Laboratory Response Network
OMB Control No. 0920-0850
Exp. Date: April 30, 2019
Request for Extension
February 12, 2019
Supporting Statement A
Contact:
Lee Samuel
Office of Policy and Planning
National Center for Preparedness, Detection, and Control of Infectious Diseases
Centers for Disease Control and Prevention
1600 Clifton Road, N.E., MS C-12
Atlanta, Georgia 30333
Phone: (404) 718-1616
Email: [email protected]
Table of Contents
1. Circumstances Making the Collection of Information Necessary 3
2. Purpose and Use of Information Collection 5
3. Use of Improved Information Technology and Burden Reduction 6
4. Efforts to Identify Duplication and Use of Similar Information 6
5. Impact on Small Businesses or Other Small Entities 6
6. Consequences of Collecting the Information Less Frequently 7
7. Special Circumstances Relating to the Guidelines of 5 CFR 1320.5 7
8. Comments in Response to the Federal Register Notice and Efforts to Consult Outside the Agency 7
9. Explanations of Any Payment or Gift to Respondents 9
10. Protection of the Privacy and Confidentiality of Information Provided to Respondents 9
11. Institutional Review Board (IRB) and Justification for Sensitive Questions 11
12. Estimates of Annualized Burden Hours and Costs 11
13. Estimates of Other Total Annual Cost Burden to Respondents or Record Keepers 13
14. Annualized Cost to the Government 13
15. Explanation for Program Changes or Adjustments 13
16. Plans for Tabulation and Publication and Project Time Schedule 14
17. Reason(s) Display of OMB Expiration Date is Inappropriate 14
18. Exceptions for Certification for Paperwork Reduction Act Submissions 14
The goal of the study is to identify gaps in preparedness for
biological threats and emerging infectious diseases.
The data will be used to develop strategies, policies, and
operating procedures for responding to biological threat and
emerging infectious disease emergencies.
The LRN website, Results Messenger data exchange application, and
Special Data Calls Questionnaires are methods used to collect data
from member laboratories. Questionnaires may be distributed via
broadcast email that asks respondents to send information via email
to the LRN help desk or through online tools (i.e. Survey Monkey)
which require respondents to go to web link and answer a series of
questions.
The subpopulation to be studied:
LRN members, reference, and national laboratories.
Data will be analyzed using tables created in word documents,
Survey Monkey, Excel, SAS, or other electronic data analysis tools.
CDC is requesting a 3 year extension without change to the data collection plan or tools. The only change is a decrease in the estimated burden from 2,382,300 to 2,064,660 annual hours. The decrease is due to a decrease in the number of LRN member laboratories from 150 to 130 laboratories. This decrease began to occur in 2014 after minimum requirements for LRN network membership were instituted. In addition, some laboratories experienced reduced funding, which made them unable to support LRN activities.
The Laboratory Response Network (LRN) was established by the Department of Health and Human Services (HHS), Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC) in accordance with Presidential Decision Directive 39 (Attachment 1a), which outlined national anti-terrorism policies and assigned specific missions to federal departments and agencies. The LRN’s mission is to maintain an integrated national and international network of laboratories that can respond to suspected acts of biological, chemical, or radiological terrorism and other public health emergencies.
Federal, state and local public health laboratories join the LRN voluntarily. When laboratories join, they assume specific responsibilities and are required to provide information to the LRN Program Office at CDC. Each laboratory must submit and maintain complete information regarding the testing capabilities of the laboratory. Biennially, laboratories are required to review, verify and update their testing capability information. This information is needed so that the LRN Program Office can determine the ability of the Network to respond to a biological or chemical terrorism event. The sensitivity of all information associated with the LRN requires that CDC obtain personal information about all individuals accessing the LRN Website. Since CDC must be able to contact all laboratory personnel during an event, each laboratory staff member who obtains access to the restricted LRN Website must provide his or her contact information to the LRN Program Office.
As a requirement of membership, LRN laboratories must report all biological and chemical testing results to the LRN Program using a CDC developed software tool called the LRN Results Messenger, or through electronic laboratory reporting referred to Data Integration. CDC supplies this software to LRN laboratories at no charge. This information obtained from LRN laboratories is essential for surveillance of anomalies, to support response to an event that may involve multiple agencies, and to manage limited resources.
