Document

FSEEE QPL Comments 070326

ICR 202609-0596-005 · OMB 0596-0182 · Object 172523800.

Document Viewer [pdf]

Status: Original and derived artifacts are available for this document.

Download: pdf

Primary: pdfSource: application/pdf
Loading document viewer…

Document Metadata

Record metadata
application/pdf
FSEEE QPL Comments 070326
Kevin
Word
2026-07-03
2026-07-03
complete

Extracted Text

P.O. Box 11615, Eugene, OR 97440 Tel: (541) 484-2692 Email: [email protected]

July 3, 2026
Hunter Jones, Fire Chemicals Branch Chief
USDA Forest Service
National Technology and Development Program (NTDP)
5785 Highway 10 W
Missoula, MT 59808
Submitted via email to: [email protected]
Re: Comments on the Information Collection: Qualified Products Lists for Fire Chemicals for
Wildland Fire Management (OMB Control No. 0596–0182); 91 Fed. Reg. 23,939 (May 4, 2026)
Dear Mr. Jones:
Forest Service Employees for Environmental Ethics (FSEEE) respectfully submits these comments in
response to the Forest Service’s notice and request for comment concerning the reinstatement of the
information collection titled “Qualified Products Lists for Fire Chemicals for Wildland Fire Management,”
published at 91 Fed. Reg. 23,939 (May 4, 2026). FSEEE is a national nonprofit organization of Forest
Service employees, other public land professionals, and concerned citizens dedicated to holding the agency
to the highest environmental and ethical standards in its stewardship of the National Forests.
FSEEE writes because the information collection at issue is not a mere paperwork formality. The data the
agency collects—and, critically, the data it declines to collect—determines which fire chemicals are placed
on the Qualified Products List (QPL) and, in turn, which chemicals are dispersed by the millions of gallons
across National Forest System lands and the waters that flow through them. Recent independent laboratory
analysis has revealed that long-term fire retardants currently qualified on the QPL contain toxic heavy
metals at concentrations that, in the case of the most widely used product, exceed federal drinking-water
Maximum Contaminant Levels by factors of hundreds to thousands and exceed federal and state hazardouswaste thresholds. The agency’s current information-collection methodology failed to detect these
contaminants. That failure is the central subject of these comments.
The agency itself has now acknowledged the gap. Following publication of the University of Southern
California (USC) laboratory study, Metals in Wildfire Suppressants (Schammel, Gold & McCurry, 2024),
the Forest Service entered into an Interagency Agreement with the U.S. Geological Survey (Agreement No.
24-IA-11132543-023) to characterize the metals and inorganic constituents in its retardant formulations

1

FSEEE Comments — QPL for Fire Chemicals (OMB No. 0596–0182)

and their bioavailability in the environment. As Deputy Director Adam Mendonca’s declaration and its
Exhibit C confirm, the agency has recognized that additional testing is necessary. These comments urge the
agency to formalize that recognition by building appropriate testing into the QPL information collection
itself, so that no product reaches the QPL without adequate vetting in the first instance.
We organize our comments under the four areas on which the agency has invited comment.

1. Whether this collection of information is necessary for the stated purposes and
the proper performance of the functions of the Agency, including whether the
information will have practical or scientific utility
FSEEE agrees that the collection of information is necessary. Indeed, it is not only necessary but legally
compelled, and the current collection is inadequate to satisfy the agency’s obligations. The Forest Service
does not collect QPL information in a legal vacuum. It qualifies and then procures chemicals that it disperses
onto lands and into waters that are protected by a comprehensive body of federal and state environmental
law. If the information collection does not capture whether a candidate product contains constituents that
would cause the agency to violate these laws when the product is applied, the collection lacks the very
practical and scientific utility the Paperwork Reduction Act requires. The presence of Superfund-level
heavy metals in a qualified product—undetected by the current collection—demonstrates the point
concretely.
The agency’s legal obligations include, but are not limited to, the following. For each, we identify the
governing requirement and the liability the agency risks if it qualifies and applies products that have not
been sufficiently vetted for heavy-metal content.

Clean Water Act (CWA), 33 U.S.C. § 1251 et seq.
The CWA prohibits the discharge of any pollutant from a point source into navigable waters without a
National Pollutant Discharge Elimination System (NPDES) permit. 33 U.S.C. §§ 1311(a), 1342. “Pollutant”
expressly includes chemical wastes and is broad enough to encompass the metals-laden retardant slurry at
issue here. In 2023, the U.S. District Court for the District of Montana held, in litigation brought by FSEEE,
that the Forest Service had discharged aerial fire retardant into navigable waters without an NPDES permit
in violation of the Clean Water Act, although the court declined to enjoin continued use while the agency
pursued a permit. The agency’s liability under the CWA turns on what is actually in the retardant. Heavy
metals such as cadmium, chromium, and lead are classic CWA pollutants with stringent aquatic-life criteria.
An information collection that does not quantify these constituents leaves the agency unable to establish,
or even to know, whether its discharges will meet water-quality-based effluent limitations.
Liability: CWA civil penalties accrue per violation, per day, and the Act authorizes citizen suits, 33 U.S.C.
§ 1365. Each unpermitted discharge of a metals-laden pollutant is an independent violation exposing the
agency to injunctive relief, penalties, and fees.

