
calculating the cooked meat yield. When you are entering a recipe where the fat will remain in
the final product, you must select the raw meat database item and enter the weight of the raw
meat into the recipe for analysis.
For example, if you are analyzing a recipe for Red Beans with Sausage, and the recipe
instructions specify to slice the uncooked sausage and add it to the beans during cooking, you
need to select the raw sausage data and the weight of the raw product. This is because the fat
which would normally have cooked out and been drained off will remain in the final product.
(This is a good example of a recipe that should be modified using either the cooking method
and/or ingredients, to reduce saturated fat.)
Other examples of situations where you would choose the raw meat database item and enter
the weight of the raw meat into the recipe for analysis include recipes for soups or stews where
raw meat is added to the soup or stew and the fat contained in the raw meat ends up in the
final product. However, if the soup or stew is chilled after preparation and the fat is skimmed
off the top, it is appropriate to choose the cooked meat item from the database and enter the
cooked weight of the meat.
Pre-Publication Copy
37
Dried Pasta
Determining Cooked Volume of Dried Pasta
A recipe for Spaghetti and Marinara Sauce calls for cooking the dried pasta in boiling salted
water prior to combining it with the sauce. This presents a difficult situation for nutrient
analysis because the pasta does not absorb the total amount of either the boiling water or the
salt during cooking. This problem can be resolved by selecting Spaghetti, Cooked, Enriched,
with Added Salt from the CN Database, item number 20321. But first, the weight of the dried
pasta has to be converted to the appropriate amount of cooked pasta, using the Yield Factor
Method. The water and salt used in the recipe are not included in the computer data entry for
the nutrient analysis.
The user would select the Spaghetti, Cooked, Enriched, with Added Salt from the CN Database
(#20321) and enter: 21 cups of cooked spaghetti.
Exception: If the pasta is cooked in and absorbs recipe liquid, the dry pasta would be the
appropriate item to select and the dry weight of the pasta would be entered. For example, a
recipe for Lasagna with Ground Beef calls for the lasagna noodles to be cooked in the tomato
sauce. In this case, dried lasagna noodles would be the selected and the dry weight of the
noodles called for in the recipe would be entered.
Adjusting Moisture and Fat Loss or Gain in Commercially Prepared Food Products
Many commercially prepared food products, such as frozen French fries, chicken nuggets, and
fish portions, will undergo further preparation in the school kitchen.
The most common preparation technique is oven heating (bringing a fully-cooked product to
the proper serving temperature). Because oven heating generally has minimal impact on
moisture or fat loss, fully cooked, prepared food products that are only oven heated do not
Pre-Publication Copy
38
need adjustment for fat/moisture loss. However, these same products may have significant
moisture loss and fat gain during deep-frying.
Although healthier preparation methods are encouraged, software already contains some fried
food items that reflect moisture loss and fat gains which occur during deep frying. For example,
if an SFA uses generic frozen French fried potatoes and deep-fat fries them in commodity
vegetable oil, the best selection from the CN Database would be Item 50491, Potatoes, Frenchfried, with salt, oven heated.
Users may select this existing item rather than entering data
on the French fries you are purchasing and adjusting for
moisture loss and fat gain, since this item description already
reflects moisture loss and fat absorption.
HELPFUL TIP
Always check the software first
and use the item that reflects
the cooking method for the
food item.
However, there are commercially prepared products that
may not be available in the software as a deep-fried version. If you serve a commercially
prepared product which will be deep fried, and it is not in the database, you will need to create
a recipe that can be adjusted for moisture losses and fat gains which occur with frying (unless
the Nutrition Facts Label or the manufacturer has provided “as served” data using the method
of cooking and/or other preparation that will be used in the school kitchen. In this case, the
food item can be entered directly into the ingredient database).
The software will allow the user to enter the type of fat and percentages of moisture and fat
losses directly into the recipe and make the calculations. Assume zero (0) moisture/fat change
for food items that are only heated/reheated.
Refer to Appendix H to obtain common moisture losses and fat gains during deep-frying, and
incorporate this information into the recipe.
KEY POINT
If a recipe for the fried product will need to be developed because there is no nutrient data available for
moisture loss or fat gain, the database food/ingredient code for the commercially prepared food product,
the database food/ingredient code for the type of fat used in frying, and the percentages of moisture loss
and fat gain will have to be entered in the recipe.
Pre-Publication Copy
39
Selecting the Correct Measure of a Food
Volume vs. Weight
When selecting data for the nutrient analysis, ensure the correct measure of food is selected.
The unit of measure entered will depend on how the food is used in the recipe or menu. When
selecting data, be sure the correct measure of food is entered, for example, teaspoon, gram,
cup, gallon, pound or fluid ounce. If weight measures (oz, lb) are available for a recipe, it is
more accurate to enter the weight measure.
When selecting the correct measure of a food, it is critical to know whether the food is
measured by weight or by volume. Any measure that is listed as ounce will be a weight
measure, unless it is specifically designated as fluid ounces (fl. oz.) in the software. Weight
measures include grams, ounces, and pounds. Volume measures will be listed as teaspoons,
tablespoons, fluid ounces, cups, pints, quarts, and gallons.
The chart below demonstrates nutrient analysis errors that can occur when volume measures
are confused with weight measures.
Example: Selecting the Correct Measurement
Menu Items:
1/2 cup Raisin Bran
3/4 cup Canned Peaches
1 cup Spaghetti
Weight
Volume
(Incorrectly Entered)
(Correctly Entered)
Raisin Bran
4 oz. = 356 calories
½ cup = 79 calories
Peaches
6 oz. = 92 calories
¾ cup = 102 calories
Spaghetti
8 oz. = 359
1 cup = 221 calories
NOTE: 4 oz. = ¼ pound (not ½ cup); 6 oz. = 3/8 pound (not ¾ cup); 8 oz. = ½ pound (not 1 cup)
½ cup = 4 fluid ounces; ¾ cup = 6 fluid ounces; 1 cup = 8 fluid ounces
With all of these considerations in mind, the user can now begin to enter the data for a local
recipe.
Steps to Entering a Local Recipe
You must follow your software directions as these directions may vary from software program
to program.
STEP 1
Pre-Publication Copy
40
Enter recipe number
Most software programs will automatically assign a number as each new recipe is added.
STEP 2
Enter the recipe name
For software that bases the “search” feature on the first word of the recipe name, it is
important to develop a system that will help you locate your recipes. For example, a recipe for
Baked Chicken could be listed as Chicken, Baked. This will allow you to find your recipe by
searching “chicken”. Refer to your software instructions for information about how to search in
your software.
STEP 3
Identify the recipe category
For example, Entrees, Salads, Vegetables. This will also help if you need to search for a recipe.
STEP 4
Identify the source of the recipe
STEP 5
Enter the serving or portion size
For example, 1/2 cup, 2.25 oz. patty, 2” x 3” rectangle, 1 each.
Pre-Publication Copy
41
STEP 6
Enter the number of servings the recipe makes (yield)
STEP 7
Select the correct food items/ingredients from the software (or software program’s
database) and enter the correct amount
•
•
•
View the food ingredients listed in the software.