LRN laboratories are also required to participate in Proficiency Testing Challenges or Validation Studies and report their results to CDC. LRN laboratories participate in multiple Proficiency Testing Challenges, Exercises and/or Validation Studies every year. These activities consist of 5-500 simulated samples provided by CDC. These challenges are necessary to verify the testing capability of the LRN laboratories. Because biological or chemical agents perceived to be of bioterrorism concern can occur rarely, some LRN laboratories may not be maintaining proficiency in certain testing methods as a result of day-to-day testing. Thus, simulated samples are distributed to ensure proficiency across LRN member laboratories. LRN laboratories also enter the results of these simulated samples into the LRN Results Messenger or through Data Integration for evaluation by CDC.
During a surge event resulting from a bioterrorism or chemical terrorism attack, or during an emerging infectious disease outbreak, LRN Laboratories must submit all testing results using LRN Results Messenger or through Data Integration. CDC uses these results in order to track the progression of a bioterrorism event, responds in the most efficient and effective way possible, and shares this data with other Federal partners involved in the response.
Data is collected via two primary avenues, the program LRN Results Messenger or through Data Integration and the LRN Website. Laboratories belonging to the Laboratory Response Network utilize the CDC developed software tool LRN Results Messenger to submit testing results to CDC. Data Integration is an effort parallel to the LRN Results Messenger which will ultimately allow laboratories to submit data to CDC using their own data collection systems. Results include details about the type and source of samples as well as the tests performed and the numerical and empirical results of those tests. The LRN Website is used by laboratories to provide their complete testing capabilities to CDC. All individuals who use the LRN Website must provide their contact information to the LRN Program Office during registration.
An LRN laboratory must provide its testing capabilities, physical and shipping addresses, United States Department of Agriculture (USDA) and Select Agent Permits, and specified responsible individuals’ names, phone numbers and email addresses. After registering with the LRN Website, a user must provide his/her first and last name, work phone number, alternate phone number, email address, and month and day of birth.
During reporting of results, sample details, tests performed, results obtained, and conclusions of tests are required.
Accomplishments during the last three years include the requalification of laboratories. The requalification occurred between November 7, 2016 and December 12, 2016. We had 130 domestic LRN labs tasked with completing the requalification. The LRN website has remained the same, and has only undergone routine maintenance since 2015.
CDC also conducted LRN proficiency testing (PT). The purpose of PT is to simulate real samples for labs that would not have regularly performed some of the LRN procedures. Having the ability to conduct LRN PTs has led to improved laboratory performance and better preparedness. In FY16 and FY17, the PT passing rate was 93%. The PT passing rate improved to 97% in FY18. This data collection is authorized under the Public Health Service Act, (42 USC 241) Section 301. A copy is included in the attachments (Attachment 1b).
The information collected in the Biennial Requalification is utilized on a daily basis by both CDC and LRN member laboratories. Details of the laboratories’ testing capabilities are an indication of the capability of the network as a whole. CDC uses the testing capabilities entered by laboratories to determine participation in LRN Proficiency Testing challenges. The responsible parties’ contact information provided in the Biennial Requalification ensures up-to-date contact information for accurate and efficient communications between CDC and the laboratories. The shipping addresses are necessary for the shipment of PT Challenges and the shipment of reagents ordered via the LRN Website. The physical address of the LRN laboratories is utilized for mapping laboratories in a Lab Referral Directory.
LRN member laboratories also have access to the testing capability information entered during the Biennial Requalification and can use this information to search for a laboratory with a certain testing capability within a certain area relative to their location in order to refer samples for additional testing.
General Surveillance Testing Results are collected constantly via the LRN Results Messenger or through Data Integration so CDC can evaluate and track potential events and outbreaks on a continual basis. General Testing Results also provide CDC with data about workload and affectivity of the LRN when reviewed over periods of time or reviewed retrospectively.
