Download:
pdf |
pdfPrivacy Impact Assessment
for the
Systematic Alien Verification for
Entitlements (SAVE) Program
DHS/USCIS/PIA-006
August 26, 2011
Contact Point
Janice Jackson
Acting Privacy Branch Chief, Verification Division
United States Citizenship and Immigration Services
(202) 443-0109
Reviewing Officials
Donald Hawkins
Chief Privacy Officer
United States and Citizenship and Immigration Services
(202) 272-8000
Mary Ellen Callahan
Chief Privacy Officer
Department of Homeland Security
(703) 235-0780
Privacy Impact Assessment
USCIS Verification Division, SAVE Program
Page 2
Abstract
The Verification Division of the United States Citizenship and Immigration Services
(USCIS) administers the Systematic Alien Verification for Entitlements (SAVE) Program.
SAVE is a fee-based intergovernmental initiative designed to help federal, state, tribal, and local
government agencies check immigration status for granting benefits, licenses, and other lawful
purposes. Previously, USCIS documented the SAVE Program along with the E-Verify Program
in the Privacy Impact Assessment (PIA) and System of Records Notice (SORN) of the
Verification Information System (VIS), which is the technology that supports both programs.
USCIS has conducted separate PIAs for the SAVE and E-Verify programs to assist the public in
better understanding each program.
Overview
Background
The United States Citizenship and Immigration Services (USCIS) administers the
Systematic Alien Verification for Entitlements (SAVE) Program. SAVE is a fee-based
intergovernmental initiative designed to help federal, state, tribal, and local government agencies
and licensing bureaus confirm immigration status information which includes status verifications
by a federal, state, tribal, or local government agency, or by a contractor acting on the agency's
behalf, to the extent that such disclosure is necessary to enable these agencies to make decisions
related to: (1) determining of eligibility for a federal, state, or local public benefit; (2) issuing a
license or grant; (3) issuing a government credential; (4) conducting a background investigation;
or (5) any other lawful purpose.
A federal, state, tribal, or local government agency that provides a public benefit or
license, or that is otherwise authorized by law to engage in an activity related to the verification
of immigration status, may enroll in SAVE as a customer agency. By using SAVE, federal, state,
tribal, and local customer agencies can request immigration status information in order to make a
determination regarding the applicant’s eligibility for a benefit or a license. It is important to note
that SAVE does not make determinations on an applicant’s eligibility for a specific benefit or
license, but it does provide the necessary information to the agencies to allow them to make an
informed decision prior to issuing benefits or licenses. The customer agency analyzes the SAVE
response against the agency’s own eligibility criteria to make an award determination. SAVE
does not know the final outcome of the benefit adjudication.
SAVE has access to multiple immigration record systems from a variety of government
agencies in order to confirm immigration status. All SAVE customer agencies must adhere to a
Memorandum of Agreement (MOA) or Computer Matching Agreement (CMA), which include
binding responsibilities regarding proper information usage and handling of SAVE information.
The MOA also stipulates the terms for billing and payment. Relative to its billing and
registration process, SAVE collects personally identifiable information (PII) such as the customer
agency’s point of contact name and professional contact information, as well as customer agency
Privacy Impact Assessment
USCIS Verification Division, SAVE Program
Page 3
and demographic information. SAVE staff may also collect sensitive information such as
customer agency credit card information and other data relevant to the billing process.
Before an applying agency is accepted as a SAVE customer, it must first be cleared
through an online registration process in which agencies are required to provide the legal
authorities that allow them to administer benefits and verify citizenship or immigration status for
those benefits. USCIS legal counsel reviews each application before it is approved.
Additionally, in administering the SAVE Program, the USCIS Verification Division may
use information about customer agencies to conduct training and outreach marketing activities.
These activities may require using information collected from customer agencies or
commercially-available company mailing lists. SAVE may also use collected information to
engage in customer service-oriented activities to improve customer agency relationships, such as
outbound welcome calls, surveys, mass message distribution, and other quality assurance
activities (e.g., complaints center). Inbound and outbound calls may be recorded and retained for
training and quality assurance purposes. Information may also be used for monitoring and
compliance activities, especially in connection with possible fraud, discrimination, or misuse and
abuse of the SAVE system. These activities are essential to educate the public about SAVE and
ensure proper usage of the program. Information may also be used for statistical analysis and
recommending program enhancements.
A typical SAVE verification involves a registered federal, state, tribal, or local
government benefit or license granting agency verifying the immigration status of an immigrant
or non-immigrant. The immigration status is based on information from a state or U.S.
government-issued document, such as a Permanent Resident Card (often referred to as a Green
Card) or Employment Authorization Document. Before a SAVE customer agency can submit a
query, the agency must collect certain information from the benefit or license applicant’s
immigration-related document. The verification process is document driven and requires the
document’s numeric identifier, e.g., Alien Number (A-Number). The document presented by the
individual determines the verification process. SAVE verifies non-citizens and naturalized
citizens. Native-born U.S. citizens are not subject to SAVE verification and would not possess
approved documents, e.g., Lawful Permanent Resident Cards or Certificates of Naturalization. A
customer agency will only query SAVE on individuals who are covered by the Immigration and
Nationality Act (INA) and have appropriate documentation. In the vast majority of cases these
are immigrants or non-immigrants, but they may also include naturalized or derived U.S.
citizens. 1 Individuals presenting U.S. passports cannot be verified in SAVE because U.S.
Passports cannot be used to initiate a SAVE query.
When a SAVE customer agency submits a query, SAVE queries various databases for
matching records. These databases consist of the Department of Homeland Security (DHS) case
management databases used for adjudicating immigration benefits, such as the Computer-Linked
1
Naturalized citizenship is defined as the conferring, by any means, of citizenship upon a person after birth.
Derived citizenship is defined as citizenship conveyed to children through the naturalization of parents or,
under certain circumstances, to foreign-born children adopted by U.S. citizens, provided certain conditions
are met.
Privacy Impact Assessment
USCIS Verification Division, SAVE Program
Page 4
Application Information Management Systems (CLAIMS 3 and CLAIMS 4) and the Department
of Justice (DOJ) Executive Office Immigration Review (EOIR) System.
If SAVE locates a record pertaining to the applicant in any of these DHS databases,
SAVE displays that data. The data displayed by SAVE depends on the customer agency’s
authority to use SAVE and the type of benefit the customer agency provides. For example,
Departments of Motor Vehicles (DMV) are not authorized to receive an immigrant’s sponsorship
information and therefore would not receive it.
If SAVE is unable to find a record pertaining to the applicant, it displays a “Institute
Additional Verification” message. The SAVE customer agency may initiate the additional
verification procedure, which entails an in-depth query by USCIS Immigration Status Verifiers
(Status Verifier) to determine the applicant’s immigration status. At the point at which the
“Institute Additional Verification” message is displayed, customer agencies are required to
inform benefit applicants of the additional verification option and to pursue it if requested by the
applicant. This is part of the MOA for all customer agencies.
Status Verifiers perform the additional verification queries and return responses to the
customer agency electronically. The additional verification ensures that the Status Verifiers
check appropriate DHS record systems and the DOJ’s EOIR system. During second and third
step verification, Status Verifiers have read-only access to information contained in immigration
systems described in the attached appendices available through the Person Centric Query System
(PCQS). Status Verifiers will only query this information to review applicant records. Each
connected system provides a view of information related to immigrants and non-immigrants that
is specific to the process or program managed by that connected system.
If the customer agency declines the second step additional verification, the process
ceases. If the customer agency elects the second step, the process continues. If the second step
search produces relevant information enabling verification of immigration status, SAVE provides
an electronic notice to the inquiring customer agency. If SAVE is still unable to locate a record
for the applicant during the second step, SAVE electronically notifies the customer agency to
submit Form G-845, Document Verification Request, with a copy of the applicant’s immigration
documents, for a third step search. 2
While each of the systems may also provide other capabilities, such as case management,
adjudication updates, or background checks, Status Verifiers only use PCQS for second and third
step verification to determine the immigration status of the applicant. In addition to conducting
manual queries of databases for status verification, Status Verifiers may also request record
corrections to the USCIS Central Index System (CIS) database by contacting the USCIS Records
Division, as appropriate, so that status will be corrected for any future SAVE queries.
2
If the submitted Form G-845 is incomplete, Form G-1120, Status Verification Return Checklist, may be
sent to the inquiring customer agency. Form G-1120 includes an explanation of what information is
missing in Form G-845. Also, if an unregistered, non-customer agency attempts to use SAVE, Form G1120 is sent advising them to register, if eligible.