Select the correct food items or ingredients from the software.
Enter the correct amount of each ingredient according to previous directions for the
Yield Factor Method.
STEP 8
If applicable, enter the type of fat used for deep-frying and the percent moisture loss
or fat gain for the recipe
Follow your software directions for entering this information. Refer to Appendix H for percent
moisture loss or fat gains for selected products.
STEP 9
Compare the recipe entered in the software with your printed recipe to be sure that:
•
•
•
•
•
the yield is correct,
the serving size is correct,
all ingredients are included,
the correct food items were selected from the software’s ingredient databases, and
the amount of each ingredient is correct using the Yield Factor Method.
KEY POINT
Selecting the correct food item from the database is critical to accurate nutrient analysis. For example, if
the SFA uses a firm hydrogenated soybean oil margarine but a soft corn oil margarine is selected from the
CN Database, the nutrient analysis will be inaccurate.
STEP 10
Save the recipe
STEP 11
Check the recipe for data entry errors
Pre-Publication Copy
42
(See the section below on How the Software Calculates Recipes) This comparison can help to
identify if there has been an error in the data entry of the recipe.
STEP 12
Print the recipe, including nutrient analysis
How the Software Calculates the Nutrient Analysis
When recipes are entered into the software, both a serving size and a recipe yield (the number
of servings a recipe makes) are entered. It is important to know that the software calculates the
nutrients in a serving based on the number of servings in the recipe (the yield), not based on the
size of the serving entered. In addition, total nutrients in the recipe are divided by the number
of servings to get the “per serving” analysis.
If the recipe has been entered accurately using the Yield Factor Method, the gram weight of
one serving as calculated by the software should be close to the average actual gram weight of
one serving.
CAUTION: Remember the software calculates a nutrient analysis by the yield (number of servings). When
recipe ingredients or quantities are changed, the recipe yield is frequently changed. You must re-standardize the
recipe, recalculate yield and enter a corrected yield, if applicable.
Checking Recipes for Error
The comparison of the gram weight of one serving as calculated by the computer with the
actual average gram weight of one serving can be used to flag a recipe for possible errors. It is
expected that there will be some variation in the two weights because nutrient analysis is not
an exact science, and moisture loss may not always be accurately reflected in the calculations.
A significant discrepancy between the two weights may indicate one of the following:
•
an error in data entry, the recipe has not been standardized and either the yield or the
serving size is inaccurate, or
•
the Yield Factor Method has not been followed.
If the recipe is portioned using a scoop or measuring spoon, you probably do not know the
weight of an average serving.
The following procedures can be used to calculate the weight of one serving of a recipe.
Pre-Publication Copy
43
•
Prepare the recipe and carefully portion out 5 servings using the stated portion size.
Using a gram scale, weigh each serving.
•
Add the serving weights and divide the total by 5. This will give you an "average” serving
weight.
•
To get a better estimate of true serving weight, 2 persons should do the portioning and
weighing of 5 samples each.
OR
Prepare the recipe, weigh the total quantity produced (minus weight of container) and
divide by the number of servings (yield) of the recipe.
Creating a Recipe Variation
USDA Recipe Variations for Optional Ingredient(s)
When the school district/school is preparing a USDA recipe exactly as written with the only
exception that they are simply adding an ingredient(s) that is listed as “optional” in the recipe
(e.g., adding the optional ingredient, raisins, to Applesauce Cake), a new recipe should be
created and named.
Example: Applesauce Cake with Raisins
Source: Local
Because the nutrient profiles of all USDA Recipes are incorporated into the CN Database, the
user would select the USDA recipe as a food item in the software’s ingredient database and add
it to the new recipe as a recipe ingredient. Then the user would need only to add the optional
ingredient(s) to this new local recipe.
USDA Recipe Variation for Alternate Ingredient(s) or Other Modifications
When the SFA/school prepares a USDA recipe using an alternate ingredient(s) or make other
changes to the recipe, you will need to create a new recipe using the Yield Factor Method by
entering the ingredients and their amounts and saving it as a different recipe. Or, if the
software company has entered the USDA recipes with its ingredients, you may copy the
appropriate USDA recipe and review it carefully for accuracy. Then, following the Yield Factor
Method, you may change the ingredient(s) and/or amount(s) as needed, and name and save it
as a different recipe.
Pre-Publication Copy
44
Modifying a Local Standardized Recipe
When adding a recipe variation such as alternate or optional ingredients to an existing recipe,
you may modify the original recipe and then resave it. If you want to keep both recipe
variations, you may copy the original recipe, make changes, rename, and save the recipe.
When local recipes are entered and saved to the recipe database in the software, you can:
•
•
Change, add or delete food ingredients and amounts.
Change preparation or serving instructions.
Single Serving Recipes
In addition, for nutrient analysis, recipes can be made for single servings, for example 1/2 cup
French fries, 1 beef patty, 1 hotdog and bun. The software is required to calculate the
ingredient amounts for a different number of servings for a recipe.
Creating a Theme Bar Recipe
Salad bars and other food bars, such as pasta bars, taco bars, deli bars, potato bars, and such
can serve as the complete reimbursable lunch (except for milk) or as a food or menu item that
is part of a reimbursable lunch depending on the food items on the bar and how it is structured.
The recipe and nutrient analysis of the food bar is based on historical usage of food bar items.
Standardized recipes can be developed for food bars and entered into the software. The recipe
should be constructed based on a “typical day”.
To develop a standardized recipe for a theme bar:
Step 1: Determine the number of servings the recipe produces (yield). This would be the
number of people who use the food bar, regardless of whether by students for reimbursable
meals, by adults, or for a la carte sales.
Step 2: Determine the serving size. The serving size is the minimum quantity that the student
must select to meet the meal pattern for the reimbursable meal. For example, for an entree
salad, the minimum quantity might be 1 cup.
Step 3: Determine the amount of each ingredient in the recipe:
•
Measure the amount of each ingredient placed on the food bar on a typical day (the
amounts placed on the bar at the beginning of the meal service plus any additions to the
bar during the meal service).
Pre-Publication Copy
45
•
Measure the amount of each ingredient left over on the food bar at the end of the meal
service.
•
Subtract the amount left over from the amount placed on the food bar for each
ingredient to determine the amount of each ingredient to enter for the recipe.
After the recipe is entered into the database, it can be used in planning or analyzing a day’s
menu. The number of servings entered into the menu for nutrient analysis would be the
estimated number of students who are expected to select a reimbursable meal from the food
bar (or the estimated number of servings of the menu item which will be selected as part of a
reimbursable meal, if the food bar does not offer a full meal).
A separate recipe must be developed for each variation of the food bar. For example, if you
rotate two salad bars, one that features iceberg lettuce and another that features fresh
spinach, two separate recipes need to be developed. If other ingredients vary, each separate
combination would need a separate recipe.
Shortcut Hints for Data Entry for Menu Analysis: Creating Recipes to
Simplify Data Entry
Most software allows you to create sub-menus of items served frequently together, such as
milk or condiments/accompaniments and the sub-menus can be added to a menu.