Endangered Species Act (ESA), 16 U.S.C. § 1531 et seq. — Section 7
Section 7(a)(2) requires every federal agency to ensure that its actions are not likely to jeopardize the
continued existence of any listed species or destroy or adversely modify designated critical habitat, in
consultation with the U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service (USFWS) and the National Marine Fisheries Service
(NMFS). 16 U.S.C. § 1536(a)(2). The agency must use “the best scientific and commercial data available.”

2

FSEEE Comments — QPL for Fire Chemicals (OMB No. 0596–0182)

Consultation must be reinitiated when new information reveals effects of the action that were not previously
considered. 50 C.F.R. § 402.16.
The “new information” trigger: The discovery of high-level heavy metals in qualified retardants
constitutes precisely the kind of “new information” that requires reinitiation of consultation. The existing
Biological Opinions supporting retardant use rely on toxicity and baseline science that is, in substantial
part, thirty years old or older, and evaluate ammonia and cyanide rather than the persistent, bioaccumulative
metals identified by the USC study. Those Opinions did not, and could not, account for the bioaccumulation
of cadmium in fish or the sublethal effects of chromium exposure, because the underlying information
collection never detected these metals. An information collection that omits elemental analysis effectively
guarantees that the agency’s Section 7 consultations proceed on an incomplete record.
Liability: The ESA authorizes citizen suits, 16 U.S.C. § 1540(g). Unlawful “take” of listed species carries
civil and criminal penalties, and a failure to consult on the basis of the best available science is
independently actionable under the ESA and the Administrative Procedure Act. FSEEE has already filed
suit against the agency under the ESA concerning the effects of retardant.

Resource Conservation and Recovery Act (RCRA), 42 U.S.C. § 6901 et seq.
RCRA governs the “cradle-to-grave” management of hazardous waste. Under 40 C.F.R. § 261.24, a solid
waste that leaches heavy metals above specified regulatory thresholds using the Toxicity Characteristic
Leaching Procedure exhibits the characteristic of toxicity and is a “characteristic hazardous waste.” The
USC study measured cadmium at 14,400 µg/L (ppb) and chromium at 72,700 µg/L (ppb) in Phos-Chek
LC-95W. These concentrations far exceed the thresholds that trigger management as hazardous waste, and
the study’s authors concluded that this product could legally be characterized as hazardous waste under
both federal and California regulations.
The conflict: If a retardant is legally a hazardous waste by virtue of its metal content, the agency cannot
simply spray it across the open landscape without implicating RCRA’s storage, handling, and disposal
requirements. Notably, the agency’s current TCLP screening evaluates only eight metals under weak-acid
conditions designed to mimic landfill behavior—a method that, as the USGS agreement acknowledges, is
not designed to capture the full environmentally available fraction of metals in a formulation.
Liability: RCRA imposes substantial civil penalties per day of violation and authorizes citizen suits, 42
U.S.C. § 6972, including for imminent and substantial endangerment to health or the environment.

Safe Drinking Water Act (SDWA) — Lead and Copper Rule, 42 U.S.C. § 300f et seq.
The SDWA protects public drinking-water supplies. Under the Lead and Copper Rule (1991), the EPA sets
an “action level” of 15 ppb for lead; exceedance requires corrective action. The USC study found 63 ppb
of lead in Phos-Chek LC-95W—more than four times the federal action level. The SDWA also prohibits
tampering with a public water system. 42 U.S.C. § 300i-1.
Liability: Where retardant drops occur within source-water protection areas—the watersheds that feed
municipal intakes—the introduction of lead and other regulated contaminants above SDWA thresholds
could expose the agency to liability for contaminating or tampering with a public water supply, independent
of the agency’s CWA status. An information collection that never measures lead cannot alert the agency to
this exposure.

3

FSEEE Comments — QPL for Fire Chemicals (OMB No. 0596–0182)

Comprehensive Environmental Response, Compensation, and Liability Act (CERCLA), 42 U.S.C.
§ 9601 et seq.
CERCLA imposes strict, and in appropriate cases joint and several, liability for the release of hazardous
substances and for the costs of cleaning up contaminated sites. Cadmium, chromium, lead, arsenic, copper,
and antimony are all designated CERCLA hazardous substances under 40 C.F.R. § 302.4, Table 302.4.
CERCLA and its implementing regulations also require immediate notification to the National Response
Center whenever a designated hazardous substance is released to the environment in a quantity that equals
or exceeds its reportable quantity (RQ) within any 24-hour period. 42 U.S.C. § 9603; 40 C.F.R. § 302.6.
The reportable quantities for the metals found in qualified retardant are strikingly low relative to the
concentrations and volumes at issue. The RQs for these metals are:

•

Arsenic — 1 pound (0.454 kg) per 24-hour period;

•

Cadmium — 10 pounds (4.54 kg) per 24-hour period;

•

Lead — 10 pounds (4.54 kg) per 24-hour period; and

•

Chromium, copper, and antimony — 5,000 pounds (2,270 kg) each per 24-hour period.