Privacy Impact Assessment
USCIS Verification Division, SAVE Program
Page 5
Other SAVE Verification Processes
The most recent Verification Information System (VIS) Privacy Impact Assessment
(PIA) Update and the VIS System of Records Notice (SORN) 3 recognized the expanded scope of
SAVE to include supporting customer agencies that conduct federal security clearance
background investigations of third parties. A customer agency conducting a federal background
investigation on an individual may use SAVE to verify the immigration status of that individual’s
family members, cohabitants, and other affiliates. For example, if a federal government customer
agency selected an individual for a government position that requires a security clearance, the
Office of Personnel Management (OPM) may use SAVE to verify immigration status information
on that individual and any family members, cohabitants, and other affiliates as part of the security
clearance process.
SAVE also assists in providing immigration status information for other lawful purposes.
For example, the United States Armed Forces verifies status as part of its recruitment activities.
Similarly, U.S. nuclear power plants may verify immigration status for security badges.
The REAL ID Act of 2005, Pub. L. No.109-13, 119 Stat. requires that any state seeking
to be REAL ID compliant use the SAVE Program to verify the legal presence status of non-U.S.
citizens requesting driver’s licenses and state-issued identification cards. Many state DMVs
already access SAVE to determine the status of non-citizens. In addition to verifying
immigration status through traditional SAVE access methods, REAL ID DMVs may accomplish
verification through the American Association of Motor Vehicle Administrators Network
(AAMVAnet). The USCIS Enterprise Service Bus (ESB) is the electronic conduit through which
AAMVAnet links to VIS. In some cases, a DMV may provide driver’s license numbers to
SAVE. SAVE does not retain this information.
Also by using AAMVAnet, REAL ID DMVs may verify passport data by linking to the
ESB to connect to CBP Pass, administered by the U.S. Customs and Border Protection. By
submitting only the date of birth of the passport holder and passport number, the passport
information in the Department of State (DoS) database, Passport Information Electronic Records
System, is queried. If there is a passport on record with information matching that provided by
the DMV, a “Match” is returned. If no record is found, a “No Match” is returned. Under
provisions of a Memorandum of Agreement between DHS and DoS, no passport data is
transmitted to the DMV.
In addition, SAVE is currently developing the capability to use Photo Tool for those
DMVs that access SAVE through AAMVAnet. When a DMV submits a query for verification of
status using certain documents, SAVE retrieves currently available data from various sources and
checks the Customer Profile Management System (CPMS) database to determine if a photo
associated with the document the applicant presents is available. Other fields, such as date of
birth, are also checked to avoid retrieving the wrong photo. If a photo is found, it is returned to
the requestor’s screen at the DMV along with the pertinent information from the database. The
3
DHS/USCIS/PIA-006 Verification Information System and DHS/USCIS-004 Verification Information
System SORN will be retired upon publication of the SAVE PIA and SORN.
Privacy Impact Assessment
USCIS Verification Division, SAVE Program
Page 6
DMV may use this information in their decision-making process for driver’s license or ID card
issuance. This process has not been finalized so it will be described more fully in a future PIA.
Following the development of Photo Tool for DMVs accessing SAVE through AAMVAnet,
SAVE intends to make it available to other agencies using other SAVE access methods.
Reasons for Publishing this PIA
Previously, DHS published the VIS single PIA and SORN, which addressed both SAVE
and E-Verify. In addition, DHS published a PIA for the Person Centric Query System (PCQS),
which supports both SAVE and E-Verify. DHS determined that publishing separate PIAs for
SAVE and E-Verify incorporating appropriate information from both the VIS and PCQS PIAs
would better assist the public in understanding these programs. 4 This PIA refers to SAVE when
addressing programmatic issues and references to VIS and PCQS and the technologies that
support the program. Upon publication of the SAVE PIA, the VIS PIAs will be retired. The
PCQS PIAs will remain in effect because they provide a more detailed explanation of the service
as part of the overall USCIS service-oriented architecture.
This PIA also elaborates on SAVE’s expanded use of foreign passport numbers for nonimmigrants from visa waiver countries. Foreign passport numbers will now be relied upon more
frequently as an identifier because the U.S. Customs and Border Protection (CBP) no longer gives
Form I-94W, Nonimmigrant Visa Waiver Arrival/Departure Form, to non-immigrants from visa
waiver countries entering into the United States. The SAVE program previously relied on Form
I-94W identification numbers to identify non-immigrants from visa waiver countries. Passport
numbers were chosen because affected non-immigrants may not have acceptable DHS-issued
documents, but in all cases should have their foreign passports at entry. Few travelers from visa
waiver countries apply for the benefits administered by SAVE customer agencies.
Section 1.0 Characterization of the Information
The following questions are intended to define the scope of the information requested and/or
collected as well as reasons for its collection as part of the program, system, rule, or technology being
developed.
1.1
What information is collected, used, disseminated, or
maintained in the system?
SAVE receives daily or real-time downloads from several DHS systems as described in
Section 1.2. SAVE collects query and transaction information from the SAVE customer
agencies. Much of this information pertains to individuals dealing with USCIS pursuant to INA,
such as applicants for immigration benefits, petitioners, and non-immigrant visa holders.
Information collected from the customer agency to facilitate verification of immigration status
verification may include the following:
4
DHS published PIAs for E-Verify in May and June of 2010. These are available at
http://www.dhs.gov/privacy.
Privacy Impact Assessment
USCIS Verification Division, SAVE Program
Page 7
About the Individual (i.e., applicant)
•
Receipt Number (issued by USCIS for applications for immigrant or nonimmigrant
benefits)
•
Alien Number
•
Form I-94, Arrival-Departure Record Number
•
Name (last, first, middle)
•
Date of Birth
•
Nationality
•
Customer Agency-issued Case Number
•
DHS document expiration date
•
DHS Document Number
•
Student Exchange and Visitor Information System (SEVIS) ID
•
Foreign Passport Number
•
U.S.-issued Visa Number
•
Alias
•
Social Security Number (in very limited circumstances using the Form G-845,
Document Verification Request)
•
Type of benefit the applicant is seeking
About the Customer Agency (e.g., federal, state, tribal, local, and other government
agencies)
•
Name of Agency
•
Address
•
Point of Contact
•
Contact Telephone Number
•
Authority to Issue Benefits
•
Data Universal Numbering System (DUNS) Number (or Dun and Bradstreet
Number)
•
Tax Payer Identification Number
•
Trading Partner Number
•
Agency Locator Code
Privacy Impact Assessment
USCIS Verification Division, SAVE Program
Page 8
About the Agency Customer
•
Name (last, first, middle)
•
Phone Number
•
Fax Number
•
E-mail Address
•
Customer ID for users within the Agency
Information Generated from Initial Verification
•
Case Verification Number
•
Immigration Status
Additional information is generated from and used in second and third step verifications.
These additional verification steps use information from DHS databases, as well as databases
from the U.S. DOJ and DoS. A listing of databases and data elements is provided in Appendix A,
a description of the databases is provided in Appendix B, and a listing of system PIAs and
SORNs is provided in Appendix C.
1.2
What are the sources of the information in the system?
SAVE is supported by and uses information derived from individuals, customer agencies,
VIS, other DHS agencies, DoS, and DOJ systems. The SAVE system receives daily downloads
of relevant subsets of information about individuals coming before USCIS pursuant to the INA,
to include applicants for immigration benefits, petitioners, and non-immigrant visa holders.
Specific information received in these downloads is provided by the following DHS databases: 5
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
5
Arrival Departure Information System (ADIS)
Central Index System (CIS)
Computer-Linked Application Information Management System 3.0 (Claims 3)
Computer-Linked Application Information Management System 4.0 (Claims 4)
ENFORCE Integrated Database (EID) Enforcement Alien Removal Module (EARM)
Enterprise Document management System (EDMS)
Imagine Storage and Retrieval System (ISRS) 6
Marriage Fraud Amendment System (MFAS)
Microfilm Digitization Application System (MiDAS)
Refugees, Asylum, and Parole System (RAPS)
Reengineered Naturalization Applications Casework System (RNACS) 7
Student and Exchange Visitor Identification System (SEVIS)
Privacy Impact Assessments (PIA) and System of Record Notices (SORN) for DHS systems are on the
DHS Privacy Web site at: http://www.dhs.gov/privacy.
6
ISRS is scheduled to be decommission by early 2011 and replaced by the Customer Profile Management
System.
7
RNACS is scheduled to be decommissioned in late 2011.
Privacy Impact Assessment
USCIS Verification Division, SAVE Program
Page 9
Information about the Individual Benefit Applicant
SAVE receives information about applicants from the customer agencies. The subject of
the query does not have direct access to SAVE. Instead, information about the individual is
submitted by a SAVE customer agency.
The Customer Agency (i.e., federal, state, tribal, local, or other government agencies)
Customer agencies participating in SAVE provide data about themselves including the
name of the agency, business address, phone number, and point of contact information, as well as
SAVE customer contact information and data about the person being queried.
Some agencies use a single sign-on for all of their individual users. In these cases, SAVE
will not collect information from individual users because individual users will appear as one
agency user. In the case of single sign-on access to users, SAVE requires the agency to sign an
addendum to the MOA which states that every user of the system must be assigned a unique
identifier for internal identification. If requested, the agency will provide this information to
SAVE to allow for a clear audit trail for all transactions.