LRN laboratories are required to submit Proficiency Testing or Validation Testing Results via the LRN Results Messenger or through Data Integration approximately once a month. The results of this testing provide both the LRN Laboratories and CDC with information about actual capability and preparedness of the LRN. Performance during Proficiency Testing Challenges can influence a laboratory’s status as an LRN laboratory. Because biological and chemical terrorism events have been rare, Proficiency Testing Challenges and Validation Testing ensure the effectiveness of the LRN.
Surge Event Testing Results are those results entered by LRN laboratories via the LRN Results Messenger or through Data Integration during an actual biological or chemical terrorism event or a naturally occurring outbreak. The quantity of samples for which results would be reported have the potential to be drastically larger than the number reported during General Surveillance. Data must be reported during an event in order for CDC and HHS to track the progression of an event or outbreak. If CDC did not have this reporting, CDC would not be able to efficiently and effectively allot its limited resources.
During the two years between Biennial Requalification, CDC may need to obtain additional information from the LRN laboratories in better understand or quantify the network’s preparedness.
Information in Identifiable Form categories included in this data collection are the names, date and month of birth, phone numbers, and email addresses of laboratory personnel. The date and month of birth are collected as a security precaution. If a user forgets his or her password to log in to the LRN Website, he or she is prompted to verify their identity by entering his or her login (User ID), first and last name, birth date (month and day, NOT year), and email associated with account before the password is reset. This information is not shared with any other party. It is necessary to have contact information for laboratory personnel with access to the LRN Website because CDC needs to be able to contact all LRN members during an event or outbreak. All LRN laboratories are able to view the contact information of each member laboratory director so that laboratories can refer samples to one another. Shipping addresses are available via the LRN Referral Directory. This information may be shared internally at CDC during events or with Subject Matter Experts during Proficiency Testing Challenges.
Biennial Requalification is conducted using the LRN Website which can be accessed using any web browser. All information is reported electronically. General Surveillance Testing, Proficiency Testing/Validation Testing, and Surge Event Testing Results are submitted using the LRN Results Messenger program or through Data Integration. Thus, 100% of information is collected electronically. CDC only collects the minimum information necessary for the purposes of maintaining the LRN.
There is no similar data collection conducted either within the Federal government or privately.
There is no impact on small businesses or other small entities. Respondents are other Federal, state, or local governmental laboratories. The data requested has been held to the absolute minimum required for its intended use.
Biennial Requalification is required in order ensure laboratory capability and contact information is accurate and up-to-date. General Surveillance Testing Results must be submitted on a continual basis to CDC to ensure adequate surveillance. Proficiency Testing/Validation Testing is conducted approximately every month in order to assure competency of the laboratories. This testing also helps to confirm preparedness of the network and identify potential testing issues. Surge Event Testing Results are submitted during a biological or chemical terrorism event or natural outbreak, the occurrence of which is unpredictable. CDC would use these results to track the progression and breadth of the event.
An LRN laboratory is required to report testing results to CDC whenever it tests a suspected sample using reagents and procedures provided by the LRN Program Office. Since such suspect samples may be received by a laboratory on a daily basis or yearly basis, the frequency of submitting General Surveillance Testing Results may exceed a quarterly basis. CDC requires the submission of all results for surveillance purposes. Negative results could still indicate attempted acts of biological or chemical terrorism, therefore the collection of even negative results is instrumental in maintaining national security. Proficiency Testing/Validation Testing is required on a monthly basis to verify the proficiency and preparedness of the LRN. Proficiency Testing requires this frequency because of the number of agents of concern for biological or chemical terrorism. These testing results are submitted to CDC so that weaknesses can be identified and addressed.
A. A 60-day Federal Register Notice was published in the Federal Register on October 4, 2018 (Vol. 83, No. 193, page 50096 (Attachment 2a). One non-substantive public comment was received (Attachment 2b).
B. The Association of Public Health Laboratories (APHL) was the CDC’s primary source of input in 1999 during the creation of the biological division of the LRN. APHL represented the stakeholders in the LRN since a majority of the LRN laboratories are public health laboratories belonging to APHL. Feedback is provided by APHL and other LRN partners during annual partnership meetings. An LRN National Meeting is held periodically to which all LRN members are invited to attend. Quarterly, a conference call is held by the LRN Program Office during which defined topics are presented by the Program Office and questions can be proposed by listening LRN members. Additionally, for the Biological division of the LRN, a working group composed of representatives from a variety of laboratories within the LRN meets at least three times a year in order for the LRN Program Office to obtain feedback on predefined issues as well as on the LRN in general. LRN members are also encouraged to provide feedback and pose questions to the LRN Helpdesk at any time.