In addition to your own standardized recipes that you will be entering in your software, there
are “recipes” that you can create to make data entry speedier. These “recipes” are not actually
recipes for food production but are data-entry shortcuts for analyzing menus. The use of
shortcut data entry recipes will reduce the amount of data entry for each menu. These are
menu item choices that do not vary from day to day and which have usage that has been
documented to be consistent.
This shortcut is illustrated for milk:
•
A school district’s menus have consistent choices for milk, and consistent student
selection from one meal to the next.
•
Because weighted averaging is required, the milk shortcut data entry recipe must be
based on the choices of milk available and the percentages consistently chosen.
Example for Weighted Averaging:
Three kinds of milk are offered every day: unflavored low-fat milk (1%), chocolate nonfat milk,
and unflavored nonfat milk. Based on historical data, 25% of the milk offered (1/2 pint cartons)
were unflavored low-fat milk (1%), 50% were chocolate nonfat milk, 25% were unflavored
nonfat milk.
Pre-Publication Copy
46
The Data Entry Shortcut Milk Recipe was created as follows:
For 100 servings:
• 25 - 1/2 pints unflavored low-fat milk (1%),
• 50 - 1/2 pints chocolate nonfat milk
• 25 - 1/2 pints unflavored nonfat milk
KEY POINT
If a SFA/school uses a data entry
shortcut recipe for milk, they
must develop their own recipe
using SFA/school data.
Other Shortcut Data Entry Recipes
Other shortcut data entry recipes for standardized choices can be created if the items offered
do not vary and student choices are consistent (for districts using weighted averages). Some
examples of menu items offered as standardized choices by SFAs/schools include fruit juices,
cold cereals, and assorted salad dressings.
Creating shortcut data entry recipes for condiments/accompaniments is not recommended
unless the exact condiments/accompaniments are offered each day, and students select the
exact percentage of condiments/accompaniments (weighted averaging). Student selection and
usage of condiments/accompaniments usually depends on the day’s menu, so a
condiment/accompaniment shortcut data entry recipe cannot be developed. For example,
students may select catsup more frequently on days that hamburgers and French fries are
offered.
Common Errors in Data Entry of Recipes
•
Incorrect food item or ingredient selected
•
Incorrect measurements, such as weight or volume errors, incorrect recipe serving sizes,
etc.
•
As Purchased weight used rather than Edible Portion (Yield Factor Method not used
correctly)
•
Recipes entered have not been standardized, or standardized recipes have been
analyzed but not used in the SFA/schools.
Reminders:
•
Carefully select the correct food item from the software’s database.
•
Choose the correct measurement, such as volume or weight.
Pre-Publication Copy
47
•
Use cooked weight for cooked foods. (May require conversion from the Food Buying
Guide).
•
Use only standardized recipes that are used in the SFA/schools. For example, a recipe
for rolls must show the added nutrients, if butter or margarine is brushed on top of rolls.
Pre-Publication Copy
48
Chapter 9:
Entering Menu Plans
CHAPTER OBJECTIVES
After reading this chapter, you will understand how to:
• Identify menu (site) names and associated Dietary Specifications for each age/grade group and menu type
offered for breakfast and lunch.
• Determine the number of projected servings using weighted averages.
• Enter the portion size of each menu item.
The various nutrient analysis software programs may have a different order of steps necessary
to establish menu plans for analysis, but the following steps should be common to all the
software.
STEP 1: Identify Menu (Site) Name and Associated Age/Grade Nutrient Standards
Menu (Site) Names
Most software requires a separate data entry menu name or site name for each age/grade
group used by the SFA. Menus are planned to meet the nutrient levels of each USDA
established age/grade group and menu type offered for breakfast and lunch by adjusting the
portion size of each menu item. It may not be necessary to re-enter menus for each age/grade
group. All software allows the user to copy a menu and adjust portions or change menu items
as needed.
Some software allows menus to be created and then allow the menu planner to assign them to
schools (sites) and age/grade groups. Other software requires establishing the menu (site)
name and age/grade group prior to entering menu data. Follow the procedures of your
software.
KEY POINT
Menu Name and Site are terms used by various software programs; the terms may refer to an actual
meal site or it may be used to refer to an age/grade group served at a site.
Pre-Publication Copy
49
Assigning Age/Grade Groups for Each Menu Type
Assign the USDA established age/grade groups and menu type offered to each specific menu
name or site. These age/grade groups have dietary specifications preset in the software.
Examples are:
• K–5
• 6–8
• 9 – 12
The software has been programmed to adjust the dietary specifications to the age/grade
grouping entered.
The SFA/State agency will establish menu names for the age/grade groups and menu types
offered only for the school being reviewed.
Administrative Review
When the State agency conducts a nutrient analysis as part of an Administrative Review of an
SFA, State staff will choose one week within the review period to evaluate the dietary
specifications for breakfast and lunch at the selected school. The site is selected is based on
results from the Meal Compliance Risk Assessment Tool. The State agency will collect the menu
documentation for each USDA established age/grade group and menu types offered at
breakfast and lunch, and conduct a weighted nutrient analysis of all menu and food items
(including condiments) offered as part of the reimbursable meal. In other words, a separate
nutrient analysis is required for each age/grade group at the selected review site and if the
review site has different menu offerings for different segments of students in the school,
separate analyses are required for each population segment.
Example:
A school serving 6-12 graders plans two different lunch menus, one menu for 6-8 and another
menu for 9-12. In this case, the school is offering two different lunch menus for different
segments of students in the school. The SA will need to conduct two weighted nutrient
analyses for lunch: one for the 6-8th grade students and one for 9-12th grade students to
ensure each menu type meets the dietary specifications.
The school selected for review is representative of how the SFA is implementing the meal
pattern. The State agency will assess compliance by comparing the nutrient analysis results to
the Dietary Specifications requirements for the age/grade groups served in the school.
Pre-Publication Copy
50
STEP 2: Identify Menu or Meal Types
The type of meal offered must be entered because there are specific program requirements for
each meal:
• Lunch
• Breakfast
NOTE: State agencies may not combine breakfast and lunch nutrient analyses. Separate
analyses make it easier to identify problems and target technical assistance.
STEP 3: Enter Individual Menus
Entering Individual Menus
The initial process in developing menus is to identify the menu items or recipes to be included
for each menu. The software allows the user to search for the recipes or menu items either by
identification code or by name of food or recipe. The identification code is the number assigned
to each food or recipe. The software will also allow the menu planner to enter the name of the
food or recipe, and it will search for the foods or recipe.
In the example below, the menu planner enters “Beef Stew” as the menu item and searches the
database for the Beef Stew recipe.
Pre-Publication Copy
51
Cycle Menus
A cycle menu is a series of individual menus that are repeated on a periodic basis; they can save
the user time in menu planning, data entry, and analysis. Most software allows the user to
develop and enter cycle menus by means of a series
of pre-numbered menus, and then allows the user
to select and copy these menus to either calendars
or cycles. SFAs may vary in the way they implement
KEY POINT
cycle menus.