These thresholds are readily approached during ordinary fire operations. Using the concentrations
independently measured in Phos-Chek LC-95W (see Point 2, Table 1), applying on the order of 83,000
gallons of that retardant within a 24-hour period would introduce cadmium in excess of its 10-pound
reportable quantity, and roughly 125,000 gallons would exceed the 1-pound reportable quantity for
arsenic1—application volumes that are entirely plausible during a single large fire. Whether any particular
incident constitutes a reportable release depends on site-specific facts, and the agency may contend that
certain releases fall within statutory or regulatory exclusions. But that is precisely the point: the agency
cannot even undertake the RQ analysis, or discharge its notification duty, when it does not measure—and
therefore does not know—the metal content of the product it is applying. An information collection that
omits elemental analysis leaves the agency structurally unable to determine when a CERCLA reporting
obligation has been triggered.
Liability: Because CERCLA liability is strict and may attach retroactively, a statutory exemption from one
program (such as a Clean Water Act permitting exemption) does not extinguish CERCLA responsibility
for the costs of responding to contamination that retardant application creates. The USC study estimated
that fire-retardant application contributed on the order of 380,000 kilograms (approximately 838,000
pounds) of toxic metals to the environment between 2009 and 2021. The agency’s potential response-cost
and natural-resource-damage exposure is therefore substantial—and, again, it cannot even quantify that
exposure without collecting the metals data the current information collection omits.

1Illustrative calculation. A reportable quantity (RQ) is a mass threshold, whereas the measured data are concentrations, so the
applied volume required to reach an RQ is estimated as volume = RQ ÷ concentration. Cadmium: 10 lb (≈ 4,536 g) ÷ 0.0144 g/L
(14,400 µg/L) ≈ 315,000 L ≈ 83,000 gallons. Arsenic: 1 lb (≈ 454 g) ÷ 0.000962 g/L (962 µg/L) ≈ 472,000 L ≈ 125,000 gallons.
These figures are illustrative and order-of-magnitude only. They assume the concentrations measured in Phos-Chek LC-95W and
that the applied mass is released within a single 24-hour period; they do not resolve site-specific questions such as how a dispersed
aerial application is aggregated, dilution in receiving waters, or the availability of any statutory or regulatory exclusion. The point
is not that any particular drop is unlawful, but that the volumes required to reach these thresholds fall within the range of a single
large fire’s daily retardant use—and that the agency cannot perform this analysis at all without measuring the metal content of its
products.

4

FSEEE Comments — QPL for Fire Chemicals (OMB No. 0596–0182)

The fertilizer exclusion does not shield these releases. The agency may respond that CERCLA’s
definition of “release” excludes “the normal application of fertilizer,” 42 U.S.C. § 9601(22)(D); 40 C.F.R.
§ 302.3, and that long-term retardant is an ammonium-phosphate product akin to a fertilizer. That reliance
would be misplaced, for three reasons.
First, the exclusion is narrow and purpose-specific: it addresses fertilizer applied to promote plant growth
at ordinary agronomic rates. Coating wildland fuels and building containment lines by discharging
thousands of gallons of chemical slurry from aircraft—to retard combustion rather than to nourish crops—
bears none of the hallmarks of normal fertilization. The purpose, method, setting, and application rate all
differ from the practice the exclusion was written to cover, and because CERCLA is a remedial statute its
exclusions are construed narrowly.
Second, the exclusion reaches the fertilizer, not the toxic metals carried with it. The cadmium, chromium,
arsenic, and other metals identified in the USC study are not fertilizer and serve no agronomic purpose;
they are unintended impurities from the mined phosphate ore and undisclosed additives such as corrosion
inhibitors. Even if the ammonium-phosphate base were treated as fertilizer, the exclusion does not reach
the separate hazardous substances co-released with it. A product that simultaneously qualifies as a
characteristic hazardous waste under RCRA—as the metals data indicate Phos-Chek LC-95W does—is not
fertilizer being applied “normally.”
Third, and most fundamentally, whether the exclusion applies is a fact-specific inquiry the agency cannot
even conduct without the metals data the current collection omits. The exclusion is, in any event, specific
to CERCLA’s definition of “release”: it offers no shelter under the Clean Water Act, RCRA, the Safe
Drinking Water Act, the Endangered Species Act, or state hazardous-waste law. The vetting failure these
comments describe is not cured by a fertilizer label.