LRN Founding Partners (Meets two times per year)
Association of Public Health Laboratories
8515
Georgia Avenue, Suite 700
Silver Spring, MD 20910
Contact: Chris Mangal, 240.485.2769, [email protected]
Federal Bureau of Investigation
2501
Investigation Parkway
Quantico, VA 22135
Contact: Doug
Anders, Phone: 703-632-7919, [email protected]
Department of Defense
US Army Medical Command
Fort Sam Houston, Texas 78234
Contact: Bill Nauschuetz, PhD LTC (ret), (210) 221-3755, [email protected]
Operational Working Group (This group meets 3 times a year, dates vary with member schedules)
Members:
Ms. Courtney Demontigny
Laboratory Technician, St. Paul, Minnesota State Public Health Laboratory
(651)201-5576; [email protected]
Patricia Blevins
Bioterrorism Coordinator, San Antonio, Texas Public Health Laboratory
(210)207-5883; [email protected]
Mr. Michael Perry
Laboratory Technician, Albany, New York State Public Health Laboratory
(518)402-4455; [email protected] |
|
Erik Reisdorf
Laboratory Technician, Madison, Wisconsin State Public Health Laboratory
(608)262-3185; [email protected]
Mr. William Dorman
Bioterrorism Coordinator, Ft Detrick, Maryland USAMRIID
(301)619-3318; [email protected] |
|
Mrs. Remedios Gose
Laboratory Technician; Hawaii State Public Health Laboratory
(808)453-5984;
|
Chris Mangal, MPH
Director, Public Health Preparedness and Response, Association of Public Health Laboratories
(240)485-2769
Tyler Wolford, MS
Senior Specialist, Association of Public Health Laboratories
(240)485-2775
Latoya Griffen-Thomas
Virginia Department of Consolidated Laboratories
(804)648-4480 ext. 281
Cary Rue
Scientific Response Unit, Federal Bureau of Investigations Laboratory
(703)632-7902
There are no gifts to respondents.
This information collection request has been reviewed by the National Center for Emerging and Zoonotic Infectious Diseases who has determined that the Privacy Act does apply since there is identifiable information being used to retrieve affiliated records. A Privacy Impact Assessment is included with this submission (Attachment 5).
Information in Identifiable Form categories included in this data collection are the names, date and month of birth, phone numbers, and email addresses of laboratory personnel. The date and month of birth are collected as a security precaution. If a user forgets his or her password to log in to the LRN Website, he or she is prompted to verify their identity by entering his or her login (User ID), first and last name, birth date (month and day, NOT year), and email associated with account before the password is reset. This information is not shared with any other party. It is necessary to have contact information for laboratory personnel with access to the LRN Website because CDC needs to be able to contact all LRN members during an event or outbreak. All LRN laboratories are able to view the contact information of each member laboratory director so that laboratories can refer samples to one another. Shipping addresses are available via the LRN Referral Directory. This information may be shared internally at CDC during events or with Subject Matter Experts during Proficiency Testing Challenges.”
Individuals responding to this request are doing so as part of their job. Although participation in the Laboratory Response Network is voluntary, member laboratories are required to provide information as a condition of membership. Stringent safeguards are in place to ensure the security of a respondent’s personal identifying information including authorized users, physical safeguards, and procedural safeguards. Access to the CDC facility where the mainframe computer is located is controlled by a cardkey system. Access to the computer room is controlled by a cardkey and security code (numeric code) system. Access to the data entry area is also controlled by a cardkey system. Guard service in buildings provides personnel screening of visitors. The computer room is protected by an automatic sprinkler system, numerous automatic sensors are installed, and a proper mix of portable fire extinguishers is located throughout the computer room. Computer files are backed up on a routine basis.