State agencies setting up menus for nutrient
Some SFAs may repeat the same set of menus every
analysis during an Administrative Review will
four weeks or so, but have different sets of cycle
only enter menus for the designated school for
menus for fall, winter, and spring. Some SFAs,
the review week.
especially those that do a lot of on-site preparation,
may establish a basic number of menus and then
vary or switch the scheduling of the individual menus depending on the day of the week and
the amount of pre-preparation required.
STEP 4: Assign Dates to Menus and Determine Date Range for Nutrient Analysis
Software allows the user to select and copy menus to either calendars or cycles. The user
determines the date range for analysis. A week for nutrient analysis purposes is 3-7 consecutive
school days. If there are fewer than three consecutive days in a week, the days in that week are
combined with the subsequent or previous week for analysis.
STEP 5: Determine Number of Servings and Serving Sizes (Portions) of Menu Items
Only menu/food items offered as part of reimbursable meals are analyzed. To conduct a
weighted analysis, the user must project the number
of servings for each menu item based on weighted
averages (i.e., give more weight to menu items that
KEY POINT
students select more often).
Weighted averages must be used for nutrient
If the State agency conducts the nutrient analysis for
analyses. This means that all menu items must be
the Administrative Review, it will select one school
weighted, including milk types and
using the Meal Compliance Risk Assessment Tool,
condiments/accompaniments.
request the menu documentation from the school for
the week selected for review, and use the actual
number of offered servings used in reimbursable meals to conduct a weighted analysis.
A More Detailed Explanation of Weighted Averaging
In the following example of weighted averaging, there are three entree choices in the meal. On
average, 200 students normally receive a reimbursable meal for this age/grade grouping in the
Pre-Publication Copy
52
school. A review of past production records of this meal indicates that pizza is more frequently
selected and should be weighted accordingly.
Sample Weighted Averaging Of Three Entrée Choices
For weighted averaging, the total number of offered reimbursable meals with numbers of
servings for each menu item, excluding food items sold as adult meals and a la carte, is required
for each menu.
To conduct weighted nutrient analysis, the reviewer must enter the following items:
•
Total number of offered reimbursable meals for each day of the weekly menu by
age/grade grouping (Example: K - 5, 6 – 8, 9 -12);
•
Portion size(s) for each menu item and condiment/accompaniment for each age/grade
grouping; and
•
Projected number of servings for each portion size of each menu item that will be part
of the day’s reimbursable meal, including milk and condiments/accompaniments and
excluding a la carte and adult servings.
STEP 6: Create Applicable Reports for Review
•
•
Day by Day Analysis
Weekly Analysis
The software allows the user to create various reports as needed to check data entry. These
include a menu spreadsheet indicating weekly analysis. These reports can be reviewed to
identify missing data and/or errors in data entry.
Common Errors in Data Entry of Menus
•
Incorrect food item/recipe selected from database
Pre-Publication Copy
53
•
Portion or serving sizes wrong
•
Numbers for weighted averaging are incorrect
•
Condiments/accompaniments are not entered as menu items, e.g., mayonnaise,
mustard and/or catsup for hamburgers
•
Menu item left off of the nutrient analysis, e.g., bun for hamburger
Reminders:
•
Carefully select the correct food item/recipe from the database. Make sure that all
recipes reflect the currently purchased food items.
•
Choose the correct portion size.
•
Make sure the numbers for production for weighted averaging have been done
correctly.
•
Review data entry to check for all menu items and condiments/accompaniments before
saving menu.
Pre-Publication Copy
54
Chapter 10:
Evaluating and Modifying Menus and Recipes to
Meet the Dietary Specifications
CHAPTER OBJECTIVES
After reading this chapter, you will understand how to:
• Evaluate how well current menus meet the Dietary Specifications.
• Evaluate the menus for variety.
• Modify the menus to meet the Dietary Specifications.
• Include substitutions in the analysis.
• Decide when to adjust future menus.
Evaluate menus
The final process of nutrient analysis is to evaluate the menus and modify accordingly to meet
the Dietary Specifications.
Review daily and weekly nutrient analyses.
1. Evaluate the nutrient analysis of menus
Evaluate how well the current menu meets the Dietary Specifications. This will help to
determine what, if any, changes must be made.
•
•
•
How do the menus compare to the Dietary Specifications? What areas need changes?
Which areas are okay?
Do the menus have calories within an allowable range? Remember the importance of
consistent calorie levels.
Are the menus too high in saturated fat or sodium?
2. Review menus for variety by looking at the frequency with which menu items are
offered
The frequency with which a particular food or type of food is offered will affect the nutrient
content of the menu.
•
•
•
Are a variety of meats/meat alternates, fruits, vegetables, and grains offered?
Are sufficient quantities of vegetables from all the subgroups offered?
What proportions of grains offered are whole grain-rich?
Pre-Publication Copy
55
•
•
•
Should the total number of low fat or low unsaturated fat food or menu items be
increased?
Are too many high sodium items offered?
Can a popular high fat or high sodium item be offered fewer times in a cycle or week?
3. Review Portion Sizes
After making adjustments to how often foods are offered, recheck the nutrient analysis. If there
are still discrepancies, look at the portion size of problem foods next.
•
•
•
•
Can a smaller serving be offered of popular foods that may be contributing too many
calories, or too much saturated fat or sodium?
Can the quantity of a high fat ingredient in a recipe be reduced?
Can a high fat ingredient in a recipe be changed to a lower fat ingredient?
Can the portion size of a menu item be increased to meet minimum calorie levels?
4. Check for “Balance”
Next, look at the balance of foods within each day and the week.
•
•
•
•
•
Are the colors in the menu pleasing to the eye?
Are the food flavor combinations pleasing to the taste?
Does the menu have pleasing contrasts in shapes and sizes, textures, and temperatures?
Are there too many foods high in saturated fat or sodium in the same day or the same
week?
Can a high fat or sodium entree be balanced with low fat or reduced sodium side dishes
or other low fat or reduced sodium entrees during the week?
Using the Nutrient Food Source List
If the Dietary Specifications have still not been met, search the Nutrient Food Source List in the
software to find ideas for menu modification.
This list suggests foods that might be added or substituted in menus in order to increase the
amount of a particular nutrient found to be below the nutrient standard in the week’s
breakfasts or lunches.
When replacing a food, be sure that the levels of the other nutrients in the menu are
maintained. After deciding which foods to change or which foods to add to the menu, the menu
must be edited, nutrient values need to be recalculated and compared to the Dietary
Specifications.
Re-create Appropriate Reports for Re-analysis
Pre-Publication Copy
56
After modifications have been made, create the appropriate reports to review the new nutrient
analyses. If nutrient targets have still not been met, continue the process described above until
the Dietary Specifications have been met.
Substitutions
Occasionally it may be necessary to make a substitution to a planned menu due to various
reasons such as food shortage, improper delivery from vendors, or effective use of leftovers.
This is a concern because:
•
Substitutions change the nutrient content; and
•
Meals may or may not continue to meet the Dietary Specifications.
If a substitution is made to the offered menu, the substitution must be included in the nutrient
analysis.
SFAs are expected to make substitutions only due to unforeseen circumstances. Remember,
reimbursable meals are based on the ability to meet the Dietary Specifications. Some examples
include:
•
Food shortage (food not delivered);
•
Improper delivery (incorrect product delivered),
•
Crop failure (food unavailable);
•
Significant cost increase in food items; and
•
Effective use of leftovers (see Leftovers below).