State Hazardous Waste and Water-Quality Laws (e.g., California Title 22)
Many western states maintain hazardous-waste programs at least as stringent as their federal counterparts,
and several reach further. California is the clearest example: under its Soluble Threshold Limit
Concentration (STLC) standard, cadmium is limited to 1,000 ppb, so the retardant’s measured 14,400 ppb
exceeds that threshold more than fourteenfold, and chromium (72,700 ppb) and vanadium (119,000 ppb)
likewise exceed their California STLCs of 5,000 ppb and 24,000 ppb—vanadium being one of several
metals California regulates that federal law does not. The same cadmium and chromium concentrations also
exceed the federal RCRA toxicity-characteristic regulatory levels (1.0 mg/L and 5.0 mg/L, respectively)
that other western states administer and enforce through their own EPA-authorized hazardous-waste
programs, including Oregon and Washington—the latter’s Dangerous Waste Regulations (Chapter 173-303
WAC) reaching beyond the federal program. A product that qualifies as hazardous waste under the law of
the state in which it is applied cannot be freely dispersed onto that state’s lands and waters.
Liability: Because a federal CWA exemption does not automatically preempt state hazardous-waste or
water-quality law, states that administer their own EPA-authorized programs can enforce those standards
directly—exposing the agency to state penalties, cleanup obligations, and citizen suits independent of
federal law. The agency operates National Forests across numerous such states, and its information
collection should enable it to determine compliance with the law of each state in which a product will be
applied.

5

FSEEE Comments — QPL for Fire Chemicals (OMB No. 0596–0182)

Public-Land Management Mandates
Three organic statutes reinforce the necessity of adequate information. The Organic Administration Act of
1897, 16 U.S.C. § 551, directs the Secretary to regulate the occupancy and use of the National Forests to
protect them against destruction. The Multiple-Use Sustained-Yield Act of 1960, 16 U.S.C. §§ 528–531,
requires management of the forests for multiple uses—including water, wildlife, and fish—without
impairment of the productivity of the land. The National Forest Management Act of 1976, 16 U.S.C. § 1600
et seq., requires the agency to maintain the diversity and viability of native species and to protect soil and
water resources. Applying products laden with persistent, bioaccumulative metals—without collecting the
information necessary to know they are present—is in tension with each of these mandates, which together
direct the agency to sustain, not degrade, forest soils, waters, and aquatic life.
Conclusion on Point 1. The information collection is necessary, but as presently constituted it lacks
practical and scientific utility because it does not capture the data the agency needs to comply with the
foregoing laws. A collection that permits products with hazardous-waste-level heavy metals to reach the
QPL undetected does not perform the agency’s functions; it undermines them. To have genuine utility, the
collection must be expanded as described under Point 2.

2. The accuracy of the Agency’s estimate of the burden of the collection of
information, including the validity of the methodology and assumptions used
FSEEE’s comments on Point 2 address the validity of the methodology and assumptions underlying the
collection—the aspect of this factor most consequential to the public interest. The current methodology is
not valid to accomplish the collection’s stated purpose of ensuring that qualified products are “effective,
nontoxic, and noncorrosive,” because it does not test for the toxic constituents that are in fact present.

A. The current methodology failed to detect Superfund-level heavy metals.
The most direct evidence that the current methodology is invalid is that it allowed aerial fire retardant
containing hazardous-waste-level toxic heavy metals to be qualified and then dispersed across National
Forests, including into waterways. Proper elemental analysis of the retardant would have revealed the
presence of these metals before qualification. It did not, because the collection does not require such
analysis. The methodology’s central assumption—that reviewing a manufacturer’s disclosed ingredient list
and safety data sheets, screening against “Chemicals of Concern” lists, and running acute toxicity tests will
identify all constituents of environmental concern—is false. Metals that enter the product as impurities from
mined phosphate ore or from corrosion inhibitors are not necessarily disclosed as “ingredients,” and
therefore escape a review keyed to the manufacturer’s recipe.

B. The third-party risk assessment must include ICP-MS elemental analysis.
To be valid, the risk assessment conducted by the agency’s third-party reviewer must include Inductively
Coupled Plasma Mass Spectrometry (ICP-MS) testing capable of detecting heavy metals at the parts-perbillion level. ICP-MS is the established industry-standard technique for trace-metal quantification and is
neither novel nor experimental. Its omission from the current collection is the specific methodological
defect that allowed the metals to go undetected.
The USC laboratory study (Schammel, Gold & McCurry, 2024) applied ICP-MS—validated against ICP
triple-quadrupole mass spectrometry and against EPA Method 200.8 at an external laboratory—to fourteen

6

FSEEE Comments — QPL for Fire Chemicals (OMB No. 0596–0182)

fire-suppression products. In Phos-Chek LC-95W, the uncolored form of Phos-Chek’s widely used LC95
long-term retardant line, the study measured chromium at 72,700 ppb (727 times the EPA drinking-water
Maximum Contaminant Level) and cadmium at 14,400 ppb (2,880 times the MCL). It also measured,
among other metals, lead at 63 ppb, arsenic at 962 ppb, copper at 2,660 ppb, vanadium at 119,000 ppb,
manganese at 16,100 ppb, and thallium at 412 ppb—with individual metals ranging up to roughly 2,880
times their corresponding MCLs. The study concluded that concentrations of chromium, cadmium, and
vanadium exceeded California STLC hazardous-waste thresholds, such that the product could legally be
characterized as hazardous waste under both federal and California law. The full results for this product are
set out in Table 1.
Table 1. Toxic metals measured in Phos-Chek LC-95W (a QPL-listed long-term fire retardant) compared to
federal and California regulatory thresholds.
Metal

CAS No.