Data is collected via two primary avenues, the program LRN Results Messenger or through Data Integration, and the LRN Website. Laboratories belonging to the Laboratory Response Network utilize the CDC developed software tool LRN Results Messenger or Data Integration to submit testing results to CDC. Data Integration is an effort parallel to the LRN Results Messenger which will ultimately allow laboratories to submit data to CDC using their own data collection systems. Results include details about the type and source of samples as well as the tests performed and the numerical and empirical results of those tests. The LRN Website is used by laboratories to provide their complete testing capabilities to CDC. All individuals who use the LRN Website must provide their contact information to the LRN Program Office during registration.
An LRN laboratory must provide its testing capabilities, physical and shipping addresses, United States Department of Agriculture (USDA) and Select Agent Permits, and specified responsible individuals’ names, phone numbers and email addresses. After registering with the LRN Website, a user must provide his/her first and last name, work phone number, alternate phone number, email address, and month and day of birth.
During reporting of results, sample details, tests performed, results obtained, and conclusions of tests are required.
The LRN Website is not directed at children less than 13 years of age.
The LRN Website, where all laboratory information is entered and stored, is certified by VeriSign SSL Certification. Access to website is limited to LRN members, partners and CDC staff and is password protected. All passwords are stored and encrypted. The LRN website establishes an encrypted link between a web server and a browser. In addition, many security checks have been implemented which would prevent Structured Query Language (SQL) database injection. SQL injection is a code injection technique that exploits a security vulnerability occurring in the database layer of an application. The system also prevents hackings such as cross site scripting (Cross-site scripting (XSS) is a type of computer security vulnerability typically found in web applications which enable malicious attackers to inject client-side script into web pages viewed by other users).
The LRN Results Messenger/Viewer where all laboratory test results are stored is maintained in a database behind CDC firewall. LRN Results Messenger/Viewer, like all Federal systems, has undergone an extensive Certification and Accreditation security review process by the Office of the Chief Information Security Officer (OCISO)/CDC to ensure that any vulnerabilities to electronic threats are mitigated appropriately to limit unauthorized access.
Access to the LRN Results Viewer is strictly limited to only those persons authorized by the LRN Program Office. These persons must obtain a special electronic certificate with dual protection passwords that is used for authentication and access to the Results Viewer. Within authorized user access, data is further restricted by the role of the user. LRN Program Office select staff are authorized access to all data. LRN laboratory users can only access data from their laboratory and are restricted from access to all other data in the Results Viewer. The submitting lab has the option to share results with other facilities of their choice.
Requesting access to the LRN Website and becoming an LRN Member is a voluntary act. No individual is mandated to join the LRN. By requesting access to the LRN Website and agreeing to the stipulations of being an LRN Member, an individual or laboratory is voluntarily providing all requested information to the LRN Program Office. Data collected on the website is accessed by the LRN Program Office at CDC and used to characterize response capabilities of the network for planning purposes and responding to congressional inquiries. Laboratory test results collected by the LRN Results Messenger or Data Integration is accessed by LRN Program office and provided as needed to CDC medical epidemiologists and subject matter experts for outbreak response with consent of submitting laboratory.
Institutional Review Board (IRB)
This submission has been reviewed by IRB and determined to be exempt (Attachment 4).
Justification for Sensitive Questions
LRN does not have questions of sensitive nature (i.e. individual identifiers such as race, medical history or patient information related to laboratory samples).
A. Estimated Annualized Burden Hours
The estimated annualized burden hours were determined as follows. There are 130 laboratories in the LRN, a decrease of 20 since the last submission. The decrease is due to a decrease in the number of LRN member laboratories from 150 to 130 laboratories. This decrease began to occur in 2014 after minimum requirements for LRN network membership were instituted. In addition, some laboratories experienced reduced funding, which made them unable to support LRN activities.
A “respondent” refers to a single LRN Laboratory. Since the Biennial Requalification is conducted every other year, the average number of Responses per Respondent is one. The Average Burden per Response for the Biennial Requalification was determined to be two hours through firsthand experience. The data on hand was utilized in estimating the Average Number of Responses per Respondent for the General Surveillance Testing Results. The Average Burden per Response was determined by reviewing the testing protocols utilized by the laboratories to determine the average length of time required to complete testing on a sample. The number of samples sent per Proficiency Testing/Validation Testing challenge varies significantly, an average of 5 was chosen since Proficiency Testing challenges generally include 5 samples. The length of time given to complete a Proficiency Testing/Validation Testing challenge also varies significantly, an average of 6 business days, or 56 hours was approximated as the burden time per sample.