USDA strongly encourages “like” substitutions, such as spinach for romaine lettuce, but meals
are compliant if the daily and weekly requirements are met.
Leftovers
If leftovers are offered to students on the serving line as part of the reimbursable meal, they
must be included in weighted nutrient analyses and are subject to the weekly Dietary
Specifications. Leftovers offered to students during the same meal in which are initially offered
are considered seconds.
Pre-Publication Copy
57
Foods offered as leftovers must be entered into the nutrient analysis once. For example, 100
servings of carrots are offered on Monday, and 20 servings are leftover. The 20 leftover carrot
servings are offered Tuesday. The nutrient analysis should be conducted on the menu as
offered: Monday’s offerings should reflect 100 servings of carrots, even though 20 leftover
servings were offered on Tuesday. The Dietary Specifications requirements are weekly
requirements, and the nutrient analysis would still reflect that 100 servings of carrots were
offered over the week, even if some leftovers were offered on subsequent days. It is important
NOT to enter 100 servings of carrots Monday, and 20 servings of carrots Tuesday because this
would result in double counting carrots.
In an effort to reduce waste, a SFA may serve leftovers in a subsequent meal period. This could
include serving breakfast leftovers at lunch, or serving lunch leftovers at breakfast. Menu
planners should not plan to have leftovers, so this is expected to be a rare occurrence. If
leftovers are being carried from breakfast to lunch (or vice versa), there is no need to reanalyze
these leftovers.
SFAs may also freeze leftovers and serve them first on the serving line, following standard
HACCP protocols, the next time that particular item reappears in the menu cycle. Schools are
cautioned that any leftover not frozen for reuse should be used within a safe period. Bacteria
continue to grow even under refrigeration.
The State has discretion to determine whether the amount and frequency of leftovers are
reasonable. If the school consistently has leftovers to add to each day’s menus, schools need
to consider participation trends in an effort to provide one reimbursable lunch for each child
every day.
Documentation
Documentation of substitutions and leftover usage, and the date the need for a substitution or
leftover usage was known, must be maintained by making notes on the menu production
records.
Adjusting Future Menus
The menus have now been planned, offered, served, and analyzed. Before the menu is used
again, the actual participation and the actual number of menu items offered (recorded on the
production record) should be compared to the numbers planned. If the differences are such
that production numbers need to be adjusted, then the menu should be reanalyzed using the
new numbers.
Additionally, menus need re-analyzing whenever:
Pre-Publication Copy
58
•
Menu/food items change;
•
Food products change, including commercially prepared products;
•
Recipes change; or
•
There is any change that will affect the nutrient content of the meals, such as a change
in foods selected, which changes the weighting.
Getting Help
Any questions that may arise about food items, recipe analysis, or menu analysis that have not
been addressed in this manual should be communicated to your FNS Regional Office.
Pre-Publication Copy
59
Appendix A:
Meal Pattern for Required Grade Groups: Breakfast and Lunch
Breakfast Meal Pattern
Grades
a
K-5
Grades
a
6-8
Grades
a
9-12
Grades
K-5
Grades
6-8
Grades
9-12
b
Meal Pattern
Fruits (cups)
Lunch Meal Pattern
Amount of Food Per Week (Minimum Per Day)
c,d
5 (1)
Vegetables (cups)
c,d
e
5 (1)
e
5 (1)
e
2½ (½)
2½ (½)
5 (1)
0
0
0
3¾ (¾)
3¾ (¾)
5 (1)
0
0
0
½
½
½
0
0
0
¾
¾
1¼
0
0
0
½
½
½
Starchy
f
0
0
0
½
½
½
f,g
0
0
0
½
½
¾
0
0
0
1
1
1½
8-9 (1)
8-10 (1)
10-12 (2)
8-10 (1)
9-10 (1)
10-12 (2)
5 (1)
5 (1)
5 (1)
Dark green
f
Red/Orange
f
Beans/Peas
f
(Legumes)
Other
h
Additional Veg to Reach Total
Grains (oz eq)
i
7-10 (1)
Meats/Meat Alternates (oz eq)
Fluid milk (cups)
l
0
j
k
5 (1)
8-10 (1)
0
j
k
5 (1)
9-10 (1)
0
j
k
5 (1)
Other Specifications: Daily Amount Based on the Average for a 5-Day Week
Min-max
cals
(kcal
m,n,o
)
Saturated fat
n,o
(% of total calories)
Sodium (mg)
Trans fat
n, p
n,o
350-500
400-550
450-600
550-650
600-700
750-850
< 10
< 10
< 10
< 10
< 10
< 10
< 430
< 470
< 500
< 640
< 710
< 740
Nutrition label or manufacturer specifications must indicate zero
grams of trans fat per serving.
a
In the SBP, the above age-grade groups are required beginning July 1, 2013 (SY 2013-14). In SY 2012-2013 only, schools may
continue to use the meal pattern for grades K-12 (see § 220.23).
Pre-Publication Copy
60
b
Food items included in each food group and subgroup and amount equivalents. Minimum creditable serving is ⅛ cup.
c
One quarter-cup of dried fruit counts as ½ cup of fruit; 1 cup of leafy greens counts as ½ cup of vegetables. No more than half
of the fruit or vegetable offerings may be in the form of juice. All juice must be 100% full-strength.
d
For breakfast, vegetables may be substituted for fruits, but the first two cups per week of any such substitution must be from
the dark green, red/orange, beans and peas (legumes) or “Other vegetables” subgroups as defined in §210.10(c)(2)(iii).
e
The fruit quantity requirement for the SBP (5 cups/week and a minimum of 1 cup/day) is effective July 1, 2014 (SY 2014-2015).
f
Larger amounts of these vegetables may be served.
g
This category consists of “Other vegetables” as defined in §210.10(c)(2)(iii)(E). For the purposes of the NSLP, “Other
vegetables” requirement may be met with any additional amounts from the dark green, red/orange, and beans/peas (legumes)
vegetable subgroups as defined in §210.10(c)(2)(iii).
h
Any vegetable subgroup may be offered to meet the total weekly vegetable requirement.
i
At least half of the grains offered must be whole grain-rich in the NSLP beginning July 1, 2012 (SY 2012-2013), and in the SBP
beginning July 1, 2013 (SY 2013-2014). All grains must be whole grain-rich in both the NSLP and the SBP beginning July 1, 2014
(SY 2014-15).
j
In the SBP, the grain ranges must be offered beginning July 1, 2013 (SY 2013-2014).
k
There is no separate meat/meat alternate component in the SBP. Beginning July 1, 2013 (SY 2013-2014), schools may
substitute 1 oz. eq. of meat/meat alternate for 1 oz. eq. of grains after the minimum daily grains requirement is met.
l
Fluid milk must be low-fat (1 percent milk fat or less, unflavored) or fat-free (unflavored or flavored).
m
The average daily amount of calories for a 5-day school week must be within the range (at least the minimum and no more
than the maximum values).
n
Discretionary sources of calories (solid fats and added sugars) may be added to the meal pattern if within the specifications for
calories, saturated fat, trans fat, and sodium. Foods of minimal nutritional value and fluid milk with fat content greater than 1
percent milk fat are not allowed.
o
In the SBP, calories and trans fat specifications take effect beginning July 1, 2013 (SY 2013-2014).
p
Final sodium specifications are to be reached by SY 2022-2023 or July 1, 2022. Intermediate sodium specifications are
established for SY 2014-2015 and 2017-2018. See required intermediate specifications in § 210.10(f)(3) for lunches and §
220.8(f)(3) for breakfasts.