A description of federal databases is provided in Appendix B.
1.3
Why is the information being collected, used, disseminated,
or maintained?
Data about an individual is used to verify the immigration status of that individual to
determine eligibility for benefits, credentials, and licenses issued by a federal, state, tribal, or
local government agency. Data is also used for federal security background investigations and
other lawful purposes. A variety of data is used for cross-referencing to ensure that data is
accurate and current, to identify inconsistencies between or among databases, and to minimize
fraud. Additionally, PII is collected from individual users of the system to provide accountability
of system usage in the event of misuse and abuse of the system. Finally, SAVE data is used for
registering agencies and other administration functions.
1.4
How is the information collected?
SAVE collects information about the customer agency and the users of SAVE directly
from the agency, applicants of the customer agency, immigration status from other federal
government systems, and as it relates to the misuse and abuse of the system. How this
information is collected is described below:
Customer Agency Users: SAVE collects Information about the customer agency from
the agency during the registration process. This information will include information about the
agency along with information about the users of SAVE.
Applicants of Customer Agencies: SAVE collects information about a benefit applicant
when the customer agency submits a query. SAVE compares that information to data found in
DHS databases in order to provide appropriate responses to the requesting customer agency.
Additional information about an applicant may be received during secondary verification.
Privacy Impact Assessment
USCIS Verification Division, SAVE Program
Page 10
Immigrant Status: SAVE collects information from daily or real-time downloads from
several DHS systems and interfaces, as well as query and transaction information from SAVE
customers. It also receives information from partnering agencies such as the Department of State
and DOJ. A customer agency seeking to establish immigration status may do so by inputting
information through secure means to include: 1) Secure File Transfer Protocols for batch
transfers; 2) secure USCIS web site; 3) Web Services access; 8 or 4) by mailing Form G-845.
Misuse and Abuse of the System: SAVE also collects information in the course of its
monitoring and compliance activities, especially in connection with determining the existence of
fraud or discrimination in the use of the SAVE system. The USCIS Verification Call Center, law
enforcement agencies, and the media also provide information to SAVE.
1.5
How will the information be checked for accuracy?
SAVE automatically provides the immigration status of an individual if the information
entered through SAVE, during an initial verification query, matches a record housed in the SAVE
database. Potential record inaccuracies are discovered when the record is queried and the
customer agency provides information for comparison.
The accuracy of the responses depends on the accuracy of the data within the databases
that share data with SAVE. If a discrepancy is encountered or if no record is found pertaining to
an individual, status verifiers conduct a manual search of additional DHS databases to determine
immigration status. If possible, status verifiers will verify the applicant’s immigration status and
request an update to the database. The applicant may be referred to a local USCIS office or to the
appropriate record holding agency to resolve discrepancies that cannot be clarified through
database or record searches.
With respect to information collected from individual applicants, it is incumbent upon
both the applicants providing their information, as well as the customer agency performing the
query, to verify the accuracy of information provided to SAVE. The SAVE Program provides a
confirmation page to the customer agency to review prior to submitting the query.
1.6
What specific legal authorities, arrangements, and/or
agreements defined the collection of information?
Congress mandated that USCIS establish a system to verify the immigration status of
individuals seeking government benefits or within the jurisdiction of the customer agency for any
purpose authorized by law. Authority for having a system for verification of citizenship and
immigration status of individuals seeking government benefits is governed by the Immigration
Reform and Control Act of 1986 (IRCA), P.L. 99-603, 100 Stat. 3359; the Personal
Responsibility and Work Opportunity Reconciliation Act of 1996 (PRWORA), P.L. 104-193, 110
Stat. 2105; Title IV, Subtitle A, of the Illegal Immigration Reform and Immigrant Responsibility
8
Web Services is a support service that allows SAVE customer agencies to access VIS information through
a software interface.
Privacy Impact Assessment
USCIS Verification Division, SAVE Program
Page 11
Act of 1996 (IIRIRA), P.L. 104-208, 110 Stat. 3009; and the REAL ID Act of 2005, Pub. L.
No.109-13, 119 Stat. 231.
All customer agencies participating in SAVE sign a MOA or CMA with SAVE.
1.7
Privacy Impact Analysis: Given the amount and type of
data collected, discuss the privacy risks identified and how
they were mitigated.
VIS, the database supporting SAVE, is required to contain a large amount of PII to
support its mission. Four privacy risks are identified due to this collection of the data.
Risk: The first risk is an unauthorized release of information, specifically a risk of
returning unauthorized information to the customer agency.
Mitigation: To mitigate this risk SAVE customer agencies are categorized and coded
according to the type of benefit they administer. Information is returned according to a customer
agency’s legally-authorized use. For example, a DMV would not receive sponsorship
information about an individual. Only the minimum data required for accurate verification of
driver’s license eligibility is returned.
Risk: The second risk concerns data quality where inaccurate information may be
attributed to an individual applying for a benefit.
Mitigation: To mitigate this risk, SAVE receives daily or real-time data enhancements
and downloads from additional DHS and DOS systems to improve the completeness of SAVE
data. DOJ’s system is accessed directly. If, during initial verification, SAVE is unable to
automatically verify an individual’s status, Status Verifiers review the information and search
other DHS databases to provide further verification so that an individual’s status can be
confirmed. When discrepancies are discovered during the second and third step manual
verification, Status Verifiers may request corrections to the appropriate systems. SAVE is
supported by an interconnected database of more than one hundred million selected immigration
records from DHS and partner agencies. The uniqueness of each individual system and their
combined diversity provides cross-references to minimize inaccurate information attributed to an
individual. The result is fewer manual and second and third step verifications conducted by
Immigration Status Verifiers. Further Status Verifiers also request record corrections to USCIS’s
Central Index System database, as appropriate.
Risk: The third risk is unauthorized customers registering to use SAVE.
Mitigation: To mitigate this risk, the SAVE Program staff conducts a manual review
and approval of all applications to use SAVE. SAVE customer agencies register themselves
online. In doing so, they may not clearly understand the SAVE definition for type of customer
agency or benefit type administered. Incorrect selections during self-registration could result in
extraneous information being returned from SAVE. To mitigate this risk, SAVE Program staff,
as well as the USCIS legal department, review all initial registration applications against a
checklist confirming the benefits the user agency claims to administer and its legal authority to do
Privacy Impact Assessment
USCIS Verification Division, SAVE Program
Page 12
so. If discrepancies are discovered, SAVE staff does not process the registration until the agency
provides the correct information.
Risk: The fourth risk is PII being misused or an unintended use of the PII data.
Mitigation: To mitigate this risk, the SAVE Program ensures that data is used only for
the purposes described in SAVE’s PIA and SORN documentation. Other proposed uses are
reviewed and put through a Privacy evaluation process as mandated by DHS Privacy Office.
Additionally, the MOU or CMA signed by user agencies requires compliance with relevant
sections of the Privacy Act and the Federal Information Security Management Act to safeguard
and protect data from possible misuse.
Section 2.0 Uses of the Information
The following questions are intended to delineate clearly the use of information and the accuracy
of the data being used.
2.1
Describe all the uses of information.
The primary use of the SAVE information is to provide immigration status information
for any legally mandated purpose to federal, state, tribal, and local government customer
agencies. The majority of customer agencies use SAVE to determine if applicants are entitled to
receive the public benefits, licenses, or credentials they administer. For example, based on IRCA,
customer agencies use SAVE when providing education and housing assistance, Medicaid, and
unemployment benefits. PRWORA, by its definition of public benefits, allows customer agencies
to use SAVE to determine the immigration status for purposes of licensing and loans. IIRIRA
provides for customer agencies to use SAVE for any legal purpose such as background
investigations and voter registration. In addition, the REAL ID Act of 2005 requires that any
state choosing to be compliant with the Act utilize the SAVE Program to verify the immigration
status of individuals claiming to be non-citizens before issuing them REAL ID compliant driver’s
licenses and identification cards.
Information in SAVE will only be used for SAVE verifications and for other
administrative purposes aligning with the SAVE process, for such things as customer agency
registration and relationship management, user accountability, program quality management, and
monitoring and compliance activities.
2.2
What types of tools are used to analyze data and what type
of data may be produced?
SAVE uses both manual and automated comparisons of information to confirm
immigration status. Analysts use the Compliance Tracking and Management System (CTMS),
which supports all monitoring and compliance activities to ensure that customers follow proper
procedures according to their signed agreements, as well as regulations. CTMS, which has its
Privacy Impact Assessment
USCIS Verification Division, SAVE Program
Page 13
own PIA and SORN, 9 collects and uses information necessary to support monitoring and
compliance activities for researching and managing misuse, abuse, discrimination, breach of
privacy, and fraudulent use of SAVE. CTMS and SAVE produce reports and data extractions for
evaluation by MPAs.
