Document

Public Comments

ICR 202609-0596-005 · OMB 0596-0182 · Object 172524000.

Document Viewer [pdf]

Status: Original and derived artifacts are available for this document.

Download: pdf

Primary: pdfSource: application/pdf
Loading document viewer…

Document Metadata

Record metadata
application/pdf
Public Comments
Mike McDonald
Microsoft® Word for Microsoft 365
2026-07-06
2026-07-06
complete

Extracted Text

July 6, 2026
Mr. Hunter Jones
Washington Office – Fire and Aviation Management
Fire Chemicals Branch Chief
5785 Highway 10 West
Missoula, MT 59808
Dear Hunter:
Thank you for the opportunity to comment on the proposed renewal of the information
collection for the Qualified Products Lists (QPL) for Fire Chemicals for Wildland Fire
Management.
1. Is this information collection necessary?
Yes. We believe this information collection is necessary because it helps ensure that
wildland fire retardants meet established safety, environmental, and performance
standards before they are approved for use. There is significant public interest in both
protecting the environment and ensuring these products perform as intended. The
information collected gives the Forest Service the data it needs to make informed
decisions and helps maintain confidence in the products approved for federal use.
2. Is the estimated burden accurate?
Based on our experience, the estimated burden appears to be somewhat low. Although
manufacturers maintain much of the required information, preparing and supporting
submission often requires additional coordination, documentation, and follow-up.
3. How could the information collected be improved?
We believe there are several opportunities to improve the quality and usefulness of the
information collected. Individual formulation components should be evaluated against
performance specifications rather than being tied to a single source of supply. This would
provide greater flexibility for manufacturers while helping reduce supply chain risks for
both the Forest Service and its customers. We also recommend requiring independent
third-party heavy metals testing for newly submitted products using ready-to-use material
and analytical methods capable of measuring contaminants at parts-per-billion levels. This
would provide an added level of confidence that products continue to meet environmental
requirements. Finally, environmental testing should focus primarily on the ready-to-use
product rather than the concentrate. Since the ready-to-use product is what is applied
during wildfire operations, it provides the most meaningful information regarding potential
environmental exposure.

4. How could the burden on respondents be reduced?
The process could be made more efficient by allowing manufacturers to reference
information that has already been submitted when it has not changed. This would reduce
unnecessary duplication while still providing the Agency with the information it needs.
We also encourage the Forest Service to look for opportunities to streamline the review
and approval process. Based on our experience, the review process moved more
efficiently when the Missoula laboratory played a larger role in approving new product
submissions. We encourage the Forest Service to consider giving the laboratory more
authority in the approval process. Relying on the expertise of the technical staff could help
speed up reviews while maintaining the high standards of the qualification process.
Sincerely,

Marcela Munoz
Marcela Munoz
Director of R&D
Perimeter Solutions