EPA drinkingwater limit (ppb)

CA hazardouswaste STLC (ppb)

Phos-Chek LC-95W
(ppb)

Multiple of EPA
limit

Cadmium

7440-43-9

5

1,000

14,400*

2,880×

Vanadium

7440-62-2

50†

24,000

119,000*

2,380×

Chromium

7440-47-3

100

5,000

72,700*

727×

Manganese

7439-96-5

50†

15,000

16,100

322×

Thallium

7440-28-0

2

7,000

412

206×

Antimony

7440-36-0

6

15,000

767

128×

Arsenic

7440-38-2

10

5,000

962

96×

Lead

7439-92-1

15‡

5,000

63

4.2×

Copper

7440-50-8

1,300‡

25,000

2,660

2.0×

Barium

7440-39-3

2,000

100,000

282

0.14×

Concentrations in µg/L (ppb) from Schammel, Gold & McCurry (2024), Table 1; values reflect the concentration present after any manufacturerrecommended dilution. CAS No. is the Chemical Abstracts Service Registry Number identifying the elemental form of each metal. * Exceeds the
California Soluble Threshold Limit Concentration (STLC) hazardous-waste threshold; these metals are also federally regulated at the same
concentrations, supporting characterization of the product as hazardous waste. † No EPA MCL established; value shown is the California
Notification Level. ‡ Regulatory value shown is an EPA action level rather than an MCL. The other QPL-listed long-term retardant tested (Komodo)
also exceeded EPA limits for multiple metals.
Sources: measured concentrations, Schammel, Gold & McCurry (2024). EPA drinking-water Maximum Contaminant Levels and action levels,
National Primary Drinking Water Regulations, 40 C.F.R. Part 141. California vanadium and manganese Notification Levels, California State
Water Resources Control Board, Division of Drinking Water. California Soluble Threshold Limit Concentrations (STLC), 22 Cal. Code Regs. §
66261.24. CAS Registry Numbers, EPA List of Hazardous Substances and Reportable Quantities, 40 C.F.R. § 302.4 (Table 302.4), and EPA SW846 Method 6020B.

The significance of these concentrations lies in the well-established toxicity of the metals involved, several
of which are persistent, bioaccumulative, carcinogenic, or all three. Table 2 summarizes the principal
environmental and human-health concerns associated with toxic levels of the metals detected. These
concerns—particularly the sublethal, bioaccumulative, and developmental harms—are exactly the effects
that the agency’s current acute-only toxicity testing, discussed in subsection F below, is incapable of
detecting.
Table 2. Principal environmental and human-health concerns associated with toxic levels of the metals detected in
QPL-listed fire retardants.
Metal

Principal environmental and human-health concerns at toxic levels

Cadmium

Classified as a human carcinogen; accumulates in the kidney and liver; damages fish gills and impairs
reproduction; environmentally persistent and bioaccumulative.

7

FSEEE Comments — QPL for Fire Chemicals (OMB No. 0596–0182)

Metal

Principal environmental and human-health concerns at toxic levels

Chromium

Hexavalent chromium is a known human carcinogen; causes organ and gill damage in fish; persists in
sediments where aquatic organisms feed and spawn.

Arsenic

Classified as a human carcinogen (skin, lung, and bladder); toxic and persistent in aquatic systems;
accumulates in sediments and biota.

Lead

Potent neurotoxin with no recognized safe exposure level, especially for children; bioaccumulative;
impairs the nervous and blood systems of aquatic life.

Vanadium

Toxic to aquatic organisms at elevated concentrations; associated with respiratory and developmental
effects in mammals.

Thallium

Acutely toxic and neurotoxic; bioaccumulative; harmful to aquatic organisms even at low
concentrations.

Antimony

Possible human carcinogen; associated with cardiac and gastrointestinal toxicity; toxic to aquatic
organisms.

Manganese

Neurotoxic at elevated exposures, including developmental neurological effects associated with
drinking-water exposure.

Copper

Highly toxic to fish; impairs the olfactory sense of salmonids, disabling predator avoidance and
homing—a sublethal effect that a 96-hour LC50 test cannot detect.

The copper entry is illustrative of the broader point developed in subsection F: metals cause serious, ESA-relevant harm—olfactory impairment,
reduced growth, impaired reproduction, and bioaccumulation—at concentrations and over timeframes that acute mortality testing does not capture.

C. The findings implicate the qualified retardant class as a whole, not a single formulation.
A threshold question is whether the tested product, Phos-Chek LC-95W, is representative of the aerial
retardants the QPL governs. It is. LC-95W is a fully qualified long-term retardant on the Forest Service’s
own Long-Term Retardant Qualified Products List for aerial applications under Forest Service
Specification 5100-304d, and the Forest Service lists it among its “Aerial Long-Term Retardant
Concentrates.” The agency has publicly acknowledged that it has used LC-95W in aerial firefighting and
that the product is approved for both aerial and ground application, having passed the QPL’s existing safety
tests, including the TCLP.2 The manufacturer has suggested that LC-95W differs from the colored product
most often dropped and has not been applied aerially; but the facts that matter for this comment are that the
agency qualified LC-95W for aerial use through the very process at issue, and that the process did not detect
the metals the USC study later found.
More fundamentally, the objection misapprehends where the metals originate. The Phos-Chek LC95 line is
offered in red (LC95A-R), fugitive-colored (LC95A-Fx), and uncolored (LC95W) forms that share the
same ammonium polyphosphate base and differ only in their color package. The heavy metals are not
constituents of the dye; they enter the product through the mined phosphate salts that form the retardant’s
active ingredient and through the corrosion inhibitors added to protect aircraft and storage tanks—
chromium and cadmium being well-known aluminum corrosion inhibitors. Measuring the uncolored
formulation is therefore a scientifically sound way to quantify the metals present in the components shared
with the colored aerial variants.