2.3
If the system uses commercial or publicly available data
please explain why and how it is used.
SAVE uses customer agency-oriented information such as Dun and Bradstreet numbers
and tax identification numbers for billing purposes. SAVE may also use commercially available
company mailing lists for outreach purposes.
The USCIS Office of the Chief Financial Officer requires the Dun and Bradstreet
numbers (also referred to as a DUNS number) and tax identification numbers. They serve only as
additional identifiers and are not used for cross-referencing. The DUNS numbers are also used
by the U.S. Department of Treasury if they must collect owed payments from a delinquent user
agency.
2.4
Privacy Impact Analysis: Describe any types of controls
that may be in place to ensure that information is handled
in accordance with the above described uses.
Risk: The information contained in SAVE is used primarily to respond to inquiries from
authorized customer agencies. Because SAVE collects PII pertaining to authorized customer
agency points of contact (POCs) and accesses databases containing information about benefit
seekers, there is a risk of unauthorized access to this information, use of this information in an
unofficial capacity, or the presence of inaccurate information attributed to an individual.
Mitigation: To mitigate this risk, all customer agencies sign an MOA stating the
intended use of the system and agreeing to the established security requirements. Each MOA
contains provisions for training, policies, safeguarding of information obtained from the system,
and procedures/instructions on the use of SAVE. Additionally, selected customer agencies must
sign CMAs to ensure that information returned by SAVE is used and handled properly. The
USCIS Verification Division Monitoring and Compliance Branch also evaluates and enforces
adherence of user agencies to the agreements laid out in the MOA and CMA.
Section 3.0 Retention
The following questions are intended to outline how long information will be retained after the
initial collection.
3.1
What information is retained?
SAVE retains information collected from the various government databases described in
9
CTMS PIA and SORN are available at http://www.dhs.gov/privacy.
Privacy Impact Assessment
USCIS Verification Division, SAVE Program
Page 14
the appendices and information on individuals applying for specific benefits when the benefit
agency conducts a SAVE check. Additionally, the system maintains information about customer
agencies, including the point of contact, the users, and the transaction history.
SAVE also retains information created by the SAVE Program such as the Case
Verification Number. In processing second and third step verifications, applicants may provide
copies of their identification documents that demonstrate identity and benefit eligibility. The
majority of these hard copies are retained only for the period necessary to close the query and are
then destroyed. Some hard copies of verified fraudulent documents may be retained for training
and law enforcement purposes.
3.2
How long is information retained?
SAVE will retain information for 10 years from the date of the completion of the
verification, unless the records are part of an on-going law enforcement investigation in which
case they may be retained until completion of the investigation. This period is based on the
statute of limitations for most types of misuse or fraud that is possible using SAVE (under 18
U.S.C. § 3291, the statute of limitations for false statements or misuse regarding passports,
citizenship, or naturalization documents).
3.3
Has the retention schedule been approved by the
component records officer and the National Archives and
Records Administration (NARA)?
The retention scheduled N1-566-08-7 was approved by NARA on June 5, 2008.
3.4
Privacy Impact Analysis: Please discuss the risks associated
with the length of time data is retained and how those risks
are mitigated.
Risk: All SAVE information is retained for a period of 10 years to coincide with the
statute of limitations for most types of misuse or fraud that is possible using SAVE (under 18
U.S.C. § 3291, the statute of limitations for false statements or misuse regarding passports,
citizenship or naturalization documents). While the business justification for this retention is
clear—pursuing SAVE fraud or misuse cases—the primary privacy risk associated with retaining
the information for 10 years is that the information might be misused.
Mitigation: To mitigate this risk, the SAVE Program has a policy to retain only
minimum information and to use technical controls that limit use and access to SAVE
information. By policy, this information may only be used for verifying immigration status or for
purposes that directly support the program such as prevention of misuse and fraud, program
analysis, outreach, quality assurance, and customer service. Furthermore, the information in VIS,
the underlying technology solution for SAVE, is purely transactional and individuals with access
to the system have procedural and technical limitations that prevent them from searching the
database for such things as previous verifications. For example, most customer agencies do not
Privacy Impact Assessment
USCIS Verification Division, SAVE Program
Page 15
have the ability to search VIS for closed cases. The SAVE Program has also developed
monitoring and compliance capabilities to detect and reduce potential misuse of SAVE
information.
Section 4.0 Internal Sharing and Disclosure
The following questions are intended to define the scope of sharing within the Department of
Homeland Security.
4.1
With which internal organization(s) is the information
shared, what information is shared and for what purpose?
When potential fraud or misuse is indicated by SAVE information, this information may
be shared, on a case-by-case basis, with DHS internal law enforcement organizations such as
Immigration Customs Enforcement (ICE). For example, information could be shared with ICE if
it were discovered that an Alien Number is used repeatedly in ways that are inconsistent with one
legal individual using his own Alien Number. In these cases, SAVE shares only the information
required to pursue an investigation into the potential fraud or misuse. Several DHS organizations
are customers of SAVE and have access to information in response to their queries.
4.2
How is the information transmitted or disclosed?
All internal sharing is conducted over a secure DHS electronic interface. This interface
utilizes secure network connections on the DHS core network. Federal government employees
and their agents must adhere to the OMB guidance provided in OMB Memoranda, M-06-15,
Safeguarding Personally Identifiable Information, dated May 22, 2006, and M-06-16 Protection
of Sensitive Agency Information, dated June 23, 2006, setting forth the standards for the handling
and safeguarding of PII. Contractors must also sign non-disclosure agreements that require them
to follow departmental transmission and disclosure limitations. All data shared between agencies
is transmitted or disclosed via secured communications.
4.3
Privacy Impact Analysis: Considering the extent of internal
information sharing, discuss the privacy risks associated
with the sharing and how they were mitigated.
Risk: The main risk associated with internal information sharing is unauthorized access
to PII.
Mitigation: To mitigate this risk, SAVE only shares information internally for law
enforcement purposes regarding potential fraud or misuse of SAVE. USCIS limits data sharing
to only those DHS components that have a need to know and put the information to uses that are
compatible with the SAVE System of Record Notice (SORN). 10 DHS enforces the requirement
of annual privacy and computer security training, which teaches how to handle and safeguard PII.
10
The SAVE SORN (DHS/USCIS-004) will be published in conjunction with this PIA.
Privacy Impact Assessment
USCIS Verification Division, SAVE Program
Page 16
In addition, USCIS employees are required to review the responsibility of handling of sensitive
and non-sensitive PII in Management Directive (MD) 140-001.
Section 5.0 External Sharing and Disclosure
The following questions are intended to define the content, scope, and authority for information
sharing external to DHS which includes Federal, state and local government, and the private sector.
5.1
With which external organization(s) is the information
shared, what information is shared, and for what purpose?
Many SAVE customer agencies are external to DHS. Over 500 federal, state, tribal, and
local government agencies currently use SAVE to receive immigration status information in
response to their queries.
SAVE may also provide data to the Department of Justice (DOJ) or other law
enforcement agencies in the case of an investigation or other legal matter related to the use of
SAVE. The general purpose of responding to such matters is within the DOJ’s jurisdiction to
include investigation of allegations of immigration fraud, discrimination, and other misuses of
SAVE.
5.2
Is the sharing of personally identifiable information outside
the Department compatible with the original collection? If
so, is it covered by an appropriate routine use in a SORN?
If so, please describe. If not, please describe under what
legal mechanism the program or system is allowed to share
the personally identifiable information outside of DHS.
The instances of external sharing are compatible with the purpose of SAVE and are
appropriately covered by routine uses in the SAVE SORN. In addition, sharing with SAVE
customer agencies are covered by MOAs and CMAs, as appropriate. External sharing for law
enforcement purposes to assist in the investigations of fraud, discrimination, and misuse cases is
fully within the purpose of the original collection and supported by routine uses E, G, and H, of
the SORN.
5.3
How is the information shared outside the Department and
what security measures safeguard its transmission?
Besides sharing information with customer agencies to verify immigration status, SAVE
may also share information for law enforcement purposes such as fraud and identify theft issues.
The method of sharing and protections involved in that sharing will depend on the particular case.
For example, information indicating that a single Alien Number has been used hundreds or
thousands of times across the United States in a short period of time may require an electronic
extraction of information that will be protected with encryption and securely transmitted
electronically to the responsible law enforcement officer(s) working the potential case. The
Privacy Impact Assessment
USCIS Verification Division, SAVE Program
Page 17
extraction would be required to comply with all DHS and federal requirements including the
Office of Management and Budget (OMB) Memorandum 06-16. Alternatively, a single SAVE
transaction that appears to indicate fraud or misuse may be extracted in hard copy and delivered
directly to the responsible law enforcement officer working the potential case.
5.4
Privacy Impact Analysis: Given the external sharing,
explain the privacy risks identified and describe how they
were mitigated.
Risk: There are privacy risks of the unintended use and the protection of PII when
sharing information with the external entities in that information may be used to commit fraud or
identity theft.