The Average Number of Responses per Respondent for Surge Event Testing Results is based on the assumptions that a large scale event is occurring on a national level so all LRN Laboratories are being utilized to their capacity. Similar to the Average Burden per Response for General Surveillance Testing Results, the Average Burden per Response for Surge Event Testing Results is also extrapolated from the testing protocols utilized by laboratories. The number of samples tested during a response to a possible event could range from 10,000 to more than 500,000 samples, depending on the length and breadth of the event. Since there is potentially a large range in the number of samples for a surge event, CDC has estimated the annualized burden for this project to be 2,064,660 hours, a decrease of 317,640 hours per year.
Respondents |
Forms
|
Number of Respondents |
Average Number of Responses per Respondent |
Average Burden Per Response (hours) |
Total Burden Hours |
Public Health Laboratories
|
Biennial Requalification |
130 |
1 |
2 |
260 |
General Surveillance Testing Results |
130 |
25 |
24 |
78,000 |
|
Proficiency Testing/ Validation Testing Results |
130 |
5 |
56 |
36,400 |
|
Surge Event Testing Results |
130 |
625 |
24 |
1,950,000 |
|
Total |
2,064,660 |
||||
Estimated Annualized Costs
Our prior submission from 2016 had a base rate of $29.32. Going forward we will be basing the wage schedule on a GS 11 Step 1 2018 Schedule with a 1% general and 19.29% locality percent. The new rate will be $30.59 which is a more accurate portrayal of cost.
The total estimated annual cost burden is $63,157,949.40, a decrease of $6,691,086.60.
Respondents |
Form Name |
Total Burden Hours |
Hourly Wage Rate |
Total Respondent Costs |
Public Health Laboratorians |
Biennial Requalification |
260 |
$30.59 |
$7,953.40 |
General Surveillance Testing Results |
78,000 |
$30.59 |
$2,386,020.00 |
|
Proficiency Testing/ Validation Testing Results |
36,400 |
$30.59 |
$1,113,476 |
|
Surge Event Testing Results |
1,950,000 |
$30.59 |
$59,650,500 |
|
Total |
|
$63,157,949.40 |
||
None.
Expense Type |
Expense Explanation |
Cost (dollars) |
Direct Cost to the Federal Government |
CDC Health Scientist |
126,147 |
Contractor and other expenses |
Results Messenger/Data Integration. LRN laboratory results reporting and informatics services. . |
3,600,000 |
LRN Website development and maintenance |
450,000 |
|
LRN PT Program – sample production and shipment |
250,000 |
|
Total |
4,426,147 |
|
This is a request for an extension of an existing data collection. We have updated this submission to include our accomplishments during the last 3 years and the wage rates.
The number of respondents has declined from 150 to 130 with an accompanying decrease in burden from 2,382,300 annual hours to 2,064,660.
The decrease is due to a decrease in the number of LRN member laboratories from 150 to 130 laboratories. This decrease began to occur in 2014 after minimum requirements for LRN network membership were instituted. In addition, some laboratories experienced reduced funding, which made them unable to support LRN activities.
There are no plans for publication of this data. The data is used for surveillance of possible terror events and public health emergences and to assess competencies of LRN member laboratories.
Not Applicable.
There are no exceptions to the certification.
1a. Presidential Decision Directive 39
1b. Public Health Service Act (42 USC 241) Section 301
2a. 60 Day Federal Register Notice
2b. Public comment
3. LRN Data Elements
a. Biennial Requalification Data Elements
b. General Surveillance Testing Data Elements
c. Proficiency Testing/Validation Testing Results Data Elements
d. Surge Event Testing Results Data Elements
e. Screen Shots for Biennial Requalification
4. IRB Determination
5. Privacy Impact Assessment
| File Type | application/msword |
| File Title | Foreign Quarantine Regulations (42 CFR 71) |
| Author | aeo1 |
| Last Modified By | SYSTEM |
| File Modified | 2019-03-07 |
| File Created | 2019-03-07 |