2 See U.S. Forest Service, Wildland Fire Chemical Systems, Long-Term Retardant for Wildland Fire Management—Aerial
Applications (Qualified Products List), qualified under Forest Service Specification 5100-304d (listing Phos-Chek LC-95-W as a
fully qualified aerial product; e.g., editions of Dec. 8, 2022 and Dec. 5, 2023), and Fish Toxicity—Long-Term Retardants (rev. Jan.
22, 2025) (classifying Phos-Chek LC-95-W among “Aerial Long-Term Retardant Concentrates”). The Forest Service publicly
acknowledged using LC-95W in aerial firefighting, and confirmed its approval for both aerial and ground application, in coverage
of the USC study; the manufacturer, by contrast, stated that LC-95W is chemically different from the colored aerial product and
has not been used aerially. See “Study finds wildfire retardant is laden with toxic metals,” FireRescue1 (Nov. 23, 2024).

8

FSEEE Comments — QPL for Fire Chemicals (OMB No. 0596–0182)

The same contamination pathway extends to the retardants in current bulk use. The aerial long-term
retardants the Forest Service now procures in largest volume—Phos-Chek MVP-Fx and LCE20-Fx, along
with 259-Fx—are, like LC-95W, ammonium phosphate-based products. The agency’s own Interagency
Agreement with USGS states that these current suppressants rely on “mined, natural phosphate salts [that]
have previously been found to contain selenium, arsenic, cadmium, and chromium,” and it is precisely those
current products that USGS is now testing. The agency thus does not treat the LC-95W findings as irrelevant
to today’s formulations; it has commissioned analysis of the current formulations for the same metals.
Finally, because the manufacturer reformulates its products frequently and the QPL and procurement lists
change from year to year, no comment tied to one formulation could remain current for long. That is the
point: the remedy FSEEE urges—ICP-MS, STLC, and acid-digestion testing at qualification and at each
requalification—is formulation-independent, and would guard against undetected metals in whatever
product, present or future, the agency places on the QPL.

D. The agency itself has recognized the need for this testing.
This is not a contested scientific proposition. The agency has already conceded the point. As set forth in the
Declaration of Adam Mendonca and its Exhibit C—the Interagency Agreement between the Forest Service
and the U.S. Geological Survey (Agreement No. 24-IA-11132543-023)—the Forest Service, after
reviewing the USC study, “determined that additional information on heavy metals was needed” and
engaged the USGS Columbia Environmental Research Center to characterize the metals in its formulations.
The agreement’s scope of work commits the USGS to quantify some forty-nine metals plus total mercury
in bulk retardant formulations using ICP-MS (a method similar to EPA Method 6020B), and, for dry
concentrates, to perform acid digestion (a method similar to EPA Method 3050B) to access the
environmentally available fraction of metals. The agreement further acknowledges that the agency’s
existing evaluation relies only on eight metals extracted under the TCLP—“weak acid conditions designed
to mimic landfill behaviors”—and that this is insufficient to assess environmental harm.
To be sure, the agreement questions aspects of the USC study's sample collection and metals quantification.
But whatever the merits of that critique, the agency's response is the telling fact: rather than dismiss the
finding, the Forest Service commissioned rigorous, peer-reviewed ICP-MS and acid-digestion testing of
the very metals the study identified—something an agency that regarded the concern as illusory would not
have done.
In short, the agency recognizes both the impact of these toxic heavy metals and the need to better quantify
and remedy them. FSEEE urges the agency to close the loop by incorporating this same testing into the
QPL information collection itself, rather than treating it as an after-the-fact research project layered on top
of products that are already qualified and in use.

E. STLC and acid-digestion testing should accompany ICP-MS.
Consistent with the USGS agreement and with California hazardous-waste methodology, the collection
should require Soluble Threshold Limit Concentration (STLC) testing and acid-digestion analysis in
addition to ICP-MS. STLC testing quantifies the soluble, leachable fraction that determines hazardouswaste status under state law; acid digestion accesses the environmentally available fraction relevant to realworld exposure. Together with ICP-MS total-recoverable measurements and analysis of both filtered
(bioavailable) and unfiltered fractions at use-level dilution, these tests would allow the agency to determine,
before qualification, whether a product would be characterized as hazardous waste and whether its

9

FSEEE Comments — QPL for Fire Chemicals (OMB No. 0596–0182)

application would exceed drinking-water or aquatic-life thresholds. This testing is what ensures compliance
with the laws identified under Point 1.