Mitigation: To mitigate these privacy risks, all SAVE customer agencies must adhere to
MOAs and/or CMAs which stipulate binding responsibilities regarding safe handling of
information, minimum security standards for electronic transmissions, and breach incident
notification. These provisions are compliant with requirements of the Federal Information
Security and Management Act, relevant OMB guidance, and DHS Sensitive Systems Policy
4300A.
Risk: There is a risk in sharing information with external organizations in that
authorized users may misuse the information or unauthorized users may gain access to it.
However, external sharing for law enforcement purposes to assist in the investigations of fraud,
misuse, and discrimination cases is fully within the purpose of the original collection and
supported by routine uses described in the SAVE SORN publishing concurrently with this PIA.
Mitigation: To mitigate this risk, sharing only takes place after DHS determines that the
receiving component or agency has a need-to-know the information to carry out national security,
law enforcement, immigration, intelligence, or other functions consistent with the routine uses set
forth in this SORN.
Section 6.0 Notice
The following questions are directed at notice to the individual of the scope of information
collected, the right to consent to uses of said information, and the right to decline to provide information.
6.1
Was notice provided to the individual prior to collection of
information?
In many cases, notice is directly given to the individual applicants or benefit-seekers of
SAVE customer agencies. The Small Business Administration collects information after
receiving the applicant’s written consent. Additionally, the MOA signed by all SAVE customer
agencies requires them to adhere to the Privacy Act. The original MOA is a static document and
binding as long as the customer agency uses SAVE. The MOA does, however, include a billing
addendum that changes with each fiscal year.
Privacy Impact Assessment
USCIS Verification Division, SAVE Program
Page 18
There may be instances when the only notice will be through the publication of a PIA and
an accompanying SORN. In some cases, federal agencies, such as OPM, will determine
immigration status through SAVE, not only for a federal security clearance or public trust
investigation subject (who has been given notice and provides consent based on agreeing to the
background investigation), but also for family members, cohabitants, and other affiliates of the
subject. OPM does not provide these individuals with the opportunity to consent, and these
individuals will receive notification only through this PIA and accompanying SORN. This
limited notification is justified based on national security concerns associated with individuals
who will be granted security clearances or public trust positions.
6.2
Do individuals have the opportunity and/or right to decline
to provide information?
Yes, applicants have the opportunity and/or right to decline to provide information to the
customer agency from which they are seeking a benefit. However, declining or providing
incomplete information may prevent SAVE’s ability to verify their status, which ultimately may
result in disqualification for the benefit the individual is seeking.
6.3
Do individuals have the right to consent to particular uses
of the information? If so, how does the individual exercise
the right?
No, individuals do not have the right to consent to particular uses of the information.
SAVE may provide information to customer agencies to support any lawful purpose including
background investigations. The agency may give the individual clear notice at the time of
application that failure to provide immigration status information may result in a determination of
ineligibility for a particular benefit.
6.4
Privacy Impact Analysis: Describe how notice is provided to
individuals, and how the risks associated with individuals
being unaware of the collection are mitigated.
Risk: There is a risk that when individuals apply for a benefit from SAVE customer
agencies that the individual may be unaware of what sort of information is gathered and what is
done with that information.
Mitigation: To mitigate this risk, each customer agency is responsible for informing
individuals that the information they provide is collected to determine whether they are eligible
for public benefits, licenses, or credentials. Federal customer agency applications will contain a
privacy notice and statement where the individual authorizes the benefit-issuing customer agency
to release any information from the application as needed to determine eligibility for benefits.
State and local customer agencies may contain a privacy notice and statement, but such a notice is
not necessary to enroll in SAVE. In addition, individuals may be advised that the information
provided may be shared with other federal, state, local and law enforcement and regulatory
Privacy Impact Assessment
USCIS Verification Division, SAVE Program
Page 19
agencies during the course of the investigation. The SAVE SORN also provides additional notice
to individuals by specifying the routine internal and external uses to which the information may
be used. The SORN further indicates that information is maintained and destroyed according to
the principles of the Federal Records Act, NARA regulations and records schedules, and in some
cases may be covered by the Privacy Act and subject to disclosure under the Freedom of
Information Act.
Section 7.0 Access, Redress and Correction
The following questions are directed at an individual’s ability to ensure the accuracy of the
information collected about them.
7.1
What are the procedures that allow individuals to gain
access to their information?
Individuals may request access to their information by submitting a written Privacy Act
request to USCIS clearly marked “Privacy Act Request” at the following address:
National Records Center
FOIA/PA Office
P.O. Box 648010
Lee’s Summit, MO 64064-8010
Requesters are required to provide their A-Number and/or full name, date, and place of
birth, and return address.
7.2
What are the procedures for correcting inaccurate or
erroneous information?
Individuals should direct all written requests to contest or amend their information
reviewed by SAVE, with appropriate proof of identity, class of admission, and other relevant
identifying information, as well as a statement about the incorrect information to the FOIA/PA
Officer at the address provided in Section 7.1. Depending on the originating source of
information, the request may be satisfied within USCIS or the individual may be referred to the
appropriate record holding agency (e.g., Customs and Border Protection for the Nonimmigrant
Information System and Border Crossing Information). If the source of data is from a USCIS
download (e.g., CIS) and SAVE confirms the data is incorrect, by comparing the documents with
the information in the SAVE database and cross referencing other VIS databases, SAVE will
contact the appropriate system owner recommending that the data be corrected. Alternatively, the
individual may make an appointment via INFOPASS located on the USCIS website to visit a
USCIS District Office and request that a Level 1 Immigration Service Officer make the change.
When appearing for the appointment, the person should provide accompanying supporting
documentation, including proof of identity, class of admission, and other relevant identifying
information. SAVE customer agencies may change their profile information directly within the
VIS application.
Privacy Impact Assessment
USCIS Verification Division, SAVE Program
Page 20
7.3
How are individuals notified of the procedures for
correcting their information?
The PIA and SORN for SAVE provide individuals with guidance for correcting
information. Additionally, benefit-issuing agencies also provide instructions for correcting
information with SAVE.
7.4
If no formal redress is provided, what alternatives are
available to the individual?
Formal redress is provided to individuals in accordance with the above sections 7.1 and
7.2.
7.5
Privacy Impact Analysis: Please discuss the privacy risks
associated with the redress available to individuals and how
those risks are mitigated.
Risk: The main risk regarding redress is that the right may be limited by Privacy Act
exemptions. The redress and access measures offered by SAVE are appropriate given the
purpose of the system.
Mitigation: To mitigate this risk, the second and third step verification options give
individuals opportunities, during and after the completion of the benefits application process, to
correct information they have provided to USCIS and/or the agencies from which they seek
benefits.
Section 8.0 Technical Access and Security
The following questions are intended to describe technical safeguards and security measures.
8.1
What procedures are in place to determine which users may
access the system and are they documented?
The SAVE Program requires potential enrollees and customer agencies to register for
participation in the SAVE Program and sign a MOA or CMA. Once the required documentation
is submitted, all users are required to complete a web-based training course that explains
functionality and security requirements.
8.2
Will Department contractors have access to the system?
Yes, contractors will have access to SAVE. All contractors shall go through a suitability
and personal clearance process before they can access the SAVE system. Appropriate nondisclosure agreements are signed by contractors. Additionally, all contractors are required to take
security and privacy training annually as described in the section below.
Privacy Impact Assessment
USCIS Verification Division, SAVE Program
Page 21
8.3
Describe what privacy training is provided to users either
generally or specifically relevant to the program or system?
SAVE internal users take the mandatory, annual DHS Computer Security Training and
USCIS Privacy Awareness Training. Additionally, staff who administer the SAVE Program take
special, supplemental training. External SAVE users take on-line tutorials explaining the SAVE
Program. The tutorial also covers the procedures and policies associated with the use of SAVE
and also includes Privacy.
8.4
Has Certification & Accreditation been completed for the
system or systems supporting the program?
Yes, VIS, as the underlying technology supporting SAVE has been Certified and
Accredited and received a full authority to operate (ATO) in April 2008. This ATO expires April
2011, or before April 2011 if significant changes are made to VIS.
8.5
What auditing measures and technical safeguards are in
place to prevent misuse of data?
SAVE has implemented a broad range of technical, operational, and physical security
measures to protect the system and its information. These security measures include access
controls for both internal and external customers, such as account names and passwords to access
SAVE. SAVE has an automated mechanism to ensure that users change their passwords at
specified intervals. User accounts are locked after several failed attempts to logon. SAVE
protects against password re-use. Additionally, inactive SAVE sessions timeout and require users
to log in again. Other examples of security controls include:
•
Password data is encrypted within the system;
•
SAVE is located within a multi-layered firewall architecture;
•
A robust set of security controls that meet DHS System Security Policy requirements
are documented and verified through the certification and accreditation process;
•
SAVE uses HTTPS protected communications during all data transmissions between
the client workstation and the system;
•
SAVE passwords are encrypted when making database connections; and
•
Procedures are in place to ensure that any potential breaches of information are
reported within one hour of being found.