Pre-Publication Copy
61
Sodium Reduction: Timeline & Amount
Baseline:
Age/Grade
Group
Current
Average
Sodium
Levels As
1
Offered
(mg)
Target 1:
Target 2:
Meet by July 1,
2014
(SY 2014-2015)
Meet by July 1,
2017
(SY 2017-2018)
(mg)
(mg)
Final Target:
2
Meet by July 1,
2022
(SY 2022-2023)
% Change
(Current Levels vs.
Final Targets)
(mg)
School Breakfast Program
< 485
< 430
(25.5% of UL)
(22.6% of UL)
< 600
< 535
< 470
(27.3% of UL)
(24.3% of UL)
(21.4% of UL)
< 640
< 570
< 500
(27.8% of UL)
(24.8% of UL)
(21.7% of UL)
K-5
573
(elementary)
< 540
(28.4% of UL)
6-8
629
(middle)
9-12
686
(high)
-25%
-25%
-27%
National School Lunch Program
K-5
6-8
9-12
< 1,230
< 935
< 640
(64.8% of UL)
(49.2% of UL)
(33.7% of UL)
1,520
< 1,360
< 1,035
< 710
(middle)
(61.8% of UL)
(47.0% of UL)
(32.3% of UL)
1,588
< 1,420
< 1,080
< 740
(high)
(61.7% of UL)
(47.0% of UL)
(32.2% of UL)
1,377
(elementary)
-54%
-53%
-53%
1
Current Average Sodium Levels as Offered are from the School Nutrition and Dietary Assessment Study-III. Data were collected
in the 2004-05 school year.
2
The IOM final targets are based on the Tolerable Upper Intake Limits (ULs) for sodium, established in the Dietary Reference
Intakes (DRI) (IOM, 2004). The sodium ULs for school-aged children are 2,300 mg (ages 14-18), 2,200 mg (ages 9-13), and 1,900
mg (ages 4-8). The final sodium targets represent the UL for each age/grade group multiplied by the percentage of nutrients
supplied by each meal (approximately 21.5% for breakfast, 32% for lunch), as recommended by IOM. IOM’s recommended final
sodium targets for the K-5 age/grade group breakfasts and lunches are slightly higher than 21.5% and 32% 32%, respectively, of
the UL because this proposed elementary school group spans part of two DRI age groups (ages 4–8 and 9–13 years).
Pre-Publication Copy
62
Appendix B: Nutrient Analysis and Validation Checklist
General Information
SFA/School:
Agreement Number:
Contact/Title:
Phone:
Email:
Address:
Reviewer(s):
Nutrient Analysis
conducted by:
Date of on-site review:
Complete the on-site portion of the Dietary Specifications Assessment Tool to gather useful information
to conduct/validate the nutrient analysis.
Comments – Areas of Concern – Follow Up Items
Other CN Programs
Breakfast
Snack
Age/Grades
General Information
Ages/Grades in School:
Check Box if Yes:
Ages/Grades for Menu Planning:
Lunch: K-5
6-8
9-12
Offer vs Serve
A la carte sales available
Adult Meals
Special Needs Meals
Breakfast: K-5
LUNCH MENU
LUNCH CONDIMENTS
Pre-Publication Copy
6-8
9-12
DAY OF REVIEW MENU
PLANNED SERVING SIZE
ACTUAL SERVING SIZE
PLANNED SERVING SIZE
ACTUAL SERVING SIZE
63
BREAKFAST MENU – (if applicable)
PLANNED SERVING SIZE
ACTUAL SERVING SIZE
BREAKFAST CONDIMENTS
PLANNED SERVING SIZE
ACTUAL SERVING SIZE
1) The on-site portion of the DIETARY SPECIFICATIONS
ASSESSMENT TOOL is complete
• On-site observation using Dietary Specifications
Assessment Tool was conducted to ensure an accurate
nutrient analysis is performed or validated.
YES
NO
COMMENTS
2) Is the targeted menu review site in compliance with the meal
pattern requirements (meal components and quantities)?
3) If required, has the SFA/school implemented corrective
action as agreed to during the on-site review to ensure the
appropriate source documents are accurate before starting
the nutrient analysis process?
• If YES, proceed with conducting a nutrient analysis.
• If NO, immediate corrective action is required. Establish a
time frame for the school to locate or develop the
necessary documentation for the reviewer to perform an
accurate nutrient analysis. Conduct analysis once
documentation is received.
• If documentation is not received by the established date,
proceed with noncompliance actions (i.e., withholding
funds).
Source Documents Required For Analysis/Validation
Review all documentation the SFA provided in support of menus
for the menu/nutrient analysis evaluation. Indicate whether the
school/SFA provided the following documentation/materials
needed to complete/validate the nutrient analysis. Request
additional information, if needed.
Pre-Publication Copy
N/A
YES
NO
COMMENTS
64
YES
NO
COMMENTS
Are the necessary materials available?
a. Menus
• The reviewer should conduct a weighted nutrient
analysis based on meals offered for each USDA
established age/grade group and menu type offered at
lunch and breakfast.
b. Production records include all required information for
each age/grade group and menu type
• Production records (including salad bar/theme bar
production records) must list all food or menu items
offered as part of the reimbursable meal. Additional
items such as condiments, gelatin, butter, must also
be included. Portion sizes, total food quantity used to
prepare each menu item or food item, and leftovers
must be recorded.
c. Number of a la carte sales, adult, and “other” meals
differentiated on production records
• If the same food items are used for reimbursable
meals, a la carte sales and/or “other” meals (e.g.,
adult meals, meals for special diets), production
records differentiate the number of menu items
planned for each type of meal, or for a la carte sales.
d. Standardized recipes include preparation instructions,
portion sizes and yield used in the menus for the period
of evaluation.
e. Nutrition information is available for commercially
prepared foods (e.g., Nutrition Facts Labels or
Manufacturer’s Data Submission Forms).
f.
Food product descriptions/specifications indicate the
specific form of the foods used (e.g., canned in light
syrup, frozen, no added salt, 1 % low fat milk).
g. Crediting Information is available.
• CN labels are useful because they give information on
creditable food items for identifying a food-based
reimbursable meal and help to identify specific
commercially prepared foods in the CN Database.
However, Child Nutrition labels do not provide
nutrient information for data input when conducting a
nutrient analysis.
Pre-Publication Copy
65
YES
NO
COMMENTS
PROCEED BELOW ONLY IF VALIDATING AN EXISTING NUTRIENT ANALYSIS
VALIDATING NUTRIENT ANALYSIS CHECKLIST
YES NO
COMMENTS
1) Was the nutrient analysis software:
a) USDA approved?