F. Aquatic and mammalian toxicity testing must use contemporary methodologies.
The validity problem extends beyond elemental analysis to the toxicity testing itself. In assessing
mammalian and aquatic toxicity as part of the third-party review—and in the agency’s consultations with
NOAA/NMFS and the USFWS—the collection must apply contemporary scientific methodologies. For
aerial fire retardant, the agency has relied on the 96-hour Lethal Concentration 50 (LC50) test, which
measures only whether more than half of exposed fish remain alive after four days. The LC50 test does not
assess whether the surviving fish are impaired, wasting, or otherwise compromised and unlikely to survive
much longer. It is blind to sublethal, behavioral, developmental, reproductive, and bioaccumulative
effects—precisely the effects that heavy metals cause and that the ESA is designed to prevent.
The consequences of relying on the LC50 alone are illustrated by the agency’s own funded research.
Dietrich et al. (2014), a study supported by the Forest Service Wildland Fire Chemical Systems program
and authored by NMFS scientists, exposed juvenile Chinook salmon to the qualified retardants Phos-Chek
LC-95A and 259F and then subjected survivors to a seawater challenge simulating ocean entry. The study
found that salmon exposed at the smolt stage suffered delayed mortality upon entering seawater—mortality
that occurred after the 96-hour window had closed and that the acute LC50 therefore did not capture. The
authors concluded that accidental retardant drops during salmon outmigration “would have adverse impacts
that extend beyond the acute mortality that occurs within the immediate drop and dilution areas,” and that
LC-95A is “more toxic to Chinook salmon than the acute LC50s would suggest.” A fish that is counted as
a “survivor” at hour 96 but dies upon reaching the ocean is a mortality the current methodology never sees.
Modern federal practice has already moved beyond the mortality-only frame. Recent NMFS Section 7
consultations—including the 2023 Biological Opinions on EPA’s approval of cadmium and selenium
water-quality criteria for North Carolina (NMFS Tracking No. OPR-2022-02170) and for Maryland and
Delaware (NMFS Tracking No. OPR-2022-03042)—evaluate a weight of evidence that includes not only
the LC50 but also fractional-effect and no- and lowest-observed-effect endpoints (e.g., EC10, LOEC,
NOEC) and behavioral and neurological effects, because the purpose of consultation is to determine
whether listed species are likely to be adversely affected, not merely whether they die within four days. The
2014 NMFS Biological Opinion on EPA’s approval of Idaho’s water-quality standards for toxic substances
(May 7, 2014) reached a jeopardy conclusion for Snake River Chinook salmon, sockeye salmon, and
steelhead, its analysis of copper reflecting sublethal effects such as olfactory impairment that mortalitybased tests do not detect. The best available science for protecting listed species is thus a weight-of-evidence
approach spanning acute mortality, chronic and sublethal effects, behavioral and neurological impairment,
and bioaccumulation. A collection that relies primarily on a 96-hour LC50 does not meet that standard.
Conclusion on Point 2. The methodology and assumptions underlying the current collection are
insufficient. To ensure that qualified products are genuinely “nontoxic,” the collection must require (i) ICPMS elemental analysis, together with STLC and acid-digestion testing, to detect and quantify heavy metals
before qualification; and (ii) aquatic and mammalian toxicity assessment using contemporary, lethal-andsublethal endpoints in consultation with NMFS and USFWS. The agency’s own USGS agreement supplies
the template; the collection should adopt it.

10

FSEEE Comments — QPL for Fire Chemicals (OMB No. 0596–0182)

3. Ways to enhance the quality, utility, and clarity of the information to be collected
The quality, utility, and clarity of the collected information would be substantially enhanced by transparent,
standardized reporting that places the test results in their proper regulatory context. Data that sits
unexplained in a technical file has limited utility; data expressed against the legal standards that govern the
agency’s conduct is immediately usable by decision-makers, cooperating agencies, and the public.
Specifically, FSEEE recommends the following:

•

Publicly disclose results against regulatory benchmarks. For every product evaluated, the
agency should publicly disclose how the results of the ICP-MS, STLC, and acid-digestion testing
compare to EPA and applicable state standards for drinking water and for the protection of aquatic
life. Reporting each metal as a multiple of its corresponding Maximum Contaminant Level, aquaticlife criterion, and hazardous-waste threshold—as the USC study did—converts raw concentrations
into information a reader can act on, and makes clear at a glance whether a product approaches or
exceeds a legal limit.

•

Disclose the methodologies used in ESA consultations. The agency should disclose which
toxicity methodologies and endpoints were used during its consultations with NOAA/NMFS and
USFWS for ESA purposes—for example, whether the assessment relied solely on 96-hour LC50
data or incorporated EC10, LOEC, chronic, behavioral, and bioaccumulation endpoints. Disclosure
of methodology allows the public and cooperating agencies to evaluate whether the “best available
science” standard has been met and enhances the scientific credibility and clarity of the record.

•

Report both bulk and use-level, filtered and unfiltered fractions. Consistent with the USGS
scope of work, results should be reported for the bulk formulation and at operational use-level
dilution, and for both filtered (bioavailable) and unfiltered fractions, so that readers can distinguish
tank-strength concentrations from the concentrations and bioavailable fractions that reach the
environment.