SAVE has a comprehensive audit trail tracking and maintenance function that stores
information on users who submit queries, when the query was processed, what the response was,
who receives the response, and when the response was received. The audit logs have restricted
access based on user roles. These logs are external to system administration access methods and
protected from modification. These audit logs are periodically reviewed for monitoring user
Privacy Impact Assessment
USCIS Verification Division, SAVE Program
Page 22
activity. Customer agencies are required to abide by all security requirements as agreed to when
they enrolled in SAVE. Attempts to evade the security controls can result in loss of access to
SAVE.
Some agencies use a single sign-on for all of their individual users. In these cases, SAVE
will not collect information from individual users because individual users will appear as one
agency user. In the case of single sign-on access to users, SAVE requires the agency to sign an
addendum to the MOA which states that every user of the system must be assigned a unique
identifier. If requested, the agency provides this information to SAVE to allow for a clear audit
trail for all transactions.
8.6
Privacy Impact Analysis: Given the sensitivity and scope of
the information collected, as well as any information
sharing conducted on the system, what privacy risks were
identified and how do the security controls mitigate them?
Risk: There is risk that users may be unauthorized to access information.
Mitigation: SAVE mitigates the risk associated with user access to information by
requiring program-specific training before system access is granted. SAVE is able to monitor use
of the system. SAVE provides the customer agency administrator with the ability to assign and
track user identification numbers and passwords; SAVE can also track these user identifiers.
Additionally, there are a few customer agencies using single user sign-on. As applicable, new
MOAs are signed based on DHS’s Interface Control Agreement requiring that both DHS and the
customer agency will be able to identify the customer agency user for a verification transaction.
SAVE also requires the agency to sign an addendum to the MOA which states that every user of
the system must be assigned a unique identifier. When requested, the agency must provide this
information to SAVE to allow for a clear audit trail for all transactions. Additionally, responses
to queries are tailored based upon agency mission requirements, providing each user with only
the information necessary for their needs. DHS requires all employees, including SAVE users, to
complete mandatory, annual DHS Computer Security Training and Privacy Awareness Training.
Risk: There is risk that users may alter SAVE data.
Mitigation: SAVE mitigates concerns about data alteration by users by providing all
external users with "read-only" access. SAVE is also able to monitor access to SAVE by the
designated users to identify any unusual activity or access.
Risk: There is a risk that unauthorized users may access PII.
Mitigation: SAVE mitigates concerns about unauthorized access to PII by monitoring
for accounts that have not been used for long periods. SAVE brings such accounts to the
attention of the customer agency for possible termination of the accounts.
Risk: There is a risk that there may be unauthorized agent users in the system.
Privacy Impact Assessment
USCIS Verification Division, SAVE Program
Page 23
Mitigation: SAVE mitigates the risk of unauthorized agent users by requiring all
agencies to sign MOAs agreeing to abide by the stipulated use and access policies before granting
access to the system. Additionally, data is only provided back to the originator or designee of the
requesting agency.
Section 9.0 Technology
The following questions are directed at critically analyzing the selection process for any
technologies utilized by the system, including system hardware, RFID, biometrics and other technology.
9.1
What type of project is the program or system?
The SAVE program is comprised of an underlying technical infrastructure and
operational policies and procedures for the verification of immigration status. VIS, as the
supporting technology, is composed of databases and web services, and communication and
security infrastructure.
9.2
What stage of development is the system in and what
project development lifecycle was used?
SAVE is at the operations and maintenance stage of the DHS system development life
cycle.
9.3
Does the project employ technology which may raise
privacy concerns? If so please discuss their implementation.
The SAVE application is a web-based service/application provided via Internet.
Risk: SAVE inherits privacy risks associated with applications available via Internet
e.g., session hijacking, network sniffing, and exploitation of vulnerable web services.
Mitigation: These risks are mitigated to an acceptable level by implementing security
controls per NIST and OMB guidelines as documented in relevant security plans and vetted
through the Certification and Accreditation process.
Privacy Impact Assessment
USCIS Verification Division, SAVE Program
Page 24
Responsible Officials
Janice Jackson
Acting Chief, Privacy Branch
U.S. Citizenship and Immigration Services
Verification Division
Department of Homeland Security
Approval Signature
Original signed copy on file with the DHS Privacy Office
Mary Ellen Callahan
Chief Privacy Officer
Department of Homeland Security
Privacy Impact Assessment
USCIS Verification Division, SAVE Program
Page 25
Appendix A
Information Generated from Second and/or Third Step Verifications
(Includes Initial Verification Data) and Quick References
Status Verification System-provided information, as a result of the verification process
under SAVE using Form G-845, Document Verification Request
• Case Verification Number
• Record in VIS database as outlined above, including pertinent information from
CIS, SEVIS and CLAIMS 3 and with the exception of the biometric information
(photograph) from CPMS.
• Immigration status (e.g. Lawful Permanent Resident)
• Employment eligibility information (depending on the document submitted). For
example, for the Department of Labor, employment authorization history for past
18 months is provided
• Certain types of SAVE referrals may require returning information about whether
an individual is on Order of Supervision, entry and parole information, and/or
Affidavit of Support information.
Person Centric Query System (PCQS) – All personal information regarding an
applicant’s status is uploaded from various databases such as:
•
Central Index System (CIS)
•
Computer-Linked Application Management Information System 3.0 (CLAIMS
3)
•
Computer-Linked Application Management Information System 4.0 (CLAIMS
4)
•
Customer Profile Management System (CPMS)
•
DOS Consular Consolidated Database (DOS-CCD)
•
ENFORCE Integrated Database (EID) Enforcement Alien Removal Module
(EARM)
•
•
Executive Office of Immigration Review System (EOIR)
Marriage Fraud Amendment System (MFAS)Microfilm Digitization Application
System (MIDAS)
•
National File Tracking System (NFTS)
•
Nonimmigrant Information System and Border Crossing Information (NIIS and
BCI)
Privacy Impact Assessment
USCIS Verification Division, SAVE Program
Page 26
•
Refugees, Asylum, and Parole System (RAPS)
•
Reengineered Naturalization Applications Casework Systems (RNACS)
•
Immigration Customs and Enforcement (ICE) Student Exchange Visitor
Information System (SEVIS)
•
TECS System: CBP Primary and Secondary Processing (TECS)
Immigration Status Information Collected from DHS, DOJ, and DOS Systems
(Sorted by Commonly Used Name Acronym)
United States Visitor and Immigrant Status Indicator Technology (US-VISIT)’s Arrival
Departure Information System (ADIS)
•
Last Name
•
First Name
•
Date of Birth
•
Country of Citizenship
•
Sex
•
Passport Number
•
Airline and Flight Number
•
Country of Residence
•
City Where Boarded
•
City Where Visa was Issued
•
Date Visa Issued
•
Address While in United States
•
Port of Entry
USCIS’s Central Index System (CIS)
•
Alien Number
•
Last Name
•
First Name
•
Middle Name
•
Date of Birth
•
Date Entered United States
•
Country of Birth
Privacy Impact Assessment
USCIS Verification Division, SAVE Program
Page 27
•
Class of Admission
•
File Control Office Code
•
Social Security Number
•
Form I-94 Number
•
Office Code Where the Authorization Was Granted
•
Employment Authorization Card Information
•
Lawful Permanent Resident Card Information
•
Naturalization Certificate Number
•
EOIR Information, if in proceedings
USCIS’s Computer-Linked Application Information Management System Version 3
(CLAIMS 3)
•
Receipt Number
•
Alien Number
•
Last Name
•
First Name
•
Middle Name
•
Address
•
Social Security Number
•
Gender
•
Date of Birth
•
Country of Birth
•
Class of Admission or Type of Visa
•
I-94 Number
•
Employment Authorization Information
•
Lawful Permanent Resident Information
•
Date of Entry
•
Valid-To Date
•
Petitioner Internal Revenue Service Number
•
Attorney Name
•
Attorney Address
Privacy Impact Assessment
USCIS Verification Division, SAVE Program
Page 28
USCIS’s Computer-Linked Application Information Management System Version 4.0
(CLAIMS 4)
•
Alien Number
•
Social Security Number
•
Last Name
•
First Name
•
Middle Name
•
Birth Date
•
Birth Country
•
Nationality
•
Gender
•
Naturalization Verification (Citizenship Certificate Identification ID)
•
Naturalization Verification (Citizenship Naturalization Date/Time)
•
Address