• If SFA is not using USDA-approved software to conduct
their nutrient analysis, the SA must conduct a nutrient
analysis.
b) Using most recent version of CN database?
• It is important for schools to update their software in
order to ensure they are using the updated CN
Database, as it will ensure a more accurate nutrient
analysis. Software companies may issue newer
versions of their software to update computer
functions that are not related to the CN Database. The
version of the software and CN Database release is
generally located under the "Help" pull-down menu. If
not, the SFA may need to contact the software
company to determine the version they are currently
using.
2) What credentials, qualifications, and/or training, does menu
planner have?
• Record the qualifications of the computer specialist who
will enter data. List any credentials, training, and/or
related experience.
3) Are source documents missing that prevent the reviewer
from validating the analysis?
4) Were the appropriate Age/Grade groups used?
• Determine if the age/grade groups used are appropriate.
Review the nutrient analysis printout to determine if the
age/grade groups entered are appropriate to the
age/grade groups used for menu planning and portioning.
5) Was a separate analysis completed for breakfast and lunch,
each age/grade group, and each menu type?
• Determine if separate analyses were completed for
breakfast and lunch.
• A separate nutrient analysis is required for each
age/grade group. Also, if a school has different menu
offerings for different segments of students in the school,
separate analyses are required for each population
segment.
Pre-Publication Copy
66
6) Validating weighted averaging:
Interview the menu planner to determine the method used
to calculate the number of offered menu items. Does the
method described yield a correct weighted nutrient analysis?
• If the answer is "No", reviewer must provide the
necessary TA and request immediate corrective action.
• If the answer is "Yes" meaning that the method used
seems reasonable, validate the weighted nutrient
analysis:
a. Was the weighting done
correctly?
o If the weighted averaging was done for the
individual school, determine if it was done
correctly. Was the weighting of individual menu
or food items based on information from past
production records at the school?
b. Were a la carte sales, adult
meals, and special needs meals
excluded from the analysis?
YES
NO
COMMENTS
7) Were all menu and food items, condiments, and foods of
minimal nutritional value served as part of a menu item,
included in the nutrient analysis?
• Determine if the school included all offered menu and
food items, condiments, and foods of minimal nutritional
value (served as part of a menu item) in the nutrient
analysis.
• Condiments or any other food item located after the
point of service must be included in the analysis if they
are part of a menu item or associated with a
reimbursable meal. For example, if a packet of catsup (9
grams) is made available for hamburgers, the menu
should include the projected number of packets
historically served. If condiments are available in bulk,
the total amount usually used for a meal should be
recorded.
8) Were recipes entered using the “yield factor method”?
• Determine if recipes and ingredients were entered into
the database using the Yield Factor Method."
• Refer to guidance manual Nutrient Analysis Protocols for
the School Meals Nutrition Program: How to Analyze
Menus for USDA's School Meal Programs for information
on using the yield factor method.
• The Yield Factor Method requires that each raw
ingredient in a recipe be converted and entered into the
Pre-Publication Copy
67
recipe database as ready-to-serve or cooked.
YES
NO
COMMENTS
9) Did the SFA/school reanalyze menus based on changes in
student selections and participation?
• Review the production records for a minimum of one day
during the review week and compare to a day(s) in a
previous menu cycle. Determine if the school/SFA is
adjusting the number of menu items offered according to
student preference.
10) Are menus being reanalyzed based on changes in purchased
products?
• Review a sample of purchased products to verify that
changes are made to the ingredient and/or recipe
database when new products are purchased.
11) Did the SFA/school input nutrient data correctly for:
a. Local or USDA modified recipes?
b. Food items not in the database?
•
•
•
•
Through interview and/or review of the local database,
determine if the school/SFA input nutrient data correctly.
Obtain a sample of the standardized recipes that the
school/SFA entered into the database and determine that
each recipe has been accurately entered into the
database, using the "Yield Factor Method."
Compare the data entered to the nutrition facts label for
the product or information submitted by the product
manufacturer.
Evaluate the detailed summary for % values that appear
too high or too low for specific menu items or nutrient
averages. This is an indication that either the ingredient
or the recipe was entered incorrectly.
o If data were not entered correctly, determine if
the problem is systemic or non-systemic.
o Ingredients and recipes need to be entered
accurately in order to generate a reliable nutrient
analysis. Frequent data entry errors (e.g., recipes
that are missing ingredients, incorrect yields,
incorrect nutrients entered for products,
incorrect portion size assigned to nutrients)
indicate a systemic problem.
12) Can the reviewer validate the accuracy of the nutrient
analysis?
• Determine if the reviewer can validate that the
Pre-Publication Copy
68
•
nutrient analysis was conducted accurately and
correctly and reflects the SFA's planned menu(s).
If NO, provide TA and request immediate corrective
action. If SFA is unable to implement corrective
action, the SA must conduct the nutrient analysis.
Pre-Publication Copy
YES
NO
COMMENTS
69
Appendix C: Foods of Minimal Nutritional Value*
The following is taken from Appendix B of 7 CFR Part 210.
Appendix B to Part 210--Categories of Foods of Minimal Nutritional Value
(a) Foods of minimal nutritional value--Foods of minimal nutritional value are:
(1) Soda Water--A class of beverages made by absorbing carbon dioxide in potable water. The
amount of carbon dioxide used is not less than that which will be absorbed by the beverage at a
pressure of one atmosphere and at a temperature of 60 deg. F. It either contains no alcohol or
only such alcohol, not in excess of 0.5 percent by weight of the finished beverage, as is
contributed by the flavoring ingredient used. No product shall be excluded from this definition
because it contains artificial sweeteners or discrete nutrients added to the food such as
vitamins, minerals and protein.
(2) Water Ices--As defined by 21 CFR 135.160 Food and Drug Administration Regulations except
that water ices which contain fruit or fruit juices are not included in this definition.
(3) Chewing Gum--Flavored products from natural or synthetic gums and other ingredients
which form an insoluble mass for chewing.
(4) Certain Candies--Processed foods made predominantly from sweeteners or artificial
sweeteners with a variety of minor ingredients which characterize the following types:
(i) Hard Candy--A product made predominantly from sugar (sucrose) and corn syrup which may
be flavored and colored, is characterized by a hard, brittle texture, and includes such items as
sour balls, fruit balls, candy sticks, lollipops, starlight mints, after dinner mints, sugar wafers,
rock candy, cinnamon candies, breath mints, jaw breakers and cough drops.
(ii) Jellies and Gums--A mixture of carbohydrates which are combined to form a stable
gelatinous system of jelly-like character, and are generally flavored and colored, and include
gum drops, jelly beans, jellied and fruit-flavored slices.
(iii) Marshmallow Candies--An aerated confection composed as sugar, corn syrup, invert sugar,
20 percent water and gelatin or egg white to which flavors and colors may be added.
(iv) Fondant--A product consisting of microscopic-sized sugar crystals which are separated by
thin film of sugar and/or invert sugar in solution such as candy corn, soft mints.