Conclusion on Point 3. Transparent disclosure of test results against EPA and state drinking-water and
aquatic-life standards, and of the methodologies used in ESA consultations, would materially improve the
quality, utility, and clarity of the collected information at little additional cost.

4. Ways to minimize the burden of the collection of information on respondents,
including the use of automated, electronic, mechanical, or other technological
collection techniques or other forms of information technology
The additional testing FSEEE recommends can be implemented without imposing an unreasonable burden,
and modern information technology can further reduce the burden of compiling and communicating the
results. ICP-MS, STLC, and acid-digestion testing are routine analytical services; the USGS cost
breakdown in Exhibit C reflects modest per-formulation analytical costs, and under the existing QPL
structure the manufacturer bears the cost of the third-party risk assessment. Because only a small number
of respondents submit a small number of products each year, the incremental burden of adding elemental
analysis to an evaluation that already spans sixteen to eighteen months is limited and is justified many times
over by the legal and environmental risk it averts.

11

FSEEE Comments — QPL for Fire Chemicals (OMB No. 0596–0182)

To minimize burden further, the agency should take advantage of automated and electronic techniques to
compile and present the results. In particular, artificial-intelligence tools can be used to compile testing
results and ESA consultation findings into succinct, comprehensive reports that are accessible to the average
layperson. An AI-assisted reporting workflow could automatically ingest laboratory data, compare each
analyte against the applicable EPA and state benchmarks, flag exceedances, and generate a plain-language
summary alongside the underlying technical tables. This would reduce the manual effort required of both
respondents and agency staff, improve consistency across evaluations, accelerate public disclosure, and
advance the clarity objectives described under Point 3—all while lowering, rather than raising, the net
administrative burden.
Conclusion on Point 4. The recommended testing is modest in per-product cost and is borne by respondents
under the existing framework, while automated and AI-assisted reporting can reduce the burden of
compiling and communicating results and make them accessible to the public.

Conclusion
The QPL information collection is necessary and important, but in its current form it does not collect the
information the agency needs to lawfully and safely carry out its mission. The current collection protocol
permitted retardants bearing hazardous-waste-level heavy metals to be qualified and dispersed across the
National Forests and their waters, undetected. The agency has already acknowledged the gap by
commissioning USGS to perform the very ICP-MS and acid-digestion analyses that the collection omits.
FSEEE respectfully urges the Forest Service to build that testing—ICP-MS elemental analysis, STLC and
acid-digestion testing, and contemporary lethal-and-sublethal aquatic and mammalian toxicity assessment
in consultation with NMFS and USFWS—into the QPL information collection itself, and to disclose the
results transparently against EPA and state standards. Doing so will give the collection the practical and
scientific utility the Paperwork Reduction Act requires and will bring the agency’s fire-chemical program
into alignment with the environmental laws it is bound to obey. Doing so will help the Forest Service
achieve the noble ambition expressed in its motto, “Caring for the Land, Serving People.”
FSEEE appreciates the opportunity to comment and welcomes the opportunity to provide any of the studies
referenced herein or to discuss these recommendations further.
Respectfully submitted,

Kevin Hood
Executive Director
Forest Service Employees for Environmental Ethics (FSEEE)
P.O. Box 11615, Eugene, OR 97440
Email: [email protected]
Tel: (541) 484-2692

12

FSEEE Comments — QPL for Fire Chemicals (OMB No. 0596–0182)

References
Schammel, M. H., Gold, S. J., & McCurry, D. L. (2024). Metals in Wildfire Suppressants. Environmental
Science & Technology Letters, 11(11), 1247–1253.
Declaration of Adam Mendonca and Exhibit C, Interagency Agreement between the U.S. Forest Service
and U.S. Geological Survey (Agreement No. 24-IA-11132543-023), filed in Case No. 9:25-cv-00066DWM (D. Mont.).
Dietrich, J. P., et al. (2014). Toxicity of PHOS-CHEK LC-95A and 259F fire retardants to ocean- and
stream-type Chinook salmon and their potential to recover before seawater entry. Science of the Total
Environment, 490, 610–621.
National Marine Fisheries Service (2023). Endangered Species Act Section 7(a)(2) Biological Opinion on
EPA’s approval of cadmium and selenium water quality criteria for North Carolina. Tracking No. OPR2022-02170. Office of Protected Resources, Silver Spring, MD.
National Marine Fisheries Service (2023). Endangered Species Act Section 7(a)(2) Biological Opinion on
EPA Region 3’s approval of water quality criteria for Maryland and Delaware. Tracking No. OPR2022-03042. Office of Protected Resources, Silver Spring, MD.
National Marine Fisheries Service (2014). Endangered Species Act Section 7(a)(2) Biological Opinion on
the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency’s approval of Idaho water quality standards for toxic
substances (May 7, 2014).
Information Collection: Qualified Products Lists for Fire Chemicals for Wildland Fire Management, 91
Fed. Reg. 23,939 (May 4, 2026).

13