USCIS’s Customer Profile Management System
•
Receipt Number
•
Alien Number
•
Last Name
•
First Name
•
Middle Name
•
Date of Birth
•
Country of Birth
•
Form Number, for example Form I-551 (Lawful Permanent Resident card) or
Form I-766 (Employment Authorization Document)
•
Expiration Date
•
Photograph
Department of State (DOS)’s Consular Consolidated Database (DOS-CCD)
•
Name
•
Date of Birth
•
Passport Number
Privacy Impact Assessment
USCIS Verification Division, SAVE Program
Page 29
•
Visa Control Number
•
FOIL Number
•
Alien Number
•
Photograph
ICE’s ENFORCE Integrated Database (EID) Enforcement Alien Removal Module
(EARM)
• Alien Number
• Name
• Marital Status
• Date of Birth
• Age
• Sex
• Country of Birth
• Country of Citizenship
• Date of Entry
• Class of Admission
• Social Security Number
• Federal Bureau of Investigation Number
• Case History
• Alerts
• Case Summary Comments
• Case Category
• Date of Encounter
• Encounter Information
• Custody Actions & Decisions
• Case Actions & Decisions
• Bonds
• Photograph
USCIS’s Enterprise Document Management System (EDMS)
All Information Contained in an Individual’s A-File, including, but not limited to:
•
Alien Number
•
Last Name
Privacy Impact Assessment
USCIS Verification Division, SAVE Program
Page 30
•
First Name
•
Middle Name
•
Date of Birth
•
Date Entered United States
•
Country of Birth
•
Class of Admission
•
Social Security Number
•
Form I-94 Number
•
Naturalization Information and Certificate
•
Photograph
•
Marriage Information and Certificate
Department of Justice Executive Office Immigration Review System (EOIR)
•
Name
•
Alien Number
•
Address
•
Nationality
•
Decision memoranda, investigatory reports and materials compiled for the
purpose of enforcing immigration laws, exhibits, transcripts, and other caserelated papers concerning aliens, alleged aliens or lawful permanent residents
brought into the administrative adjudication process
USCIS’s Marriage Fraud Amendment System (MFAS)
•
Individual’s
o
Name (Last, First, Middle)
o
Date of Birth
o
Country of Birth
o
Country of Citizenship
o
Class of Admission
o
Date of Admission
o
Alien Number
o
Receipt Number
o
Phone Number
o
Marriage Date and Place
Privacy Impact Assessment
USCIS Verification Division, SAVE Program
Page 31
•
•
•
Spouse’s
o
Name (Last, First, Middle)
o
Date of Birth
o
Country of Birth
o
Country of Citizenship
o
Class of Admission
o
Date of Admission
o
Alien Number
o
Receipt Number
o
Phone Number
o
Marriage Date and Place
o
Naturalization Date and Place
Children’s
o
Names (Last, First, Middle)
o
Date of Birth
o
Country of Birth
o
Class of Admission
o
Alien Number
Employer
o
Name
o
Address
o
Supervisor’s Name
o
Supervisor’s Phone Number
USCIS’s Microfilm Digitization Application System (MiDAS)
•
Name
•
Alien Number
•
Date of Birth
•
Citizenship Number
USCIS’s National File Tracking System (NFTS)
•
Alien Number
•
File Location
Privacy Impact Assessment
USCIS Verification Division, SAVE Program
Page 32
USCIS’s Refugees, Asylum, and Parole System (RAPS)
• Class of Admission
• Country of Birth
• Date of Birth
• Date of Entry
• Current Status
• Asylum Applicant Receipt Date
USCIS’s Reengineered Naturalization Applications Casework System (RNACS)
•
Alien Number
•
Last Name
•
First Name
•
Middle Name
•
Birth Date
•
Birth Country
•
Gender
•
Nationality
•
Naturalization Verification (Citizenship Naturalization Date/Time)
•
Naturalization Verification (Citizenship Certificate Identification ID)
•
Immigration Status (Immigration Status Code)
•
Address
Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE)’s Student and Exchange Visitor
Identification System (SEVIS)
•
Student and Exchange Visitor Identification Number (SEVIS ID)
•
Last Name
•
First Name
•
Middle Name
•
Date of Birth
•
Country of Birth
•
Class of Admission
•
I-94 Number
•
Date of Entry
•
Valid To Date
Privacy Impact Assessment
USCIS Verification Division, SAVE Program
Page 33
•
Social Security Number
•
Nationality
•
Gender
•
Student Status
•
Visa Code
•
Status Change Date
•
Port of Entry Code
•
Non Citizen Entry Date
•
Status Code
•
Program End Date
Quick Reference of SAVE Systems and their Use for Each Step of Verification
(Sorted by Commonly Used Name Acronym)
Initial Verification (also used during Second and Third Step Verification)
• Central Index System (CIS)
• USCIS’s Computer-Linked Application Information Management System
Version 3 (CLAIMS 3)
• USCIS’s Computer-Linked Application Information Management System
Version 4.0 (CLAIMS 4)
• USCIS’s Image Storage and Retrieval System (ISRS)
• USCIS’s Reengineered Naturalization Applications Casework System (RNACS)
• Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE)’s Student and Exchange Visitor
Identification System (SEVIS)
Second and Third Step Verification
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
United States Visitor and Immigrant Status Indicator Technology (US-VISIT)’s
Arrival Departure Information System (ADIS)
Department of State (DOS)’s Consular Consolidated Database (DOS-CCD)
ICE’s ENFORCE Integrated Database (EID) Enforcement Alien Removal
Module (EARM) USCIS’s Enterprise Document Management System (EDMS)
Department of Justice’s Executive Office of Immigration Review System (EOIR)
USCIS’s Marriage Fraud Amendment System (MFAS)
USCIS’s Microfilm Digitization Application System (MiDAS)
USCIS’s National File Tracking System (NFTS)
USCIS’s Refugees, Asylum, and Parole System (RAPS)
Privacy Impact Assessment
USCIS Verification Division, SAVE Program
Page 34
Appendix B
Description of Federal Government Databases
•
Arrival Departure Information System (ADIS): ADIS contains information on individuals
arriving and departing at United States ports of entry. This information includes biographic
information from passenger manifests and Forms I-94. SAVE uses this information to verify an
individual’s eligibility to be received public benefits, licenses, or credentials. Status Verifiers use
ADIS as part of the secondary immigration status verification for SAVE.
•
Central Index System (CIS):
CIS contains information on the status of 57 million
applicants/petitioners seeking immigration benefits to include: lawful permanent residents,
naturalized citizens, U.S. border crossers, aliens who illegally entered the U.S., aliens who have been
issued employment eligibility documents, individuals who petitioned for benefits on behalf of family
members, and other individuals subject to the provisions of the Immigration and Nationality Act
(INA). Status Verifiers will use CIS as part of the immigration status verification for SAVE.
•
Computer-Linked Application Management Information System 3.0 (CLAIMS 3):
CLAIMS 3 is a mainframe database centered major application that supports processing of USCIS
applications and petitions for various immigrant benefits (e.g. change of status, employment
eligibility, extension of stay, etc). It supports case management for and adjudication of all USCIS
benefits except naturalization and citizenship. Status Verifiers will use CLAIMS 3 as part of the
immigration status verification for SAVE.
•
Computer-Linked Application Information Management System Version 4.0 (CLAIMS 4):
CLAIMS 4 was developed by the Immigration and Naturalization Service (INS) to provide
immigration status verification information and to assist in the processing applications related to
naturalization or attaining U. S. citizenship. Status Verifiers will use CLAIMS 4 as part of the
secondary immigration status verification for SAVE.
•
Customer Profile Management System (CPMS): CPMS is the new repository of all digitized
biometric data in USCIS. It stores biographic and biometric data used for Forms I-131 (Application
for Travel Document); I-765 (Application for Employment Authorization); and I-551 (Alien
Registration Card or Green Card). Status Verifiers will use CPMS as part of the immigration status
verification for SAVE.
•
Department of State Consular Consolidated Database (DOS-CCD): DOS-CCD is used by
consular personnel as a resource for verifying prior visa issuances/refusals. It is also used by consular
management for statistical reporting. Status Verifiers will use DOS-CCD as part of the secondary
immigration status verification for the SAVE program. While the data from DOS-CCD will be used
for verification, it will not be stored in VIS.
Privacy Impact Assessment
USCIS Verification Division, SAVE Program
Page 35
•
ENFORCE Integrated Database (EID) Enforcement Alien Removal Module (EARM): EID
contains biographic and case information on aliens encountered and booked in Immigration and
Customs Enforcement (ICE) and other DHS component enforcement actions. Status Verifiers will
use EID as part of the secondary immigration status verification for the SAVE program. Information
from EID is required by the Status Verifiers to help determine whether an individual may not be
eligible for employment, government benefit, credential, or other reason for which they are having
their immigration status verified in the first place. DHS components collect the information in EID
during enforcement or administrative actions. Its use for verification of immigration status follows
because in all cases that the verification is performed, eligibility may be contingent on not having
been the subject of an enforcement action.
•
USCIS Enterprise Document System (EDMS): EDMS is a web-based system that allows users to
view, search, and add comments to digitized immigration records or A-files. EDMS can consolidate
digitized A-Files, while allowing users to display primary and secondary A-Files.