(v) Licorice--A product made predominantly from sugar and corn syrup which is flavored with
an extract made from the licorice root.
Pre-Publication Copy
70
(vi) Spun Candy--A product that is made from sugar that has been boiled at high temperature
and spun at a high speed in a special machine.
(vii) Candy Coated Popcorn--Popcorn which is coated with a mixture made predominantly from
sugar and corn syrup.
(b) Petitioning Procedures--Reconsideration of the list of foods of minimal nutritional value
identified in paragraph (a) of this section may be pursued as follows:
(1) Any person may submit a petition to FNS requesting that an individual food be exempted
from a category of foods of minimal nutritional value listed in paragraph (a). In the case of
artificially sweetened foods, the petition must include a statement of the percent of Reference
Daily Intake (RDI) for the eight nutrients listed in Sec. 210.11(a)(2) ``Foods of minimal
nutritional value,'' that the food provides per serving and the petitioner's source of this
information. In the case of all other foods, the petition must include a statement of the percent
of RDI for the eight nutrients listed in Sec. 210.11(a)(2) ``Foods of minimal nutritional value,''
that the food provides per serving and per 100 calories and the petitioner's source of this
information. The Department will determine whether or not the individual food is a food of
minimal nutritional value as defined in Sec. 210.11(a)(2) and will inform the petitioner in writing
of such determination, and the public by notice in the Federal Register as indicated below
under paragraph (b)(3) of this section. In determining whether an individual food is a food of
minimal nutritional value, discrete nutrients added to the food will not be taken into account.
(2) Any person may submit a petition to FNS requesting that foods in a particular category of
foods be classified as foods of minimal nutritional value as defined in Sec. 210.11(a)(2). The
petition must identify and define the food category in easily understood language, list examples
of the food contained in the category and include a list of ingredients which the foods in that
category usually contain. If, upon review of the petition, the Department determines that the
foods in that category should not be classified as foods of minimal nutritional value, the
petitioners will be so notified in writing. If, upon review of the petition, the Department
determines that there is a substantial likelihood that the foods in that category should be
classified as foods of minimal nutritional value as defined in Sec. 210.11(a)(2), the Department
shall at that time inform the petitioner. In addition, the Department shall publish a proposed
rule restricting the sale of foods in that category, setting forth the reasons for this action, and
soliciting public comments. On the basis of comments received within 60 days of publication of
the proposed rule and other available information, the Department will determine whether the
nutrient composition of the foods indicates that the category should be classified as a category
of foods of minimal nutritional value. The petitioner shall be notified in writing and the public
shall be notified of the Department's final determination upon publication in the Federal
Register as indicated under paragraph (b)(3) of this section.
(3) By May 1 and November 1 of each year, the Department will amend appendix B to exclude
those individual foods identified under paragraph (b)(1) of this section, and to include those
Pre-Publication Copy
71
categories of foods identified under paragraph (b)(2) of this section, provided, that there are
necessary changes. The schedule for amending appendix B is as follows:
Actions for publication
Deadline for receipt of petitions by USDA.
USDA to notify petitioners of results of
Departmental review and publish proposed rule (if
applicable).
60 Day comment period
Public notice of amendment of appendix B by
May
Nov. 15
Publication
November
May 15
Feb. 1
Aug. 1
Feb. 1 through
Apr. 1
May 1
Aug. 1 through
Oct. 1
Nov. 1
(4) Written petitions should be sent to the Chief, Technical Assistance Branch, Nutrition and
Technical Services Division, FNS, USDA, Alexandria, Virginia 22302, on or before November 15
or May 15 of each year. Petitions must include all information specified in paragraph (b) of this
appendix and Sec. 220.12(b) (1) or (2) as appropriate.
*NOTE: This appendix applies to SY 2013-14 only. It will be removed for SY 2014-15, when the
Smart Snacks standards are implemented.
Pre-Publication Copy
72
Appendix D: USDA-Approved Nutrient Analysis Software
Requirements
Description of Software Requirements and Functions
• Nutrient Standard Menu Planning software, which meets the specifications for use in the
Child Nutrition Program, must comply with the following criteria:
• All of the appropriate files and fields from the Child Nutrition (CN) Database must be
incorporated into the software (standard reference foods, USDA standardized recipe food
items, commodity foods, manufacturer’s foods, weights and measures, and the USDA Food
Buying Guide).
• Users cannot alter information provided by the CN Database; however, user-entered
information can be edited or deleted.
• The user will be able to enter new food items into a local database from information provided
in a manufacturer’s fact sheet or food label in nutrients per serving or specific weight, or
percent of the Daily Reference Value (DRV).
• The software will automatically convert measures for weight and volume (if available) at all
levels of item entry, recipe development, and menu planning.
• The user will be able to enter recipes; the software will produce a recipe report that includes
the recipe code number, recipe name, serving/portion size, yield of the recipe based on number
of servings, ingredients, the amount of each ingredient in units appropriate for food service,
preparation instructions, and nutrient value of the recipe per serving or per 100 g (with nutrient
changes calculated due to moisture/fat factors).
• The Recipe Nutrient Composition Report will contain the nutrient value contributed by each
ingredient and the total nutrient value of the recipe per serving or per 100 g. The yield of the
recipe will be able to be accurately adjusted to meet the needs of the food service without
degrading the base recipe.
• A Recipe/Ingredient Cross Reference report will identify recipes that contain a certain food
ingredient.
• Menus for a specific site can be developed and copied to another site or data range and the
serving sizes adjusted for various age groups.
• Menu Reports will be available in both calendar and report formats.
• A Menu Production Record can be printed for use by foodservice workers to determine the
Pre-Publication Copy
73
quantities and serving sizes of food to prepare for a specific site. The Standard and Modified
RDA data sets provided USDA are incorporated into the software and used for comparison in
nutrient analyses.
• A Weighted Nutrient Analysis of an individual menu or range of menu dates can be provided.
A summary of the calculated nutrient value of the menu is then compared to the nutrient
standards of a selected age group and deficiencies highlighted.
• The software will search the database for food items containing specific nutrients, so that
menus can be adjusted to meet the nutrient standards.
• The nutrient composition of all food items and recipes in the databases (CN Database and
local database) can be printed.
• Training Documents and the User’s Manual must be presented in a complete, sequential,
easy-to-understand format. The developer must have a system to update the database
whenever a new release of the CN Database is available.
Pre-Publication Copy
74
Appendix E: Sample Nutrition Facts Label
For more information on the Nutrition Facts Label visit the FDA website at:
http://www.fda.gov/Food/IngredientsPackagingLabeling/
LabelingNutrition/ucm20026097.htm
Pre-Publication Copy
75
Appendix F: Form for Manufacturers to Submit to Have Food Products
Added to CN Database
Pre-Publication Copy
76
Pre-Publication Copy
77
Pre-Publication Copy
78
Pre-Publication Copy
79
Pre-Publication Copy
80
| File Type | application/pdf |
| File Title | Nutrient Analysis Protocols: |
| Subject | How to Analyze Menus for USDA’s School Meals Programs |
| Author | klattk |
| File Modified | 2023-07-24 |
| File Created | 2014-02-12 |