•
Executive Office Immigration Review System (EOIR): This Department of Justice system
contains information pertaining to aliens and alleged aliens brought into the immigration hearing
process, including certain aliens previously or subsequently admitted for lawful permanent residence.
Status Verifiers will use EOIR as part of the immigration status verification for the SAVE Program
when there is a question of immigration status. Information from EOIR is required by the Status
Verifiers in order to help determine whether an individual may be eligible for benefits, or other
reasons for which they are having their immigration status verified in the first place. Its use for
verification of immigration status follows because in all cases that the verification is performed,
eligibility may be contingent on not having been the subject of an enforcement action.
•
Marriage Fraud Amendment System (MFAS): The Marriage Fraud Amendment System (MFAS)
supports and maintains casework resulting from the Immigration Marriage Fraud Amendment Act
(MFA), which became law on November 10, 1986. MFAS allows users the ability to process and
control applications and petitions to grant Conditional Permanent Resident (CPR) status and
Permanent Resident (PR) status, and to identify and terminate the CPR status of aliens who acquired
this status fraudulently or who have not removed this status during the designated time period that the
law requires. Status Verifiers will use MFAS as part of the secondary immigration status verification
for the SAVE program. While the data from MFAS will be used for verification, it will not be stored
in VIS.
•
Microfilm Digitization Application System (MiDAS): MiDAS is an image-based search and
retrieval application of digitized alien records on individuals who entered the U.S. between 1906 and
1975 (50-60 million records). MiDAS allows the USCIS Office of Records to achieve a more
effective search result and improved customer service. When digitization of all files is complete, the
MiDAS database will hold over 80 million records including Master Index, Flex-O-Line, A-files,
Privacy Impact Assessment
USCIS Verification Division, SAVE Program
Page 36
Citizenship/Naturalization files (C-files, 129, 3904, OM, etc), file locator information cards, and other
historical records. Status Verifiers will use MiDAS as part of the immigration status verification for
SAVE.
•
National File Tracking System (NFTS): NFTS provides a centralized, automated, mechanism for
determining the location of a physical A-File and associated Receipt Files. NFTS supports the
Records requirement to track files at the local level, as well as the national level. It is designed to
support the Records mission and to provide efficient access to high-quality immigrant information by
maintaining an accurate file inventory. Status Verifiers will use NFTS as part of the immigration
status verification for the SAVE program in order to locate files.
•
Refugees, Asylum, and Parole System (RAPS): RAPS contains biographic information collected
for USCIS Form I-589, Asylum Application. Status Verifiers use RAPS as part of the secondary
immigration status verification for SAVE. Information from RAPS is required by the Status Verifiers
in order to help determine whether an individual is ineligible for employment. DHS components
collect the information in RAPS when an applicant for asylum completes a Form I-589. Its use for
verification of immigration status follows because asylum brings with it access to certain benefits.
•
Reengineered Naturalization Applications Casework Systems (RNACS): RNACS provides full
case tracking and management capability for naturalization casework including assignment of cases
to Case Control Offices (CCO); queuing of cases for appropriate actions, scheduling interviews and
oath ceremonies; editing transactions; reporting; and production of correspondence. Status Verifiers
will use RNACS as part of the immigration status verification for SAVE.
•
Student and Exchange Visitor Identification System (SEVIS): SEVIS maintains information on
non-immigrant students and exchange visitors (F, M, and J Visas) and their dependents, and also on
their associated schools and sponsors. SEVIS enables DHS to maintain current information and
facilitate oversight relating to nonimmigrant foreign students and exchange visitors during the course
of their stay in the U.S. SAVE accesses information from SEVIS and will use the information for
primary verification of immigration status for SAVE. Status Verifiers will use SEVIS as part of the
immigration status verification for SAVE.
Privacy Impact Assessment
USCIS Verification Division, SAVE Program
Page 37
Appendix C
Links to PIAs and SORNs of databases assessed by the SAVE Program
(Sorted by Commonly Used Name Acronyms)
•
United States Visitor and Immigrant Status Indicator Technology (US-VISIT)’s Arrival Departure
Information System (ADIS)
o PIA: http://www.dhs.gov/xlibrary/assets/privacy/privacy_pia_usvisit_adis_2007.pdf
o SORN: http://edocket.access.gpo.gov/2007/E7-16473.htm
•
USCIS’s Central Index System (CIS)
o PIA: http://www.dhs.gov/xlibrary/assets/privacy/privacy_pia_uscis_cis.pdf
o SORN: http://edocket.access.gpo.gov/2007/E7-375.htm
•
USCIS’s Computer-Linked Application Information Management System Version 3 (CLAIMS 3)
o PIA: http://www.dhs.gov/xlibrary/assets/privacy/privacy_pia_cis_claims3.pdf
o SORN: http://edocket.access.gpo.gov/2008/E8-22802.htm
•
USCIS’s Computer-Linked Application Information Management System Version 4.0 (CLAIMS 4)
o PIA: http://www.dhs.gov/xlibrary/assets/privacy/privacy_pia_cis_claims4.pdf
o SORN: http://edocket.access.gpo.gov/2008/E8-22802.htm
•
USCBP’s Nonimmigrant Information System and Border Crossing Information
o PIA: http://www.dhs.gov/xlibrary/assets/privacy/privacy_pia_cbp_borderops.pdf
o SORN: http://edocket.access.gpo.gov/2008/E8-17123.htm
•
Department of State (DOS)’s Consular Consolidated Database (DOS-CCD)
o PIA: http://www.state.gov/documents/organization/93772.pdf
o SORNs:
1) http://www.state.gov/documents/organization/102787.pdf
2) http://www.state.gov/documents/organization/102790.pdf
3) http://www.state.gov/documents/organization/102815.pdf
•
ICE’s ENFORCE Integrated Database (EID) Enforcement Alien Removal Module (EARM)
o PIA: http://www.dhs.gov/xlibrary/assets/privacy/privacy_pia_ice_eid.pdf
o SORN: http://edocket.access.gpo.gov/2010/2010-4099.htm
•
USCIS’s Enterprise Document Management System (EDMS)
o PIA: http://www.dhs.gov/xlibrary/assets/privacy/privacy_pia_uscis_iddmp.pdf
o SORN: http://edocket.access.gpo.gov/2007/E7-375.htm
Privacy Impact Assessment
USCIS Verification Division, SAVE Program
Page 38
•
Department of Justice’s Executive Office of Immigration Review System (EOIR)
o PIA: http://www.justice.gov/opcl/eoir_pia.pdf
o SORN: http://edocket.access.gpo.gov/2004/04-10564.htm
•
USCIS’s Image Storage and Retrieval System (ISRS)
o PIA: http://www.dhs.gov/xlibrary/assets/privacy/privacy_pia_cis_bss.pdf
o SORN: http://edocket.access.gpo.gov/2007/07-1643.htm
•
USCIS’s Marriage Fraud Amendment System (MFAS)
o SORN: http://edocket.access.gpo.gov/2007/E7-375.htm
•
USCIS’s Microfilm Digitization Application System (MiDAS)
o PIA: http://www.dhs.gov/xlibrary/assets/privacy/privacy_pia_cis_midas.pdf
o SORN: http://edocket.access.gpo.gov/2007/E7-375.htm
•
USCIS’s National File Tracking System (NFTS)
o PIA: Referenced in: 1) PIA titled: USCIS Person Centric Query Service Supporting
Immigration Status Verifiers of the USCIS National Security and Records Verification
Directorate/Verification Division
http://www.dhs.gov/xlibrary/assets/privacy/privacy_pia_cis_pcq_nsrv_update.pdf
and 2) Application Connection and Information Sharing Agreement between USCIS Enterprise
Service Bus (ESB) and USCIS NFTS System Owner
•
USCIS’s Refugees, Asylum, and Parole System (RAPS)
o PIA: http://www.dhs.gov/xlibrary/assets/privacy/privacy_pia_cis_rapsapss.pdf
o SORN: http://edocket.access.gpo.gov/2010/E9-31267.htm
•
USCIS’s Reengineered Naturalization Applications Casework System (RNACS)
o PIA: http://www.dhs.gov/xlibrary/assets/privacy/privacy_pia_cis_rnacs.pdf
o SORN: http://edocket.access.gpo.gov/2008/E8-22802.htm
•
Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE)’s Student and Exchange Visitor Identification
System (SEVIS)
o PIA: http://www.dhs.gov/xlibrary/assets/privacy/privacy_pia_sevis.pdf
o SORN: http://edocket.access.gpo.gov/2010/E9-31268.htm
| File Type | application/pdf |
| File Title | Systematic Alien Verification for Entitlements Program |
| Subject | The Verification Division of USCIS administers the SAVE Program, a fee-based intergovernmental initiative designed to help feder |
| Author | U.S. Department Of Homeland Security |
| File Modified | 2011-08-29 |
| File Created | 2011-08-29 |